Should've Been Mine (Laurens x Angelica) {COMPLETE}

Reads 38,919
Votes 1,297
Parts 39
Time 1h 3m

Reads 38,919
Votes 1,297
Parts 39
Time 1h 3m

John Laurens and Angelica Schuyler both meet at their current unrequited love's (Alexander Hamilton) wedding. However, their similarities don't stop there. 

COMPLETED!!!!!!!!!All Rights Reserved

Table of contents

39 parts

#678hamliza

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Helpless | A Modern Hamliza Story by hamlizaxxx

Eliza Schuyler and Alexander Hamilton met in college and fell in love. They try for a baby soon after marriage, but in their second year of marriage, they receive life changing news. #1 in hamliza 2/24/21

To London and Back (Completed) by vintagecassette

Angelica Schuyler is living in modern NYC with a rich father, wonderful sisters, and a hell of a crush. Her father soon whisks them off to London, and Angelica is forced to go to college in New York and pursue a growing romance or stay with her younger sisters in London. Updates are random. Started March 27th, 2017.

I Don't Like Your GF (Lams//Modern AU) ✖ by writingtheother51rn

Two happily married men. Alexander Hamilton and John Laurens. Accept- they're kinda dating and fucking on the side. Sure, there's love between the two of them but they're in intense politics, if someone were to catch on their careers would be over. They think their wives are completely oblivious- and they are-well... At least one of them isn't...

Love is Blind//Sequel to We're Forbidden by __John_Laurens__

Alexander Hamilton and John Laurens are in love during a time when their relationship could get them killed.

hey, lover! [lams//college au] // completed by mcswoonfor_mcdoon

"John Laurens' life was a mess. He knew this, and not much else." John didn't expect to fall in love at first sight, but college is full of surprises. *** this is a rewrite of one of my stories, "Oh, Lover Boy." pls don't read that one it is horrible.

Opposites Attract {Hamliza Fanfic} by intoxicatedapplee

Alexander Hamilton is a real asshole. Ever since he met John Laurens, Lafayette and Hercules Mulligan, he's become a bad boy. And with Thomas Jefferson constantly trying to threaten him all the time, makes the situation even worse. He thinks that Love is fake. Perhaps someone will change his mind? Elizabeth Schuyler, Usually called Eliza, Liz or Betsey. She is the good girl in this story. She doesn't like fighting, arguing or killing. Duh, she is a cinnamon roll. Eliza thinks that her sisters are much more prettier and talented. Maybe someone will make her think differently. What happens when the two cross paths. Will they fall in love with each other or will they just become friends, or even enemies??? {THIS HAS SWEARING. Please don't read if not comfortable with that...}

The Story of Tonight (A Lams Fic) by HamilGorl

John Laurens and his friends go to Columbia University and meet Alex Hamilton, little did they know their lives would be intertwined forever... (Very basic, Hamilton College modern AU, told from multiple POVs but centers around John and Alex's relationship)

Satisfied || A Hamgelica Fanfic by live_fully

"But when I fantasise at night it's Alexander's eyes, As I romanticise what might have been if I hadn't sized him up so quickly ..." And until then, I will never be satisfied. ::: It was clear from the beginning that Eliza was madly in love with Alexander Hamilton. But what if the story was different? What if Eliza didn't get her happy ending? What if Angelica did? ::: #1 in angelicaschuyler - 15/5/18 *(This is appropriate for all ages)*

Undercover - A Hamliza Story Completed ✅ by howcanisaynotothis

Elizabeth Schuyler is happily married to her husband Alexander. She notices changes in his behavior. So, she and her sister go undercover to discover what he's been doing when he's not home.

You Look Perfect (lams) by pansmexual_lams

Alexander Hamilton is a 16 year old bisexual, who's recently been adopted from the Caribbean. John Laurens is a 17 year old openly gay teen but who still has to hide his true self from his father. They both have scars. They both have been broken. What happens when they fall in love? (Edit: this story starts off bad, seeing as this was my first story but it gets increasingly better fast so pls stick with it) ⚠️TW's are at the top of the chapters⚠️ Highest rankings so far: #2 in Lams #1 in Mullette #1 in herc #6 in alexanderhamilton #7 in jeffmads #1 in Laurens #4 in Angelica

Helpless | A Modern Hamliza Story

Eliza Schuyler and Alexander Hamilton met in college and fell in love. They try for a baby soon after marriage, but in their second year of marriage, they receive life changing news. #1 in hamliza 2/24/21

More details