Butterflies and Stranger
- Reads 978
- Votes 46
- Parts 9
MatureOngoing54m
Last published Wed, Aug 6, 2025
Michael X Reader
You and Jeremy met in history class of freshman year and became pretty good friends. Jeremy was nice, but there was one problem, Michael. You were never really close to him and are always awkward with him....until, Jeremy got Squipped.
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
GAME OVER (Jeremy X Reader)
Be More Chill, reader insert fanfic. You, the reader, are a new student and Middleborough High where you meet Jeremy Heere, a nerdy, kind of insecure boy who has a crush on you. After a party you wake up with a voice in your head... A SQUIP. And the SQUIP will stop at nothing to get revenge on Jeremy, who tried to destroy him/it the previous year. You have to stop the SQUIP from killing Jeremy and your friends. Highest Ranking: 1 in #bmc for 6 weeks 1 in #jeremyheere for 9 weeks 1 in #jeremyxreader CURRENTLY 1 in #bmcxreader for 10 weeksComplete
The New Girl (Michael Mellxreader) Finished
Y/N L/N she was "normal" she had her issues.. But she never gave up so she'd keep all her issues locked away and help her friends until she meets Michael Mell the boy who shows her loveComplete
GAME OVER: a Be More Chill fic
Things have been going downhill for Jeremy ever since he got rid of the Squip. So after uncovering some long-buried feelings for his Player 1, Jeremy does something he knows he'll regret.Complete
I'll Be Right Here Forever
Michael stopped talking to Jeremy after the squipcident. It was his fault after all, wasn't it? When he finally comes back in he expects a big welcome. Instead he gets his heart broken by the person he needed most. All that's left is for Jeremy to know that he'll be right here forever.Complete
The Guy That I'd Kinda Be Into- Squip x Reader (Be More Chill)
****READER IS BI/PAN**** (Y/N) (L/N) is best friends with Michael and Jeremy. However, she is feeling sick of being at the bottom of the social status ladder. So when popular guy Rich offers her a "Squip" to boost her reputation in the school, how could she say no? Fandom: Be More Chill (musical) Title: Song from the musicalComplete
~Watching From a Distance: Squip x reader x Jeremy~
Highest rank: #1 in Squip (5-9-22: This story is very outdated in my humble opinion. But, if you ever wondered what it would be like to become a Mary Sue in the world of "Be More Chill," I suppose you're in for a real treat. This is your warning!) You, Jeremy Heere, and Michael Mell have always been best friends. Jeremy has a huge crush on you, but is to afraid to admit it. He finally gets a Squip to help him win over you. Squippy just thinks this will be another "get your crush" goal, but something about you fascinates him. He know from that point on that he has to have you, and will do whatever it takes to do it. Even if it means going against his code. (COMPLETED! :D)Complete
You're my dork (Michael mell Xreader)
Y/N L/N, that's you. You're forced to move in with the Mell's after your mom has to go on a business trip for a year and she doesn't want you to be home by yourself. You've known the mells ever since you were little since your mom was best friends with michaels mother. you and Michael were best friends but the issue was its been years since you've seen him. you knew that you both had changed and it terrified you, you went from a happy outgoing girl to one who hid behind a fake smile and sarcasm and you had no clue how Michael was and it terrified you, lets just say you weren't prepared for what was about to happen. Cover art by: MeComplete
Hurt Me Once- A Boyf-riends fanfiction
The SQUIP has happened. Michael saved the day, Jeremy got the girl, everything is perfect... right? Only Jeremy may or may not have realized his feelings for his friend are more than friendly. And Michael... well Michael's trying not to feel to broken up over his crush of many years finally getting a girlfriend. Michael may not be happy for himself, but he's happy for Jeremy. But is Jeremy happy? Their friendship isn't what it used to be, and Jeremy is steadily beginning to notice that nothing matters to him quite the way Michael does. Can he let go of Christine and reach for Michael before Michael is out of reach?Complete![||Priority|| (Michael Mell x Reader) [Be More Chill]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/115492823-256-k638881.jpg)
||Priority|| (Michael Mell x Reader) [Be More Chill]
"That one? Really?" The squip asked, shocked. "Yes." You replied. "So you got me to get him? Of all the other hot people in the school, you pick the one at the bottom, Micheal Mell." The squip scoffed. Micheal Mell. He was the only guy you wanted. ((Cover by @Damsel-ly))Complete
The Answer Lies in the Truth
The Squip comes back to tell Jeremy that there is someone who has a crush on him. Jeremy must find out who it is before the Valentine Party.Complete
Be More Chill, reader insert fanfic. You, the reader, are a new student and Middleborough High where you meet Jeremy Heere, a nerdy, kind of insecure boy who has a crush on you. After a party you wake up with a voice in your head... A SQUIP. And the SQUIP will stop at nothing to get revenge on Jeremy, who tried to destroy him/it the previous year. You have to stop the SQUIP from killing Jeremy and your friends. Highest Ranking: 1 in #bmc for 6 weeks 1 in #jeremyheere for 9 weeks 1 in #jeremyxreader CURRENTLY 1 in #bmcxreader for 10 weeks
More detailsContent Guidelines