After three years of ridicule, Maddie makes her neighbor Levi promise to be her boyfriend through out highschool. Through the process of becoming a couple, Levi and Maddie became immensely popular, putting another opportunity on the table: prom king and queen. But when Maddie falls off the top of the cheerleading pyramid, and Levi begins to fall for another girl, she realizes she might've put all her eggs in one basket.