- Reads 508,570
- Votes 6,019
- Parts 155
- Time 39m
Complete, First published Aug 04, 2018
New cover made by @Jaschicken, thank you so much! The title says it allAll Rights Reserved
Table of contents
- Who Took You To The MansionThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Which Slender Brothers Team?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Which Creepypasta Protects You?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Your Best Friend IsThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Cupcakes w/ Pinkamena or Flying w/ Rainbow Factory?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Goes With You On Vacation And Where?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Hits You With A Frying Pan?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Call When You Need HelpThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Watches A Horror Movie With You And Which Movie?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Accidentally Injured You BadlyThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Which Underrated Creepypasta Do You Hang Out With?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Falls Asleep With You On The Couch?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Drags You To The Mall?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- What Video Game You Play With BEN?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Get In A Fight WithThu, Oct 15, 2020
- What Does Shadow Think Of You?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Pushes You Into A Pool?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Blames You For Everything?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Which Broadway Musical Do You Watch And With Who?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Takes The Blame For Things You Did?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- What Does Scarecrow Think Of You?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Lets You Cry On Their Shoulder?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Were Friends With Before They Became KillersThu, Oct 15, 2020
- What Does Murdered Alice Think of You?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Does Slenderman Spare You?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Your Partner In Crime IsThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Hang Out With On Lazy Sunday?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Watches You In Your Sleep?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Play The "Knife Game" WithThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Takes Care Of You When You're Sick?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Listen To Melanie Martinez With And Which Song?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Hugs You Out Of The Blue?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Which Signs Are Brave Enough To Steal LJ's Candy?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Lights You On Fire?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Go Midnight Binge-Watching WithThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Has A Screaming Competition With You?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Smashes Your Face Into A Pie?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Throws A Bar Of Soap At You?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Jack, Jason, or Pop?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Gets You A Pet And What Kind?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Gives You A Birthday Gift And What They Give YouThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Scares You?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Does EJ Take Your Kidneys?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Likes You More, Liu or Sully?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Wakes You Up And HowThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Were Dared To KissThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Lights Your House On Fire?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Will Offender Offer You A Rose?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Gives You A Piggy Back Ride?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Buys You Ice Cream?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Race WithThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Goes Full Yandere On You?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Does LJ offer you candy?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Tries To Kidnap YouThu, Oct 15, 2020
- What Does Ebony Think Of You?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who YOU Push Into The PoolThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Sing A Duet WithThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Watch Youtube With And Who You WatchThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Send You Flying Off An Air MattressThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Pushes You Down The Stairs?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Watch The Sunset WithThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Which Hamilton Song You Listen To And Who You Listen WithThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Which Disney Movie You Watch With Who?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Makes You Food?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Forgets Your Birthday?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Throws A Surprise Party For You?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Punches You In The Stomach?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Randomly Starts Dancing With You?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Tells You Their Secrets?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Listen To Music With And Who You Listen ToThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Looks After You?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Blows Up Your Phone With Notifications?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Makes You Carry Their Stuff?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Are You A Proxy Or A Killer?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Puts Hot Sauce In Your Food?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Gives You A Random GiftThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Pushes You Off A Cliff?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Likes You More - Smile or Grinny?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Calms You Down When You're Upset?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Play "Never Have I Ever" WithThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Helps You When You Get Injured?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Which Proxy Foods?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Reads Books With You?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Do 7 Minutes In Heaven WithThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Gives You The Death Glare For No ReasonThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Kicks You In The Gut?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Keeps You Awake At Night?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Plays Video Games With You And BEN?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Takes You To Disneyland?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Murders Your Family?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Falls Asleep With You?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Annoys You On A Daily BasisThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Plays In The Snow With You? Sally or Lazari?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Makes You Their Servant For A Day?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Makes You Cry?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Helps You Hide Dead Bodies?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Kisses You From A Dare?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Helps You With HomeworkThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Your Roommate IsThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Makes You Slowly Lose Your Sanity?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Shares An Umbrella With YouThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Fistfight WithThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Spys On YouThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Keeps You CompanyThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Breaks Glass On Your Head?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Dr. Smiley or Nurse Ann?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Which Artist You Listen To And With Who (Part 2)Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Get Locked In A Room With And Who Did ItThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Takes You Out To Dinner?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Pokes The Crap Out Of You?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Pushes You Down The StairsThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Climbs Trees With YouThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Asks You A Billion QuestionsThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who's Shoulder You Fall Asleep OnThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Successfully Kidnaps YouThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Hits You With A ChairThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Stargaze WithThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Watches Horror With You And What You WatchThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Has A Rap Battle With YouThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Bleeds The Library Dry With YouThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Destroy BEN's console withThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Reads Manga With YouThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Suicide Squidward, Sadie, or Mouse?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Walks In The Woods With YouThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Spoils You?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Which Creepypasta Likes You MostThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Drives You Around The CityThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Confesses Their Love To YouThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Bosses You AroundThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Share A Blanket WithThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Comes Up To You CryingThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Does The Ice Bucket Challenge With YouThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Gets Lost With YouThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Sets Your Stuff On FireThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Listens To Dear Evan Hansen With You And Which SongThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Stays Up Late With YouThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Hugs You When You CryThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Listens To Music With You And Which Artist (Part 3)Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Constantly Asks You What Time It IsThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Sneak Attacks YouThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who's Senpai You AreThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Hangs Out With You On The Mansion RoofThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Breaks Your WristThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Breaks Your HeartThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Teaches You How To Drive And Were They Successful?Thu, Oct 15, 2020
- Which Tall Pasta's Shoulders You Ride OnThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Would Take A Bullet For YouThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Which Proxy Likes You BetterThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Plays The "Numbers You Should Never Call" GameThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Plans Your Birthday PartyThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Hugs You Like A BabyThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who You Were Forced To MarryThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Steals Your FoodThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Who Goes Trick or Treating With YouThu, Oct 15, 2020
- Author's NoteThu, Feb 22, 2024
Sign up to add Creepypasta Zodiacs #1 ✔ to your library and receive updates
or
You may also like
You may also like
