Story cover for What Should Have Happened by extroverted-bookworm
What Should Have Happened
extroverted-bookworm
  • WpView
    Reads 5
  • WpVote
    Votes 1
  • WpPart
    Parts 1
  • WpHistory
    Time <5 mins
  • WpView
    Reads 5
  • WpVote
    Votes 1
  • WpPart
    Parts 1
  • WpHistory
    Time <5 mins
extroverted-bookworm
Complete, First published Jan 17, 2019
boyxboyfanfictiongayboysgaylovelgbtlgbt-themedloveromanceshortshortstory
What would have happened if Simon noticed the second note from Blue sooner?
What if he noticed it when he got the shirt? 
Ladies, gentleman, and everything in between this is What Should Have Happened.

Characters belong to Becky Albertalli.

Credit goes to the owners of the fanart.
All Rights Reserved
boyxboyfanfictiongayboysgaylovelgbtlgbt-themedloveromanceshortshortstory
Table of contents

1 part

Sign up to add What Should Have Happened to your library and receive updates
or
Content Guidelines
You may also like
Breaking the Ice by tragicvenus
32 parts Ongoing Mature
[bxb] Luke had always suspected that he was gay. There's a very big difference, however, between thinking you 𝘮𝘪𝘨𝘩𝘵 be gay, and having a pretty boy naked and underneath you in the backseat of his car. *+*❅*+* Lucas Donovan had always kept his life on a tight leash. Between high school, hockey, and helping take care of his family, there was scarcely room for romance-not that Luke minded. Girls seemed too complicated, too messy, and too damn stressful when they came with any intention beyond quick, drunk sex. The "spark" was all fairytale bullshit, anyways... or so Luke believed. It was funny, really. All it took to change Luke's mind was getting laid in the backseat of the car of a boy with big, blue eyes shrouded in an even bigger mystery. *+*❅*+* Rankings: #1 friendswithbenefits #1 comingout #2 skating #4 boyxboy #8 bisexual #7 ice #22 gay *+*❅*+* Cover Photo: Kelli Clintock Cover Design: tragicvenus
Blue Moon [BXB]│✓ by lovenesha
47 parts Complete Mature
❝Okay, I bet I can seduce him by the end of this year.❞ ━━━━━━━━☾☽━━━━━━━━ Senior year has approached, and Blue couldn't be more anxious to graduate. As a trend starts to go around the school on who could lose their virginity, Blue doesn't take part in it. With him being the only virgin in his senior class, he knows he has to protect his V-Card at all costs. ©RoseNesha, 2018 All Rights Reserved
Sun Kissed ✓ by swallowedhearts
16 parts Complete
[BXB] Two boys, an ice cream store and a summer to fall in love. ✩✩✩ Outgoing Tanner makes it a mission to befriend his reserved coworker Austin over the course of the summer and turns out to be more successful than he ever could've hoped. [ July. 2021. - August 2021. ]
22 Letters✓ by salemmiles_
42 parts Complete
🏆Featured ×3 Revised edition available on Barnes and Noble, Apple Books, Amazon and many more retailers near you! ** 22 letters. 24 days. 1 boy. What could possibly go wrong? ************* When Leon James takes a bet to reveal his true feelings to his crush, he didn't expect a timeline to it. He also didn't expect that timeline to be in 24 days. Now with his shyness and mental health getting the best of him, he has to find a clever way to let his crush- or crushes- know how he truly feels. And what better way than writing letters to them?
Not A Day Goes By by skwarlogirlcfc
15 parts Complete Mature
WARNING: I seriously hate this story. Read at your own risk. It CLEARLY gets better with each chapter, as my writing skill improved- but it starts with a disgusting cliche. Looking back now, it seems silly. It seems silly to think that, after all the jokes, stares, and meaningful silences, we'd still only be friends. It seems silly to think that I'd tried so hard to go against the very thing I wanted. It seems silly to think that he and I couldn't see what the future held for us. Mark and I, well it was only a matter of tempting fate.
Tense by howtosellmysoul
55 parts Ongoing Mature
"I love you." "Oh?" "In a non-bro sort of way, y'know? Full homo." ~~~ Kai and Roan are a lot of things. Best friends, football players, straight A students, future roommates, and so on. Read what happens when a kiss adds something new to the list. ~~~ [This is a FREE book with paid exclusive chapters.] [bxb] [Marked mature for sexual content.]
Out of reasons (M×M) ✔ by sweetcaressesofmay
