Anyone But You
- Reads 5,222
- Votes 628
- Parts 9
Ongoing2h 59m
Last published Tue, Aug 25, 2026
Lucy Carter goes to college to become someone other than Ben Carter's little sister.
Then she meets Cole Bennett again.
Her brother's best friend. Northwood's football captain. Campus heartbreaker. The boy who used to call her kid and now somehow makes it impossible to remember how breathing works.
Cole doesn't do relationships. Lucy knows that.
Unfortunately, knowing something is a terrible reason not to want it.
* * *
Lucy has spent most of her life knowing Cole.
She just never expected to fall for him.
But somewhere between football games, jealous looks, late-night conversations and one kiss that was definitely not supposed to happen, the rules start getting blurry.
And Cole has more reasons to keep people out than Lucy ever realized.
She falls first.
He falls harder.
The only problem?
He's the one person she was never supposed to choose.
All Rights Reserved
#14
player
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Stung By You
I just close my eyes. Feeling him. Smelling him. Just existing close to him. My fingers clutch at his shirt, like it's the only thing keeping me from doing something reckless. Something completely, irrevocably stupid. Like kissing my son's best friend. And it feels so wrong. Oh God. So damn wrong. But then- His thumb shifts against my skin. A slow, lazy stroke. And suddenly, it feels so right. SO DAMN RIGHT. I breathe in too sharply. Mistake. He notices. Of course, he notices. His grip on my hips tightens. "You always this tense?" I force out a breath. "You always this annoying?" Leo laughs under his breath. "Only when I'm right." I tilt my head, and his eyes are already waiting for me-dark, unreadable, impossibly close. His fingers brush just above my waist. Barely there, but enough. Enough to make me hyper-aware of how easy it'd be to- "You wear this every night, don't you?" It takes me half a second to register what he means. The hoodie. His hoodie. *** 💔 She never expected to fall for him. 🔥 He never stopped waiting for her. 🏡 But some love stories don't follow the rules. Jenny Thompson moved to start fresh. A new neighborhood, a new home, a new beginning. What she didn't expect? Leo Mitchell. Her son's best friend. Fifteen years younger. And looking at her like she's something he's never stopped wanting. She tells herself it's nothing. She tells herself it can't happen. But then- 💬 "I don't know how to stop wanting this." 🔥 "Then don't." 📖 A slow-burn, emotional age-gap romance about love, healing, and the risk of wanting more. ** Taboo. Age gap. Off-limits tension. A love that shouldn't exist-but try stopping it.**Complete
Rock Bottom
"I pray that the last time I said goodbye was not meant forever." *** Growing up with a single parent with not much money to spare wasn't particularly easy, but Kayla never felt like her life was anything less than amazing. Her father loves her dearly, she has two amazing best friends, and she helps out at her family owned bistro while still managing to do well in school. What more could she ask for? Everything was perfect. Until the night her entire life came crashing down. The night of the accident. Kayla is forced to move in with her aunt who she hasn't seen since the young age of two. With Kayla's life breaking at the seams, she struggles to cope with her overwhelming sorrow. On Kayla's journey towards self- forgiveness she takes a risky leap towards love. She soon realizes that he will either save her, or be the cause of her reckoning. *completedComplete
𝓣𝓱𝓮 𝓡𝓮𝓽𝓾𝓻𝓷 𝓣𝓸 𝓨𝓸𝓾
Some love never really leaves. Soretta thought she was done with Devon. He thought he could forget her. But fate has other plans. A glance. A word. A memory that won't fade. Sparks ignite slowly, secrets linger in the shadows, and hearts ache with the weight of what was left unfinished. Returning to someone isn't easy, but maybe, just maybe, it's worth every moment. ----------- Slow Burn Romance | Second Chance | Coming of Age | Mature Romance | Secrets & Heartbreak | Slow Reveal of Feelings Content Warnings: ⚠️ Mature Themes: Sexual content, intimate situations, adult situations, Mental Health, and emotional tension. Please read responsibly.
Summer 010
Three years ago, a terrible accident happened. The aftermath of the tragedy changed their lives forever. She went to Paris and found herself. He went to New York and lost himself. Although they never spoke again, they never forgot one another. But after three years, Noah and Amy find themselves living next door for one last summer. What happens when someone from their past resurfaces and haunts them, forcing them to work together over and over again? And most importantly, can someone truly forget their first love? One last summer of elitist parties, extravagant dresses, indie rock music and late-night drives. One last summer of true friendships, unrequited loves and childhood dreams. And maybe, it's one last summer to fall in love again. [completed] cover by the very talented @thepeacefuloblivionComplete
The Corner Store
I fell for a boy with the kindest blue eyes, and a charming dimple. He made me feel loved, and cared for, and most importantly he made me feel safe in his presence. He came right in the middle of a tornadoe and managed to turn it into blue skies. He changed my perspective and gave me hope and strength." I looked at him, and he was smiling, and his eyes were a little glossy. He took my hand and kissed it, a small tear caught in the corner of his beautiful eyes. "I thought, hey, maybe life isn't so bad after all. Maybe I can finally allow myself to love and be loved, and to live life normally. When we went to your party, you told me to wait for you. But then your perverted cousin made me feel super uncomfortable, so I went looking for you, just to be able to feel at peace again. And that's when I saw it." My heart beats skyrocketed, because this was the moment everything changed forever. "Saw what?" Asked Axel. I took a deep breath, and continued. It's now or never. ✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨✨ Sophia Grace is a 25 year old Forensic Science major who recently started working as a cashier at her local grocery store - "The Corner Store". Amidst her cute demeanor and kind eyes, she harbors a dark secret that she doesn't want anyone to know about. To protect herself and those around her, she tries not to make friends at all and only go there for extra cash until she can graduate and leave. But what happens when Axel gets her on his radar? Would she allow herself to feel anything? And most importantly, what if they're more connected than they ever thought possible?? Will she run as soon as it gets tough, or will she fight against anything that tries to taint her past? Stay tuned for The Corner Store. 1st Place: GYSO Awards (Oct 2023) 2nd Place: YearlyAwards (Dec 2023)Complete
When Did It Go Wrong?
