All her life, Lilly Carabine has enjoyed her uncontested reputation as an absolute nobody. Her friends have been pushing and pushing her to pursue a relationship with one of her several suitors, but she's never been interested - until now. When she unexpectedly finds herself lost in a high school cooking class her sophomore year, Lilly has all but abandoned ship, until she is assigned to a semester-long baking project with a mysterious junior guy. David just might be the one to entice Lilly into dating, but can she convince her friends and family of his good side when all they can see is his hardened exterior and his suspicious past?