Creepypasta high

Reads 275,415
Votes 10,007
Parts 43
Time 1h 5m

Reads 275,415
Votes 10,007
Parts 43
Time 1h 5m

Lucy is starting out new at a Creepypasta school. She befriends everyone except one girl and a rivalry begins. 

But as soon as that rivalry ends a new one starts. Lucy tries hard to think of plans to destroy the enemyAll Rights Reserved

creepypasta drama love lucy toby

Table of contents

43 parts

#542toby

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Childhood (Ticci Toby x Reader) by Miss_Megaheart

A little girl. No older than 3. Abandoned in the forest and left to die by her parents. The only thing she had was her family scrapbook and a stuffed animal. Befriended the beast called The Rake that day. She ate some poisonous berries by accident and almost died. Her new friend hollered to the being known as Slenderman. They saved her life and brought to their mansion, where she met more funny, weird, and creepy friends called "creepypastas." 13 years later, a new creepypasta comes by and they become the best of friends. His name is Toby Rogers. Otherwise known as Ticci Toby. Together, Toby helps find her find birth parents to get payback. After that, she starts developing a crush on the twitching boy. Why is this all so important to you? You are that girl.

Tris prior is starting high school when she meets the school bad boy,Four, will they become enemies? Or something else? This is my first fan fic and I'd love some criticism

I have a lot of ideas for Toby but not for fanfics so they will go here.

One Week changes everything || TobyxReader by hazelnut420

Y/n encounters Toby in the most random way possible. How will their relationship grow for this first week?

Secret // Ticci Toby x Reader by Vid3oGameFreak

"In order to make sure that the creepypasta's do their best at their jobs, Slenderman has one rule. You can't fall in love or be in a relationship... But what happens when Toby Rogers falls for his victim..?" This is my first fanfic so feel free to drop tips to help me out with stories in the comments below! WARNING: CONTAINS LEMON AND MANY SWEAR WORDS

Addicted ( Ticci Toby x reader) by Iris_5212

(Y/n)'s life is going great until one day, she is told she will be participating in a school field trip that not everyone can go. She soon discovers she is not as lucky as she thought. Disclaimer, I don't own the images shown in the chapters, as well as the creepypastas or you, the only thing I own is the plot, and the characters I create.

Bound by Teeth and Strings by Ghost_Dungeon

You just wanted to have a good time with your friends. But everything went straight to hell when you made the mistake of staying at the wrong cabin. Or, Toby does his job but takes a liking to you, and you quickly come to realize what that means for you. It's a fight to survive and a fight to keep your humanity.

CreepyPasta: Proxy Girl-(The Return of Suna the Nightalia) by CjHuffman4

Suna Colette, a Creepypasta DemonAngel, is coming back to the Creepypastas! After an appearance-changing growth-spurt and a year's worth of studying about them in Reality, she wants to see them so badly! Coming home, there's new trouble going on. Top it off with Toby and Clock Work's wedding with a new king in Hades, a battle's waiting for Suna...waiting to take her from her home...

(Y/N) was once human, living a normal and happy life. After her weird encounter, her life takes a turn but is it for better or worse? Let's read to find out

Creepypasta X Reader- A New Beginning by xXSilent_ShadowXx

Y/N is just a normal girl, with a normal life. At least it is normal to her. Ever since her little brother, Tommy, was killed at the young age of 4 by her father, her mother has been blaming her for it ever since. Your father has long since gone to jail and has been executed so the only person your mother had to blame was you. You soon couldn't take her daily beatings and seeing her drunk 24/7 didn't help your case either. Soon one thing leads to another and lets just say, you meet a certain Slenderman who takes you to a group of people that change your life forever. Your soon lonely life is now filled with the love of your murderous friends, little did you know most of them loved you in a way more than you could ever know. -NOTE- The cover that is currently on this book was NOT made by me, all rights are reserved to the creator of it but sadly I couldn't find the creator.... ;-; sorry (I also don't own Creepypasta or you so.... ON WIT DA STORY!!! (ﾉ◕ヮ◕)ﾉ*:･ﾟ✧)

$Creepypasta X Reader /Lost in the Woods\ by neve_trixxiboo$

[Name] was all so normal when it all happened. Is it against her to be the normal girl she was? Or is it her friends fault of being too obsessed with Creepypastas? Find out what happens to [Name] in this story! I do not own any pictures unless said otherwise and I do not own any of the Creepypastas. All rights go to their respective owners.