In the midst of his teenage years, a 14-year-old high schooler found himself falling deeply in love for the very first time. However, there was a catch - his beloved was far away, and their relationship was bound by distance. Despite the odds stacked against them, the young boy refused to give up, fighting valiantly to keep the flame of their love burning bright. But fate is a fickle mistress, and three years later, tragedy struck. The boy received the heartbreaking news that his long-distance girlfriend had passed away. Consumed by grief and struggling to make sense of his loss, he turned to his diary for solace, seeking answers to the question that haunted him day and night: when did it all go wrong? As he embarked upon the daunting task of unraveling the enigma before him, our protagonist found himself confronted with an array of formidable obstacles that threatened to entangle him in their grasp and impede his progress. These challenges, which were to prove more insurmountable than he had anticipated, weighed heavily upon him, shackling his life and casting doubt upon his ability to overcome them. Thus began a journey of self-discovery, as the young boy poured his heart out onto the pages of his diary, reliving the memories of his past and grappling with the harsh realities of the present. From the highs of first love to the lows of crushing loss, his story is a poignant reminder of the power of love and the strength of the human spirit in the face of adversity.)Complete
Always | ✓
#1 in Teen Fiction - 26.03.2020 #10 in Romance - 04.10.2020 #1 in Unrequited - 21.02.2020 #1 in LoveTriangle - 01.01.2020 # 14 in Angst - 20.20.2020 Loving someone who doesn't love you is hard... But watching someone you love, fall in love with someone else, is harder... Serena was waiting for the moment that Liam would notice her. She was his neighbour since he'd moved into the house across from her, and she's been in love with him since he crashed his bike outside her house. What she didn't expect was that the moment Liam said the words "Hey, Neighbour", he was about to shatter her heart into pieces... *** *Requires Some Major Editing (hopefully I'll get to eventually) and Also Contains Some Swearing*Complete
Over Again | ✓
|| The Global Awards Winner: Best of Awards: Teen Fiction || ❝It's your turn to prove just how much you love him.❞ What I didn't know was I might have been too late already. All I said was, ❝I don't know how.❞ Then and there, I had my answer. ** One summer. Seven Friends. And a road trip they'll never forget. Friendships are fun. Especially when there are more than two of you. Seven to be exact. But what happens when you lose one and is replaced by another? It was supposed to be the only seven of them for Harper. And when her boyfriend and best friend died, he was almost immediately replaced by none other than the new boy in the neighborhood-Adam Pierce. Adam Pierce is your typical 90s bad boy. He's got the looks, the attitude, you name it. A true-to-life arrogant prince that most hopeless romantic wants. Hell, even his name sounds like it. But even princes keep their owns secrets. And this one got more than you can count. Harper Woods wanted nothing to do with him. Adam wanted everything that has got to do with her. They think it'll be easier than that, but everything is different when you start all over again. Created on: 3-12-17 Finished on: 6-25-17 PSA: This is still unedited. So, please excuse the mistakes.Complete
I just close my eyes. Feeling him. Smelling him. Just existing close to him. My fingers clutch at his shirt, like it's the only thing keeping me from doing something reckless. Something completely, irrevocably stupid. Like kissing my son's best friend. And it feels so wrong. Oh God. So damn wrong. But then- His thumb shifts against my skin. A slow, lazy stroke. And suddenly, it feels so right. SO DAMN RIGHT. I breathe in too sharply. Mistake. He notices. Of course, he notices. His grip on my hips tightens. "You always this tense?" I force out a breath. "You always this annoying?" Leo laughs under his breath. "Only when I'm right." I tilt my head, and his eyes are already waiting for me-dark, unreadable, impossibly close. His fingers brush just above my waist. Barely there, but enough. Enough to make me hyper-aware of how easy it'd be to- "You wear this every night, don't you?" It takes me half a second to register what he means. The hoodie. His hoodie. *** 💔 She never expected to fall for him. 🔥 He never stopped waiting for her. 🏡 But some love stories don't follow the rules. Jenny Thompson moved to start fresh. A new neighborhood, a new home, a new beginning. What she didn't expect? Leo Mitchell. Her son's best friend. Fifteen years younger. And looking at her like she's something he's never stopped wanting. She tells herself it's nothing. She tells herself it can't happen. But then- 💬 "I don't know how to stop wanting this." 🔥 "Then don't." 📖 A slow-burn, emotional age-gap romance about love, healing, and the risk of wanting more. ** Taboo. Age gap. Off-limits tension. A love that shouldn't exist-but try stopping it.**
More detailsContent Guidelines