Macey Lancher has everything a girl needs - caring friends, good grades, awesome parents, except a boyfriend. She has not one guy she likes... but two who have different personalities, but each have some kind of charm that has Macey hooked. As the school year goes on, Macey will get closer to both of them, but she will also learn more about Chris and John. Some things may be good, but she may learn some things that aren't so appealing as well. Who will Macey choose in the end, Chris, John, or neither of them?