Best Kind of Mess (Sequel to Into The Flame)

Reads 655
Votes 57
Parts 18
Time 2h 31m

Reads 655
Votes 57
Parts 18
Time 2h 31m

Mature

After two years of leaving the Pasta's, [Y/N] doesn't notice the changes happening around her. Zalgo was alive all this time, and BEN has to beg for [Y/N] to come back.All Rights Reserved

Table of contents

18 parts

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Bloody Romance | Eyeless Jack x Reader by amyau_08

Y/n was always considered different too everyone except their Nanna who dies unfortunately. However, Y/n meets the creepypasta's who are similar too them and is welcomed by Slenderman. Some of the creepypasta's don't exactly like this new arrangement at first and others welcome you with open arms. During this time, Y/n is determined too find out what they truly are. However a small love blossoms in between Y/n and the man behind the blue mask. A/n: I'm sorry but not all the famous creepypasta's you know of (cause I'm dumb) will be in this story, but I'll try too add as many as possible, and this is my first story so dont judge me. ⚠️Warning⚠️ *Swearing *Blood, grotesque imagery !Don't read if easily triggered!

Ellie's lost all faith of the world and her life but once she meets her long lost father, what does she do?? Will she stay or go?? Read more to find out

When Will You Forget Me? (Book three in the Misguided Killer Series) by Unseen-and-unspoken

The battle with Zalgo has left a few scar on the Creepypasta. Memories have shattered and personalities altered. With Jeff so far back from the edge, Slenderman much make a choice. To try and get Jeff back, or leave him to a normal life. But nightmares don't stay dead for long, and perhaps a deal with the devil may be the only way to keep everyone happy. And alive.

Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios [COMPLETED] by tinymoth_jpg

Here is the stories for Jeff, Slender, BEN, and Eyeless jack. I will be in the story later on. I will mention other creepypastas if that's what you want. I always love suggestions and stuff so thanks!

Male Survivor Reader X Female Creepypasta by TheChainsOfDespair

This is a Story about you the reader this is my first story where I'm not the character so yay. I don't own any of the creepy pastas they belong to there original creators, you on the other hand belong to yourself. Poor Y/N L/N has survived the apocalypse and is the last known human being alive. In search of other survivors he travels around the world for answers because you just woke up from a coma unexpectedly. When you travel into the wrong forest though you realized you now have to fight for your life against several beautiful ghouls that would love nothing more to kill you. But unknown to you they have other wicked things in mind, so please take a seat and delve into this twisted world.

After the breakout from the hospital, Y/N and Zalgo have gotten married and the other pastas have gotten back to their normal routines. Fear, however, has found things to be difficult after the betrayal of her sister, Blasphemy. Now she's nowhere to be found. But when evil forces threaten Y/N and her new family, will she be able to convince Fear to come home and fight? Or will Fear give up her old life completely? Book 3 of Every King Needs a Queen trilogy

Cry Baby - BEN Drowned x Reader by jeffsno1gf

It started with tears, but will it end in tears? -BEN Drowned x Reader -Profanity -Mature themes -LGBTQ+ representation (cause fuck homophobes) -Don't be an asshole if you comment -If you don't like it, don't read it. Move along. STARTED: 09/22/19 ENDED: 11/05/19

Ben Drowned x Reader A Glitchy Heart by TazminMcPasta

Y/n is a young girl who was beaten and mistreated at school. She stays with her step dad, who has disorders. His boss hates kids. So her step dad had the keep her in the basement with only her bed, desk, and lamp, but she finds old boxes and a old fashion computer. No windows, no sunlight, and no life. Y/n though everything was pointless but one day she did something that would change her life forever.

She's Mine. (Creepypasta x Reader Fanfiction) by AwkwardSunset

My name is Y/N, and I guess you can say I'm not normal. I met Slenderman one day, while running through the woods, and since then my whole world changed. The reason I'm not normal is because of what happened just a few weeks after I became a pasta. I find out who I really am, and who I love. ----------------------------------------------------- WHO WILL YOU CHOOSE? Ben Drowned? Eyeless Jack? Homicidal Liu? Hoodie? Jeff the Killer? Laughing Jack? Masky? Offenderman? Slenderman? Splendorman? Ticci Toby? Trenderman? [COMPLETED]

Grim Reaper| Creepypasta X Reader by LostKilljoy_

Book Two of the 'Wings of Freedom' series. Book one: Wings of Freedom A new threat falls in the Pasta town, how will Y/n and her friends deal with the new enemy destined to arise? ==== COMPLETED! Disclaimer: I don't own you! I don't own Creepypasta! Claimer: I DO own the OCs I've made I DO own the plot line Creepypasta OWN you ;) WARNINGS!!: Swearing Gore(?) Violence THRID BOOK: Zalgo's Return (not out yet) A/n: Thank you for reading this far into the series! It really mean a lot as a writer! Thank you for all the wonderful comments and support I've been getting. Again, thank you!

Bloody Romance | Eyeless Jack x Reader

Y/n was always considered different too everyone except their Nanna who dies unfortunately. However, Y/n meets the creepypasta's who are similar too them and is welcomed by Slenderman. Some of the creepypasta's don't exactly like this new arrangement at first and others welcome you with open arms. During this time, Y/n is determined too find out what they truly are. However a small love blossoms in between Y/n and the man behind the blue mask. A/n: I'm sorry but not all the famous creepypasta's you know of (cause I'm dumb) will be in this story, but I'll try too add as many as possible, and this is my first story so dont judge me. ⚠️Warning⚠️ Swearing Blood, grotesque imagery !Don't read if easily triggered!

More details