Once upon a time, Peggy's parents thought it'd be a good idea to send their three eldest daughters to boarding school to determine whether or not to send their younger siblings there. Once upon a time, Angelica, Eliza, and Peggy packed their bags and got sent to Columbia Boarding School. Once upon a time, Peggy found out the boarding school they'd been sent to was extremely homophobic. Once upon a time, Angelica and Eliza became like the others. Once upon a time, Peggy found out she was a lesbian. Once upon a time, Peggy began to hate herself for it. Once upon a dream, Peggy met Maria.