Stella loved Louis when they were younger but when a conflict split them apart, they never made and effort to reconnect. Now he is famous, and Stella can only watch as the boy she knew, and shared secrets with, rises in fame. She hides that she ever knew him for 5 years, but all that changes in a game of Truth or Dare. She is forced to reveal her relationship with the singer, and then to meet up with him and eventually date him again. Stella accepts- after all what harm could it do?- but after a while, old feelings are stirred up, new ones are aroused, and through an emotional roller coaster, Stella starts to wonder why she ever took that Double Dare.