The Way It Used to Be - Shey Cole - Wattpad

Story cover for The Way It Used to Be by sheycole

The Way It Used to Be

Reads 212,881
Votes 7,320
Parts 64
Time 7h 37m

Reads 212,881
Votes 7,320
Parts 64
Time 7h 37m

"Two souls are sometimes created together and in love before they're even born."  -F. Scott Fitzgerald 

When eight year old Beau Ruby met twelve year old Colton Caine, she had no idea she was meeting the love of her life. She had no idea she'd grow up with him, with his story weaved into her world as much as her own. 

She had no idea that at eighteen she'd make a terrible mistake and leave him and everything she knew behind.  She had no idea that she'd tear his heart completely apart.

She had no idea that returning home and finding out that Colton was engaged would hurt her so much. She had no idea if he'd ever love her again. 

She had no idea if it would ever return to the way it used to be. 

                                              •        •        •
"The Way It Used To Be" is a dual perspective story told from different points of view over the course of twelve years in the lives of two best friends who just happened to fall in love.All Rights Reserved

Table of contents

64 parts

Sign up to add The Way It Used to Be to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

I'd Still Choose You by SSGNox

Author's Note: None of these characters depicted in this story is based on a real life counterpart, nor are they under the age of 18. --- Seven years ago, Naya Brooks watched the love of her life walk away - not with anger, but with a promise to become a better man. Now, Isaiah Rhodes is back. Same coffee shop. Same silence. But everything else between them has changed. In a story of love lost, scars buried, and the kind of memories that never fade, two souls must decide if time has broken them... Or if some love is strong enough to survive the years apart. Some goodbyes echo louder than others. And some hearts? They never stop choosing.

Irrevocably Yours by _hellomissannie_

She fell for him when she wasn't supposed to. He broke her heart when she needed him most. Now, five years later, fate is giving them one more chance. When Hanna fell in love with her brother's best friend, she knew it was reckless but she didn't care. Their love was real... until it wasn't. One secret, one night, and everything shattered. Left to raise her daughter alone, Hanna learned to survive without him. But when Johnny unexpectedly walks back into her life and discovers the truth he never knew... everything changes.

Back To You by xxlewixx

Madison thought she had closed the door on Tayler forever. Two years ago, she walked away, leaving behind the only boy who ever truly knew her-the one who made her feel safe, seen... and ultimately, shattered. She swore she'd never look back. But now, fate has other plans. Thrown back into each other's lives, Madison tells herself she's over him. That what they had is nothing more than a distant memory. But Tayler? He makes forgetting impossible. He's still the same cocky, flirtatious guy who knows exactly how to push her buttons-and pull her back in. Every lingering glance, every teasing remark feels like a dangerous game, and she's not sure she knows the rules anymore. But between them stands more than just unfinished business. New love, tangled emotions, and the unshakable weight of what once was. Madison knows she should keep her distance, but when it comes to Tayler, that's always been easier said than done. "You still look at me the same way," she muttered, hating the way her voice wavered. Tayler smirked, stepping closer, his voice low and daring. "And you still get flustered when I do." She should leave. She should mean it this time. But what if their story was never meant to end-just to begin again?

My Untold Love story by meraki_31

Two quiet souls. One undeniable pull. They don't speak, but their eyes do. A connection that builds in silence, where every glance feels louder than words. What happens when noticing turns into needing?

The Fate We Chose by shivyaxwriters

They thought school was the end. But it was only the beginning. Eleven friends. Two farewells. A lifetime of memories waiting to be written. Life scatters them across cities, careers, and dreams. But when they reunite, the laughter, the fights, the secrets, and the unshakable friendship prove one thing distance changes nothing. Because love may arrive in many forms, but friendship is the one promise that never leaves. But. But. But. Life has its way of rewriting stories that started with friendship, soon tangled itself in love triangles, silent heartbreaks, and the weight of unspoken feelings. Fate drew lines where they least expected: family rivalries, forbidden promises, choices between love and hate. Some would find love where they never looked, others would fight to hold on to what was slipping away. And some? It will be uncover soon... In the end, will they fight for their hearts... or let life choose for them?

Yes, Love Sucks! ✔ by WonViolet

Featured on New Beginnings in Romance Picks Anthology at Romance Recognised in 6x Awards - What do you do when your heart pulls you in two different directions? Hi, my name is Olivia Meyer, and I'm a seventeen-year-old girl who has a little confession: falling for Freddie Hutchinson, the school's infamous 'bad boy,' was never part of the plan. I've always been perfectly fine with my low-key life. Books over parties? Check. Silence over drama? Double-check. Honestly, I'm just trying to survive high school with my best friend, Tom McKenzie, by my side since he's the only person who's ever really seen me. But then I got paired with Freddie for a class project. Freddie Hutchinson, with his leather jacket, sharp smirk, and reputation darker than my coffee order. We've never spoken a word to each other before now, but suddenly, I'm seeing sides of him no one else seems to notice. Like the kind-hearted boy hiding beneath the tough exterior. And now my carefully crafted world is starting to crack. Alicia James, the queen bee of high school politics, isn't happy about the Status Quo changing and Tom... well, let's just say he's acting weird. Like, jealous kind of weird. The worst part? I think I might actually like Freddie. Like, love him. You read it right: love him. But if I choose him, I could lose everything else I care about. So, what do I do? Follow my heart, or stick to the plan? Either way, I have a feeling my senior year is about to get way more complicated than ever. Wish me luck. XO Olivia Copyright © 2024 by Alina Bryne