Under the Hood (discontinued) by MrsScarlet_Akatsuki

Killer Katie, the new girl at Creepypasta High, doesn't know what she's in for! Making new friends, getting into trouble, having an asshole for a cooking partner, forced to make a presentation when she knows she has stage fright, and falling for a mysterious proxy named Hoodie makes her life just harder. Things take a turn for the worst when she runs into an evil warlord named Zalgo who plans to destroy every Creepypasta and uses Katie as his bait! This is the story of how Katie began the journey to find herself and protect her loved ones with everything she has. Note: This story will be discontinued

Old Friends (Ticci Toby x reader) DISCONTINUED by CurlyAfro124

(Y/N) (L/N) has always been different. She's always been best friends with Toby Rogers, but it all changed after....the incident. When (Y/N) slowly starts to lose everything what will she become? What happens when she meets an old friend?

Symone The Doll (Creepypasta) by JordanSymone21

A young teenage girl name Symone goes through a natural life in highschool with friends and family and supposedly a new crush. But she start to realize things start to change when she mysteriously opens a portal to the creepypasta world and she discovers dark and creepy figures entering her world. She soon realizes that things may go for a change in her life for once and for all.

She's The Devil {Ticci Toby x reader} by XannVe

Toby and I have been friends since we met each other in pre-school. After that we've been going to the same schools. We're both 17 years of age now, and we're in the same class. People bully him for his tics but I protected him. At school he was unpopular but I was popular, I used it in my advantage to help Toby. But when the bullies gave him the nickname; Ticci Toby, everything changed. (I WILL BE CHANGING SOME THINGS FROM THE ORIGINAL CREEPYPASTA SO THE STORY COMES BETTER AROUND, LIKE TOBY BEING 17 YEARS OLD AND HIS SISTER 19 YEARS OLD)

Suicidal Love (Ticci Toby x Suicidal, abused reader){discontinued} by ryandeathsadboi

y/n was a 17 year old girl. constantly being abused by her always drunk parents, she finally decides to end it all. and that was when she meant him. but sometimes, some things never change and other times you find new twists. WARNING-this is about suicide, has language( cussing) and self-harm, also depressing things. also i suck at spelling so if u read try to bear with it ok thank you for reading- love you all💜☺

You just moved into a new neighborhood and you become friends with your neighbor, Toby Rogers... You become best friends... then in one night your whole life changes...

The New Girl And The Bad Boy by forever_Jen_

Avery Hunter was a normal popular girl. She is loved by all of her friends and she is really pretty. But one day she has to drop everything and move to Portland to help her mom take care of her sick grandmother. A new school, house, friends and on top of all that, the bad boy is after her. Insert Toby Halloway, the schools bad boy. All he cares about are girls, girls and more girls. He constantly gets in trouble and into fights. That is until one day he sees the new girl Avery standing in the middle of the hallway looking lost. He takes an interest in her but she has heard about him and she only wants to be friends. Can Toby convince Avery that he's not just trouble? Or will Avery compleatly ignore Toby's existence? Join Avery and Toby in their adventures in The New Girl And The Bad Boy

Violet has no experience with friendships because she has been homeschooled for her entire life. She knows about Creepypasta, but she isn't a super fan of it. Then she finds a strange gift in her car. Who left the gift? Only one person, of course; Laughing Jack. LJ has known Violet for the longest time. He wants to be her friend, but first he has to actually meet her. Will LJ work up the courage and meet her, or just admire her from afar?

Childhood (Ticci Toby x Reader)

A little girl. No older than 3. Abandoned in the forest and left to die by her parents. The only thing she had was her family scrapbook and a stuffed animal. Befriended the beast called The Rake that day. She ate some poisonous berries by accident and almost died. Her new friend hollered to the being known as Slenderman. They saved her life and brought to their mansion, where she met more funny, weird, and creepy friends called "creepypastas." 13 years later, a new creepypasta comes by and they become the best of friends. His name is Toby Rogers. Otherwise known as Ticci Toby. Together, Toby helps find her find birth parents to get payback. After that, she starts developing a crush on the twitching boy. Why is this all so important to you? You are that girl.

More details