Butterflies and Stranger
- Reads 978
- Votes 46
- Parts 9
MatureOngoing54m
Last published Wed, Aug 6, 2025
Michael X Reader
You and Jeremy met in history class of freshman year and became pretty good friends. Jeremy was nice, but there was one problem, Michael. You were never really close to him and are always awkward with him....until, Jeremy got Squipped.
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Hurt Me Once- A Boyf-riends fanfiction
The SQUIP has happened. Michael saved the day, Jeremy got the girl, everything is perfect... right? Only Jeremy may or may not have realized his feelings for his friend are more than friendly. And Michael... well Michael's trying not to feel to broken up over his crush of many years finally getting a girlfriend. Michael may not be happy for himself, but he's happy for Jeremy. But is Jeremy happy? Their friendship isn't what it used to be, and Jeremy is steadily beginning to notice that nothing matters to him quite the way Michael does. Can he let go of Christine and reach for Michael before Michael is out of reach?Complete
~Watching From a Distance: Squip x reader x Jeremy~
Highest rank: #1 in Squip (5-9-22: This story is very outdated in my humble opinion. But, if you ever wondered what it would be like to become a Mary Sue in the world of "Be More Chill," I suppose you're in for a real treat. This is your warning!) You, Jeremy Heere, and Michael Mell have always been best friends. Jeremy has a huge crush on you, but is to afraid to admit it. He finally gets a Squip to help him win over you. Squippy just thinks this will be another "get your crush" goal, but something about you fascinates him. He know from that point on that he has to have you, and will do whatever it takes to do it. Even if it means going against his code. (COMPLETED! :D)Complete
Loving Me as Me (BMC Micheal x Jeremy)
This is a smut, you have been warned. This story is meant to take place in their senior year when these characters are of age. There's a romantic plot too, no worries This does happen to be my first smut fic. Micheal Mell is canon player 1 don't @ meComplete
The Answer Lies in the Truth
The Squip comes back to tell Jeremy that there is someone who has a crush on him. Jeremy must find out who it is before the Valentine Party.Complete
Boyf riends one shots (FINISHED)
Jeremy x Michael Fluff, love and angst Any grammar police comments will be deleted.Complete
L̶o̶s̶e̶r̶s̶ Lovers
School has been hard ever since the SQUIP incident, but Jeremy is ready to unwind when Thanksgiving break comes around. Jeremy feels like he should be happy. He just got with the girl of his dreams, got his best friend Michael back, and got rid of the SQUIP. But Jeremy still feels like a part of him is missing. Michael, throughout the SQUIP + Jeremy and Christine's relationship, has still managed to come through it. He can barely stand to see Jeremy with another girl, still, especially after liking him for almost 8 years. He is never able to let go of his feelings, even after almost a decade of doubt. Throughout the break, Jeremy and Michael go through hundreds of thoughts, and Jeremy has to decide "What is Michael Mell to him?" Lmao sorry I'm trash at summaries so forgive me for this corny ass descriptionComplete
The Guy That I'd Kinda Be Into- Squip x Reader (Be More Chill)
****READER IS BI/PAN**** (Y/N) (L/N) is best friends with Michael and Jeremy. However, she is feeling sick of being at the bottom of the social status ladder. So when popular guy Rich offers her a "Squip" to boost her reputation in the school, how could she say no? Fandom: Be More Chill (musical) Title: Song from the musicalComplete![how could this happen? [expensive headphones- bmc]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/155308156-256-k661614.jpg)
how could this happen? [expensive headphones- bmc]
[art credit goes to amelia dear on pinterest] [lowercase aesthetic not used in story] michael mell thought he disliked- no, hated- rich goranski. for most junior year, rich had bullied michael and his best friend jeremy heere. he'd also given jeremy the idea to get a squip- a super quantum unit intel processor. the squip took jeremy away from michael, leaving him alone. but now that the squip epidemic is over, rich had been getting nicer to jeremy and michael. now it's their senior year and jake, jeremy, rich, and michael are all close friends. jake and jeremy had started dating, leaving rich and michael alone more often. to michael, rich was only a friend, but what he didn't know is that rich thought of him as more.Complete
Be More, You!
(completed) (This is what I would like to happen in BMC. Basically a happy little book of fluff and the gays. Pairings: Michael x Jeremy, Rich x Jake, Christine x Jenna). Jeremy and Michael have been friends for 12 years, but when Jeremy's birthday rolls around the corner, he discovers something called a Squip. Michael, being the person he is, volunteers to buy it for Jeremy for the low price of 400$. What will they do when Jeremy's feelings for Michael change? (Cover art by scribs).Complete
Level Up || A Boyf riends Fanfic
Jeremy and Michael have been friends for 15 years now, being seniors in high school. When Jeremy and Christine break up, who is gonna be there for him? Read this dual perspective, cute Boyf riends fanfic filled with fluff, angst, and their journey as they get to know each other even better, make new friends, and interact with their families. There are trigger warnings listed at the top of the section.
The SQUIP has happened. Michael saved the day, Jeremy got the girl, everything is perfect... right? Only Jeremy may or may not have realized his feelings for his friend are more than friendly. And Michael... well Michael's trying not to feel to broken up over his crush of many years finally getting a girlfriend. Michael may not be happy for himself, but he's happy for Jeremy. But is Jeremy happy? Their friendship isn't what it used to be, and Jeremy is steadily beginning to notice that nothing matters to him quite the way Michael does. Can he let go of Christine and reach for Michael before Michael is out of reach?
More detailsContent Guidelines