What If I Was Nothing by FearghalLorcan

They loved hard, fought harder, and broke quietly. Ryan and Hannah were supposed to last - the kind of love that survives slammed doors, sleepless nights, and promises said in the dark. But love, as they learned, doesn't always fade in one clean motion. Sometimes it unravels, thread by thread, until you wake up beside someone you no longer recognize. After years of trying to fix what was already gone, Hannah walked away. Ryan stayed - until the silence between them became too heavy to bear. Years later, Ryan has rebuilt his world. A new home. A wife who makes him laugh. A baby boy who carries his smile. He's finally found peace in the wreckage. But when Hannah reappears one morning, holding all the words she never said, both are forced to face the truth: love doesn't die - it changes. And sometimes, the hardest part isn't losing each other. It's learning to live with what remains.

The Bad Boy Saved Me by Pentatonix21

Do you ever wonder what life would be like if it were a movie? Or some sappy romance novel that you wish your life could be like but it's not? Sometimes you may even get to caught up in the fictional world that you don't realise it IS fictional. Then when you do realise life isn't what you convinced yourself it would be, there is only one possible outcome. Depression. Which may lead to anxiety, self-harm, low self esteem, and worst of all, losing the people you love. Life works in weird ways. Not just for you but for others too. Take Cassidy Rivers for example. Her life is far from perfect. No parents, over protective big brother, few friends, and Asher Norman, the bad boy who won't stop picking on her. Could life get any worse for Cassidy?

My Genius Mate by FantasyComeToLife

Ali Baker once adored her pack-until her mother's death forced her father to flee, shattering her world and leaving behind her best friend and first love, Ronan Black. Years later, she turns down Ivy League offers to attend college back home, determined to discover if Ronan is her fated mate. He is-but he already has a girlfriend. As undeniable feelings and their bond resurface, Ronan is torn between loyalty and destiny. When a dangerous vendetta emerges, targeting Ali, the two must fight for their love and their lives, forcing Ronan to confront the dark legacy of his father's past before it destroys them both. **** 'No! No! No! This is not happening!' Ronan panicked as he spoke to me through our mate bond. I could hear the defeat in his voice as I was taken further and further away from him. 'I want you to know that I love you, Ronan. These past few months have been the happiest of my life. I only wished I could have returned the favor to you.' 'Don't say it like you're saying goodbye.' He was in full distraught now. Ronan's voice was breathy and cracked as he spoke to me. 'I'm not. I know you'll find me again.' 'Yeah, I promise. I'll find you, baby. Hold on, ok?' 'I will. I will wait for you. I love you.' 'I love you too, Ali, more than anything. Please just keep -' Suddenly, I was alone. The mate bond was a funny thing. It had its limits. The bond worked like a rubber band. When we were close to each other, it pulled and strained against us, pulling our souls together and allowed us to hear the other's thoughts. That bond allowed us to feel the other's emotions and pain. It was a fantastic thing to be a part of. However, just like taking a rubber band and pulling it as far as possible, it loses strength before breaking entirely. Warning: Story contain graphic details of violence, torture, sexual activity, and curse words.

We're Not Related Anymore... by ElizaJGrant

In which two ex-step-siblings reconnect after just about blowing up their family the first time around... Three years ago, Maddie fell hard for Jacob Isaacs, the smartest boy in her school. The only problem was this: Her dad had quite literally gotten engaged to his mother. The two tried to dampen the flames of their burgeoning attraction for each other but not before they got caught and were the talk of the town for months. After the fall out, Maddie moved away to try and start her life over and not be known as the girl who got caught doing it with her 'brother' at prom. She hasn't seen her family in ages and intends to keep things that way. Jacob, on the other hand, has worked hard to accomplish everything he's ever dreamed of. He's stayed close to home, done exceptionally well at school, and is adored by just about everyone who meets him. There's only one problem: There's a Maddie-shaped hole where his heart used to be. But no matter how hard he tries to reach out and find her, he can't. She won't let him. He let her down and gave up on them when she needed him most. And she's not ready to forgive and forget. But then Maddie's dad passes and she's forced to come home for his funeral. It should be a quick visit. She intends to make it one. But Jacob has other plans. He let his girl slip through his fingers once and he won't let that happen again. So now he has to convince her to give him one more chance. After all, they're not related to each other anymore.

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

I'd Still Choose You cover

Irrevocably Yours cover

Back To You cover

My Untold Love story cover

The Fate We Chose cover

Yes, Love Sucks! ✔ cover

What If I Was Nothing cover

The Bad Boy Saved Me cover

My Genius Mate cover

We're Not Related Anymore... cover

I'd Still Choose You

Author's Note: None of these characters depicted in this story is based on a real life counterpart, nor are they under the age of 18. --- Seven years ago, Naya Brooks watched the love of her life walk away - not with anger, but with a promise to become a better man. Now, Isaiah Rhodes is back. Same coffee shop. Same silence. But everything else between them has changed. In a story of love lost, scars buried, and the kind of memories that never fade, two souls must decide if time has broken them... Or if some love is strong enough to survive the years apart. Some goodbyes echo louder than others. And some hearts? They never stop choosing.