I Think I Love You
- Reads 57,863
- Votes 1,443
- Parts 12
Ongoing1h 11m
Last published Wed, Oct 23, 2024
From burning his house down, to being taken in
by a faceless eldritch creature. Toby has now become curious about a certain mask wearing man. He knows just the way to get closer to him, but he realizes this might be more than he bargained for.
Warning for: Gore, medical descriptions/situations, and slight homophobia.
Mansion AU!
art by: yasmimkilleruwu on tumblr
(Rewriting! Slight OOC Toby, personal headcanons ensue. Comments and votes appreciated!)
All Rights Reserved
#8
eyelesstoby
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Dollhouse ( A Creepypasta Fanfiction)
highest rank - #1!! in creepypasta, #40 in fanfiction Brooklynn may only be 6, but she already hates her life. Her father is cheating on her mother. Her mom knows he is cheating, but just drinks away the pain of a broken heart. Her brother does drugs in his room all day. Nobody wants Brooklynn. The only friends she has are her dollies. They listen to her. They help her through this very tough time. But, they can only do so much. Brooklynn had imaginary friends. The only issue with this is... They weren't imaginary.Complete
Bloody Romance | Eyeless Jack x Reader
Y/n was always considered different too everyone except their Nanna who dies unfortunately. However, Y/n meets the creepypasta's who are similar too them and is welcomed by Slenderman. Some of the creepypasta's don't exactly like this new arrangement at first and others welcome you with open arms. During this time, Y/n is determined too find out what they truly are. However a small love blossoms in between Y/n and the man behind the blue mask. A/n: I'm sorry but not all the famous creepypasta's you know of (cause I'm dumb) will be in this story, but I'll try too add as many as possible, and this is my first story so dont judge me. ⚠️Warning⚠️ *Swearing *Blood, grotesque imagery !Don't read if easily triggered!Complete
The Cannibal and The Mute | Eyeless Jack x Mute! Male! Reader
(M/N). A young boy who is unable to speak. Not able to make a sound. To make up for it he has amazing art skills. His parents hated it. They didn't want to pay for lessons to speak.They wanted a child who could talk. Not someone who "waists their time on childish things like drawing." They didn't want to have this.... mistake of a child. They thought they deserved a normal child. So they had another child. Who COULD speak. And they absolutely spoiled and loved him. So Rick naturally was a jerk. Which caused (m/n) to one day crack and lose his sanity after a long beating. He becomes the true demon inside him when it comes to killing. His inner psychopath. As (m/n) walks through the forest, unsure of what to do next, he meets a tall man. A man who could enter (m/n)'s mind. A man who had no face. That man took (m/n) in, into a mansion of killers just like himself. And (m/n) couldn't feel more like at home. (M/N) makes lots of friends. But one caught his eyes the first time they met. The tall man was introducing (m/n) to the rest of the killers. (M/N) saw that most of them had masks. But one particular blue mask caught his eyes. He walked over to the taller male and stared at him in curiosity. He then lifted his hand and reached for the mask. Only to be stopped by a strong hand. "What are you doing?" The taller male lowly growled. (M/N) backed up in fear. Will (m/n) and Jack become friends? Enemies? Or.... Lovers?Complete![Bloody Flowers [TicciJack]](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/396652643-256-k700985.jpg)
Bloody Flowers [TicciJack]
⚠︎There will be mental health struggles, suicide, attempted suicide, death, abuse, violence, and other triggering topics. If any of this is a trigger, please do not read this fan fiction.⚠︎ [insert description] I did not come up with Ticci Toby or Eyeless Jack, they aren't my ocs. Credit to their creators (Azelf500 & Kastoway) 💪 The art isn't mine either 😞 (Yasmim.Killer_UwU) #1 in Marble Hornets - Nov. 8th 2025 #1 in ticcitobyxeyelessjack - Dec. 12th 2025 #1 in proxies - Feb. 10th 2026Complete
𝓢𝓽𝓪𝔂 𝓦𝓲𝓽𝓱 𝓜𝓮 - ❣︎☾︎𝐓𝐢𝐜𝐜𝐢𝐌𝐚𝐬𝐤☽︎❣︎
The rest of the Pastas go out for vacation, leaving only Masky and Toby with the mansion. find out what happens cover credit to LameLies on DeviantArt #1 Tobyrogers 6/11/19 11/24/18 - 01/06/21 !TW! -self-harm -gore -suicide ⋘ » ☆ « ⋙ Authors note - 2024 / 11 / 26 I don't know how this is still doing its rounds or why, but know I wrote this in middle school !!!! I saw 1 person ask about their ages and 2 my knowledge when I wrote this I made them 21 and 25. But I was also like. If you're still interested in my work, I am dysaniaX on ao3. Theres nothing new yet but we can prayComplete
Mask (Ticci Toby x Eyeless Jack)
Toby has been trying to befriend everyone in the mansion for the longest time. Over the years friend groups have emerged. Toby has played a part in creating more than a few of them. He likes to make sure that people feel cared for at the mansion. That was Slenders goal anyway, create a home for the outcasts. Toby among them. So when Jack came along it became a problem. He didn't want to be friends. He didn't want to be cared about. He wanted to be left alone. Toby didn't understand why, but that didn't mean he was going to give up. He would befriend the gloomy bastard if it was the last thing he ever did. Jack never wanted any of this. He wanted a normal life, but what could he do with the cards he was dealt? He is shut off from everyone, for his own safety and theirs. He is dangerous. He can't be trusted. Just like everyone else on this god-forsaken planet. Toby was someone who had managed to get in, not break down his walls but make a door in them. He hated it. He didn't want this. He didn't want to care about the annoying fucker, but he did. And what could he do about it? Nothing. A whole lot of nothing. Jason was quick to realize this and try to use it against him. So out of spite, when the opportunity arose, Jack said fuck it and got closer to Toby. Was this just a ploy to get back at Jason for being an asshole? Or was there something more to this feeling?Complete
highest rank - #1!! in creepypasta, #40 in fanfiction Brooklynn may only be 6, but she already hates her life. Her father is cheating on her mother. Her mom knows he is cheating, but just drinks away the pain of a broken heart. Her brother does drugs in his room all day. Nobody wants Brooklynn. The only friends she has are her dollies. They listen to her. They help her through this very tough time. But, they can only do so much. Brooklynn had imaginary friends. The only issue with this is... They weren't imaginary.
More detailsContent Guidelines