All Marilynn wanted for her sixteenth birthday was for her life long crush/best friend, Nate, to ask her out. But when only a few people come to her party she ends up hanging with the neighbor boy, Caden, all winter break and tells herself she's in love. Then when prom rolls around Nate wants to go with Marilynn but so does Caden and now she can't seem to decide who to go with. It just happens that Nate seems to be in the same situation with his EX. Who will she choose, who will HE choose.