Claudia cannot help but cause a commotion wherever she goes. She is in outcast in her conservative town, despite her popularity, for her "controversial aura." When accusations are thrown around about the death of a classmate, Claudia is forced to prove her innocence. Along for the ride is Benjamin, a pest, who now seems even more interested in Claudia amid rumors of her having something to do with the murder. Problems only grow when a mystery man shows up in town hot on Claudia's trail.