Hiccup leaves Berk and starts his own village. He's blessed with two daughters, and cursed by the death of his wife. Few years later, Berk crashes on the shore of his island. Despite his feelings for him, he helps them get back on their feet. Once they're ready to leave, Stoick, still being against their way of life, takes Hiccups youngest daughter to train her as one of his own. After a decade and a half, the daughter returns to the island, but has no recollection of the meetings she'd had with her older sister, nor does Hiccup have any idea who she is. Once Hiccup is told who she is, instead of acting out, like the village had expected, he started to see what she knew. He was more than relieved when he found that Berk had failed in their mission to make her a blood thirsty killer, out for the skin of the man who supposedly abandoned her and killed her mother. When another Hooligan comes to the island in search of her, how will Hiccup respond, having just gotten his long lost daughter back? What happens when his child hood tormentors rebel against their chief and ask to join him? Will Tawny be able to handle the pressure of becoming the next chief of a village who knew her, but she had no idea existed?