34 parts Complete
Only a few months after his dad's death, Daniel decides to leave his hometown to study in an art school at countryside. New ambience would surely help him deal with his dad's death, but what if it, instead, only gives him more issues to deal with? In his new school Daniel meets an illicitly good-looking guy, who seems almost too good to be true. It would have been a perfect beginning of the journey, if Daniel didn't have to share his dormitory flat with a bad-tempered and dishevelled roommate.. CW: violence, sexual assault, trauma, mentions of suicide, panic attacks 2019 (original), 2022 (edited).
Blue's Rose by ReadAnyGoodBLLately
40 parts Complete Mature
Kool Somboon, a Thai foreign exchange student stayed with Blue Cavanaugh and his family in America during the boys' senior year of high school. The story starts with a glimpse of their last moments together when Kool gives Blue a small and simple gift that potentially has large and complex implications. Four years later, Blue is on a plane to Thailand. He is determined to find Kool and put to rest all of the questions that have plagued him since Kool dashed out of his life. With college behind him and a new job awaiting him, Blue has decided he cannot continue forward without finding Kool and getting some answers. For four years he has been preoccupied by a parting gift and the image of a bittersweet smile and troubled by the lack of response to any of his attempts at contacting him. Enough was enough! He had questions. He deserved answers. What came next? Well... read on to find out!
The Boy That Stole My Heart Boyxboy by igrowlandbite
23 parts Complete Mature
ITS FINISHED EVERYONE. THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT. I HOPE THIS STORY MEANS AS MUCH TO YOU AS IT DOES ME. (Please don't let the first chapter stop you from reading this. It's such a good story. Please let me know what you think!!!!! LOVE YOU GUYS!
You All Over Me [BxB] by chroniclesoftatiana
47 parts Complete Mature
"Sooner or later, you'll fall for me, too." Theodore bursts into laughter. "I don't know where your confidence is coming from." Jacob chuckles and says, "I just know." And then it catches Theodore off guard when Jacob adds, "We should be making out right now." Theodore swallows and looks him in the eye. "We should." "And I should be undressing you at this very moment," he continues, "We could stay up all night with our hands on each other and just... forget everything." ****** Meet Jacob and Theodore, the polar opposites within a tight-knit circle of the most esteemed members of society. Jacob, reserved and hard to read, isn't exactly Theodore's biggest fan-unlike everyone else, who's head over heels for the golden boy. However, as they navigate their way through law school, they trip over a connection that sparks a lowkey romance, catching both of them by surprise. Content warning: Physical assault, homophobia, mental health, strong language, sexual content Started: September 21, 2023 Ended: January 9, 2024 Revised: June 1, 2025 - June 28, 2025
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
Breaking the Ice cover
Blue Moon [BXB]│✓ cover
Sun Kissed ✓ cover
22 Letters✓ cover
Not A Day Goes By cover
Tense cover
Out of reasons (M×M) ✔ cover
Blue's Rose cover
The Boy That Stole My Heart Boyxboy cover
You All Over Me [BxB] cover

Breaking the Ice

32 parts Ongoing Mature

[bxb] Luke had always suspected that he was gay. There's a very big difference, however, between thinking you 𝘮𝘪𝘨𝘩𝘵 be gay, and having a pretty boy naked and underneath you in the backseat of his car. *+*❅*+* Lucas Donovan had always kept his life on a tight leash. Between high school, hockey, and helping take care of his family, there was scarcely room for romance-not that Luke minded. Girls seemed too complicated, too messy, and too damn stressful when they came with any intention beyond quick, drunk sex. The "spark" was all fairytale bullshit, anyways... or so Luke believed. It was funny, really. All it took to change Luke's mind was getting laid in the backseat of the car of a boy with big, blue eyes shrouded in an even bigger mystery. *+*❅*+* Rankings: #1 friendswithbenefits #1 comingout #2 skating #4 boyxboy #8 bisexual #7 ice #22 gay *+*❅*+* Cover Photo: Kelli Clintock Cover Design: tragicvenus

More details