It has been six years since Slenderman has hired a new Proxy. And when he does, it disappoints the other Proxies greatly. How could this small, twitchy boy be a new Proxy? However, Toby is quick to prove himself to the other Proxies when Masky attempts to fight him to figure out why Slender chose him. Toby can't feel any pain. Nothing will stop him until his opponent is dead, or cute. Toby is quick to latch onto Tim since he's the only kind human in the Proxy clan. Tim doesn't want to admit it but he now sees Toby as a friend, maybe even more. However, these feelings are quickly interrupted when Tim gets a visit from his past and begins a long journey toward completing the job he never got done. And in a twist of irony, this brings Tim and Toby closer than either is willing to admit. Hoodie's there too. But he's just there to kill some people, not for the gay stuff.