It all happened one night in December of 2009, it even got its own two-minute slot on several news stations despite how little people actually cared. But this isn't about a late murder on Christmas Eve of all nights, but Eric Berardi and Tobias Vincent. People suspected and even asked questions but they're the only two who really know what happened that night and why Aaliyah Berardi's piano is missing its last three keys. This is their story.