Jeff x Male!Reader

Jeff x Male!Reader

shellyandshoal123

Reads 50,200
Votes 1,260
Parts 18

Ongoing1h 20m

Last published Mon, May 18, 2026

creepypasta jeffthekiller jeffxmalereader jeffxreader malereader

(Y/N). Young. Dumb. Legally blind. And that's it. Oh, and a serial killer thinks he's cute. There's that too.

All Rights Reserved

Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.

You may also like

Fatal Insanity (Jeff The Killer X Reader)
You and Jeff had been best friends and neighbors since you were both little and basically grew up together, until you almost turned thirteen and moved away to a new town. Crying inside knowing you would never see him again, but that all changed a year later, when you had found out that him and his family were moving into the same town and neighborhood as you. Overall, you were happy that you could hang out with your best friend again, like old times. Though, you never expected to have feelings for him since he was your best friend, but one thing that took a turn for the worst, and the one thing that never left you the same, was that your best friend..... ~turned into a killer~
Complete
The Rose Of Death ~~ Jeff The Killer X Gender Neutral Reader
Jeff the killer X gender neutral reader This book takes place in the early 2000's Y/n finds themselves in a very deathly situation, in a situation with a dangerous serial killer who is obsessed with them. How will this story end, will you have a good or a bad end to the story Reader is referred by they/them pronounce in this book
Complete
[OLD] Sympathy's Downfall (JTK x Reader)
You get caught up in a storm of chaos that involves a particular murderer. This murderer's behavior reminds you of a friend you lost a year ago. So tell me, can you sympathize with a serial killer? (If you know me from Quotev, hello, yes I am the original author)
Complete
Partners In Crime (Jeff X Reader
Okay. Im doing a Jeff x Reader. Because I'm bored. And I need serious help Like I really need help Please. Anyways, Jeff the Killer x Reader I hope you enjoy. I also hope you don't mind being a murderer. Or possibly another creepypasta. I need some help rn
Complete
Jeff The Killer x reader
Your a normal girl but then you see him.............again. (Jeff x reader!) (Ben x readers daughter!) {WARNING!!! Very Crappy}
Complete
The Game [Jeff The Killer x Reader]
I wasn't sure what love was. Everyone spoke of it like a legend. Something sacred that you'd capture if you were lucky. The man I had let take my heart wanted to carve it out of my chest as proof. I tried to forget feeling that way about him. I tried to figure out why I could ever love someone like him. He terrified me but at moments it was like a roller coaster. Up and down I would try to hold on for dear life. I liked how he made me feel alive, knowing he was always there made me feel less alone. He had done something to me I wish he hadn't. When he hurt me every time seemed to get worse and worse but at some point, I had gotten addicted to it. I wanted him to drown me in his hate and make me beg. I knew it was wrong, toxic and unhealthy. The way I felt was bad the only question was does he feel it too? Does he know this is wrong and how bad I want him? I looked up to him, he brushed the hair out of my face gently, eyes locked to mine. I didn't care if he felt the same, it was too late for me. I was intoxicated. His lips brushed softly against mine, teasing my heart strings. He slipped passed my mouth and whispered with that low gruff voice of his that made me melt, "Let's play a game..." WARNING: THIS IS NOT YOUR ORDINARY FANFICTION. VIEWER DISCRETION IS ADVISED. MATERIAL MAY NOT BE SUITABLE FOR SOME. JEFF ISN'T NICE. YOU'VE BEEN WARNED. 1st POV Jeff the killer Fanfic Give it a chance T~T
Complete
Knives and Hearts - Creepypasta Jeff the Killer X Reader
The infamous crazed killer has been wreaking havoc, killing all across town and tonight it's your turn. But will you be too interesting to kill? More content from me besides what's on here? -My DeviantArt or FF.net. @ Linklove93. Also it is complete. There is a mature scene in a later chapter. Art belongs to it's respective artist, I take no credit for it.
Complete
Stay With Me ~ Yandere Masky x Reader ~
"Sweetheart," His voice was low, an attempt at comforting you as he held your face. You turned away, flinching as his thumb ran circles on your cheek. "I'm not going to ever hurt you..." His voice was soft, but you knew better. God, you knew better. "I'm keeping you safe..." he murmured. "You make me feel ... like I'm getting better." "You'll be safe if you just stay with me..." Authors note: Chapters are written in long format, meaning this is going to read far more as a book. I update as much as I have time for, but in saying this, lots of editing and re-writing occurs and takes time. I take care in this story as it means a lot to me as a passion project and want it to be something I can be proud of. Thank you for understanding and I hope you all can enjoy this as much as I love writing it! -M

Fatal Insanity (Jeff The Killer X Reader)

You and Jeff had been best friends and neighbors since you were both little and basically grew up together, until you almost turned thirteen and moved away to a new town. Crying inside knowing you would never see him again, but that all changed a year later, when you had found out that him and his family were moving into the same town and neighborhood as you. Overall, you were happy that you could hang out with your best friend again, like old times. Though, you never expected to have feelings for him since he was your best friend, but one thing that took a turn for the worst, and the one thing that never left you the same, was that your best friend..... ~turned into a killer~

Content Guidelines