I Think I Love You
starrykid19
  • Reads 54,855
  • Votes 1,361
  • Parts 12
  • Time 1h 11m
  • Reads 54,855
  • Votes 1,361
  • Parts 12
  • Time 1h 11m
starrykid19
Ongoing, First published Apr 07, 2019
bendrownedclockworkcreepypastaeyelessjackeyelessjackxticcitobyeyelesstobyfluffjackxtobyjanethekillerjeffthekillerlaughingjackromancesallywilliamsshippingshipsslendermanticcijackticcitoby
From burning his house down, to being taken in 
by a faceless eldritch creature. Toby has now become curious about a certain mask wearing man. He knows just the way to get closer to him, but he realizes this might be more than he bargained for. 

Warning for: Gore, medical descriptions/situations, and slight homophobia. 

Mansion AU! 

art by: yasmimkilleruwu on tumblr

(Rewriting! Slight OOC Toby, personal headcanons ensue. Comments and votes appreciated!)
All Rights Reserved
bendrownedclockworkcreepypastaeyelessjackeyelessjackxticcitobyeyelesstobyfluffjackxtobyjanethekillerjeffthekillerlaughingjackromancesallywilliamsshippingshipsslendermanticcijackticcitoby
Table of contents

12 parts

Sign up to add I Think I Love You to your library and receive updates
or
#26bendrowned
Content Guidelines
You may also like
She's Mine. (Creepypasta x Reader Fanfiction) by AwkwardSunset
20 parts Complete Mature
My name is Y/N, and I guess you can say I'm not normal. I met Slenderman one day, while running through the woods, and since then my whole world changed. The reason I'm not normal is because of what happened just a few weeks after I became a pasta. I find out who I really am, and who I love. ----------------------------------------------------- WHO WILL YOU CHOOSE? Ben Drowned? Eyeless Jack? Homicidal Liu? Hoodie? Jeff the Killer? Laughing Jack? Masky? Offenderman? Slenderman? Splendorman? Ticci Toby? Trenderman? [COMPLETED]
Living With The Creepypastas (Old) by VikingMetalToby
43 parts Complete
IMPORTANT: I originally wrote this back in 2018 when I was younger and an idiot and sucked badly at writing. It's all toxic fandom stereotypes in this book. You should know ahead of time that this story is gonna suck. Huge L. DESC: You're a useless outsider until you get recruited by Slenderman one night. Congrats, you get to be a proxy and live in the Slender Mansion with the creepypastas and have cliché a Creepypasta x reader life! Ughhh. !𝐒𝐓𝐎𝐑𝐘 𝐖𝐀𝐑𝐍𝐈𝐍𝐆𝐒! - Y/N, unfortunately, is the overused female lead idiot stupid. (Please feel free to treat Y/N as your preference). - Ticci Toby is 'sort of' a waffle addict. - Hoody and Masky are considered Creepypasta/Proxies. - There's TicciWork (This was old, alright?) - There's obvious excessive cursing. - There's obviously cringe (2018 trash.) - yeah #1 in boring. Now you know to run...
Bittersweet | Ticci Toby by sirin_writes
10 parts Ongoing Mature
◤━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━◥ Bittersweet /ˈbɪt̬.ɚˌswiːt/ (adj.) "containing a mixture of happiness and sadness" ◣━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━◢ A series of unfortunate events determine you to want to pluck a certain goggled male's eyes out. He seems to enjoy the dynamic between the two of you. Do you? If you're looking for one of those classic old fashion creepypasta fanfics with a disgusting amount of swearing, but with no cringe slendermansion, look no further this is it. TW: MAJOR gore and blood warning, swearing, stalking, murder, lots of death, angst, mental illness, lots of bad decisions 🙏 (Female!ReaderxYandere! Ticci Toby) enemies to lovers Slenderverse AU
Creepypasta Headcannons Book 2 by kjm126316
197 parts Complete
Well whaddya know whaddya know I actually managed to fill up an entire book with these bloody headcannons. And, surprise surprise, I have an overactive imagination, so here we go again! NOTE: Read the first headcannons book before this one. You'll thank me later
DISCONTINUED | the wind breeze ~ Ticci Toby x Eyeless Jack by venusmoon555
14 parts Complete
Eyeless Jack, a introverted guy who has demons in him falls in love with none other than the annoying, idiotic Ticci Toby. this story shows how they fall in love, then into the dangers ahead of the demons and nightmares. this story contains: swearing!! maybe incorrect words Gore and a beautiful ship (in my opinion) this is also my first story! please critique/judge my story, I'd love to learn how to become better at writing and that would be the only way how! ^^ I'll mostly write this when I'm bored at 1 am, so, my writing could be off lol
Fighting Love by JessicaDark2
17 parts Complete
