They've lived seven years without their children. Their on again, off again marriage has finally worked itself out, and they feel as if things are starting to become a new kind of normal. Suddenly, Faith begins to feel as if maybe they haven't lost all of their children, there might still be one out there. Tim doubts Faith's suspicions, thinking that Faith is just feeling a bit uneasy with their new, calmer lifestyle. Is Faith right, or is she losing her mind? After Tim and Faith discover Audrey's state, Faith learns that Tim isn't exactly the man she thought he was. Tim's reputation, marred by the past, is put at stake when people from the past begin to show up and tell Faith the truth about Tim.
Years after setting down different paths, a chance encounter causes the two formerly star-crossed lovers to return to the stage together. When the song is over, everything they thought quickly begins to shatter around them, leading Tim and Faith to reconsider their decisions in the past.