I don't own any of the characters, except mine. Yes I know most or all characters, and I am a huge fan of creepypasta. Characters that you will or may see and that I will use. Characters - Slenderman, Ticci Toby (Toby Rogers), Masky (Tim,Timothy), Hoodie(Brian), Jeff the Killer (Jeffrey Woods), Eyeless Jack (Jack), Jane the Killer (Jane Richerdson), Sally Williams, Ben Drown, Dark Link, Lulu (Lucial Tiffany), Laughing Jack, Nurse Ann,Yandary (Ayano), Lazari, Jason the ToyMaker, Suicidal Liu(Liu Woods), the Puppeteer, Nina the killer(Nina), Clockwork , Blood Traitor, Jasper, Lost Sliver, Smiling Dog, Rake, Zalgo, Creepy Fanf characters, Sonic Ex, Jason, Huntress, Doctor Tima- Kiel, Cp/n (Y/n) and Red Mask ( Rosaline, or Rose Grey) and Blue Mask (Ryan Grey), Pink Wolf (Ruby Grey) and Grey Night (Susen Grey) ....I know most of these characters aren't creepypasta but to me they are, and the last one is my oc, soo ye.. shipping Toby x Masky Hoodie x Rose Lulu x Jeff Sally x Ben Ryan x Eyeless Jack
Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios. by AwkwardSunset
20 parts Complete Mature
You're the girlfriend of a notorious Creepypasta killer, what have you gotten yourself into? ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Characters: Ben Drowned Doll Maker Eyeless Jack Homicidal Liu/Sully Hoodie Jason the Toymaker Jeff the Killer Laughing Jack Masky Ticci Toby [COMPLETED]
A Dance With The Devil (Ticci Toby X Reader) by SteveFromCorporate
17 parts Complete
In this story we are taken into your life you are a sarcastic,fun loving girl with a bit of a swearing problem not that you care. You are about as normal as any 18 year old. You have school and other daily struggle any teenager comes across so you can imagine the horror you experiences when you come across a murder scene. Your whole life goes to hell when you meet the man behind the murder but is the hell your life has gone to as horrible as you think? This story does have a bit of swearing and there is some talk about sex though no actual lemons,don't get excited! I'm just warning anyone incase they might get offended so that you don't read this book. Other then that please do read,comment and enjoy! ******** So I have started a YouTube channel, and I'd really appreciate some support! Youtube: m.youtube.com/channel/UChnQ4J-2xTGnx4aLYVt5Etw Instagram: Stevefromcorporate Snapchat: Stevefromcorporate Twitter: @Stevefromcorpr8 (Everything is under construction but you can still subscribe and follow!) Thank you so much for your support!
𝚆𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚝𝚑𝚎𝚢? [✔] {Jeff the Killer x Gender Neutral Reader} by Lesbesbean
37 parts Complete Mature
In order to save your life, Slenderman does what he swore he'd never do - he makes you his proxy. Little did you know how much it would change your life... - - - The reader is kept gender-neutral throughout the whole story and smut chapters always have two versions (one for male and one for female anatomy). Tldr; this is a creepypasta x reader fanfic, let's not take it *too* seriously. Characters here are probably very OOC, I shaped them as I wish to create a fun story ;3
Bloody Romance | Eyeless Jack x Reader by amyau_08
32 parts Complete
Y/n was always considered different too everyone except their Nanna who dies unfortunately. However, Y/n meets the creepypasta's who are similar too them and is welcomed by Slenderman. Some of the creepypasta's don't exactly like this new arrangement at first and others welcome you with open arms. During this time, Y/n is determined too find out what they truly are. However a small love blossoms in between Y/n and the man behind the blue mask. A/n: I'm sorry but not all the famous creepypasta's you know of (cause I'm dumb) will be in this story, but I'll try too add as many as possible, and this is my first story so dont judge me. ⚠️Warning⚠️ *Swearing *Blood, grotesque imagery !Don't read if easily triggered!
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
She's Mine. (Creepypasta x Reader Fanfiction) cover
Living With The Creepypastas (Old) cover
Bittersweet | Ticci Toby cover
Creepypasta Headcannons Book 2 cover
DISCONTINUED | the wind breeze ~ Ticci Toby x Eyeless Jack cover
Fighting Love cover
Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios. cover
A Dance With The Devil (Ticci Toby X Reader) cover
𝚆𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚝𝚑𝚎𝚢? [✔] {Jeff the Killer x Gender Neutral Reader} cover
Bloody Romance | Eyeless Jack x Reader cover

She's Mine. (Creepypasta x Reader Fanfiction)

20 parts Complete Mature

My name is Y/N, and I guess you can say I'm not normal. I met Slenderman one day, while running through the woods, and since then my whole world changed. The reason I'm not normal is because of what happened just a few weeks after I became a pasta. I find out who I really am, and who I love. ----------------------------------------------------- WHO WILL YOU CHOOSE? Ben Drowned? Eyeless Jack? Homicidal Liu? Hoodie? Jeff the Killer? Laughing Jack? Masky? Offenderman? Slenderman? Splendorman? Ticci Toby? Trenderman? [COMPLETED]

More details