Sally's Sister Sarah - ollie w. - Wattpad

Sally's Sister Sarah

refurbished2024

Reads 17,799
Votes 402
Parts 12
Time 49m

Reads 17,799
Votes 402
Parts 12
Time 49m

refurbished2024

creepy creepypasta creepypastagirls creepypastastory horror sally

Sally's death affected a lot of people. Especially her Twin Sister Sarah, who can barely cope without her twin sister. Sarah and Sally were very close together; Too close together for Sarah's safety in the future...

(I wrote this when i was like 12 okay 😂)All Rights Reserved

creepy creepypasta creepypastagirls creepypastastory horror sally

Table of contents

12 parts

Sign up to add Sally's Sister Sarah to your library and receive updates

or

#79creepypastastory

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Sing a Song of Sixpence (CreepyPasta X Reader) by Blob_Fish_05

(Y/N) was just an ordinary(ish) girl, she was happy for the first 5 years of her life. After that, her father left her and her mother. Her mother started to hate (Y/N). (Y/N) didn't care, she had an aunt and uncle and two cousins that were about her age, soon her aunt,uncle, and cousins die. One night (Y/N) wakes up to see a shape with a knife, as it got closer she realized it was her (Dead) cousin...

The daughter of Slenderman by BloodyHeartDash

Slenderman had a hidden secret that only his brothers knew- he had a daughter. They all loved her but never told the other Creepypastas... until her 20th birthday. And when everyone met her. They all loved her, but Jeff had deeper feelings for her... Hey, this is my first book, so I'm sorry if it's terrible, plz don't hate me!

Heartless with a heart by Ballora06

(Attempt at a creepypasta with an updated version of an old oc) Elizabeth was feeling more and more melancholic. Just like usual. But one day, a gruesome murder of a family of 4 would change her life. Strange events and multiple murders made her heart filled with anxiety and fear. But between that, love found it's way into her blank heart. Who is behind those murders? A psychopathic human being? Or worse. A hungry creature from the deepest pits of hell.

Sally's Story (Romance) by Creepypasta_girl15

Sally Williams was just a normal little eight year old girl until her Uncle Johnny raped and killed her. Now she has to find her place in this world when she finds out she's immortal. But how will she handle it if she starts to fall in love? Will she try leaving the pasta's? Only time will show. What do you think will happen if the chance comes up for Sally to live again? Will she take it or keep the life she has now?

Jeff The Killer x Reader Book One by _Jello_101_

This story is going to be about Y/N that feels like she dosent matter in life and no one loves her, she just feels like she is alone in life. Then one night as she is sleeping, Jeff brakes into her house and kills her whole family, and tries to kill her. Be aware, Its my first Creepypasta story, so just be slow with me, anyways, enjoy! Book started April 2nd, 2018 Book ended July 12th, 2018

Your My Sister?! (siren x creepypasta ) by LazariNyres

Nightmare forever, missing her sister. She was part of something that changed her life complete. Will she someday change or will she forever keep everyone in the shallows. What happens when she meets a girl that could possible save her life and......

Her Story by ShatteredDusk

She stared into the forest her younger brother by her side. Their new family was in there but for now they had to deal with their mother. Who has a mysterious past that makes her jumpy and weary of her daughter. One wrong move may set the mother off and when that happens what will the siblings do? Will they make it to their new family?

For All Of Eternity (A Sally Creepypasta Fanfiction) by ForevermoreSoul

《1st Place in Sally category - Fall Awards 2016 | Admin's Choice - CreepyPasta_Awards》 "You can't leave the horror behind; it's a part of you." Sally Williams was a young, bright girl until she met a cruel fate by the hands of a man with cruel desires. Ever since she died, the horror comes back to her, over and over again, like a reoccurring nightmare. This child, scarred by her past, is engulfed by a powerfully wicked anger and an urge that she doesn't yet understand. In her search for answers, she only comes across more questions. Crossing paths with killers doesn't seem to make her situation any easier, despite the help some of them offer. Plagued with immortality, little Sally will be met with decisions that may forever haunt her. With eternity in sight, what can a young girl do? What does she most desire, and what will it take to get it? ~*~*~*~*~Praise for For All of Eternity~*~*~*~*~ "Can't stop the tears...This is so real, that's why it hurts so much...Bittersweet and beautiful. And oh so much sorrow..." ~LokisPuppet "Thank you so much for writing this. Honestly, not a lot of stories--much less, fanfiction--give me a new perspective on the world..." ~pastel-feels "Rereading this because it's one of the few creepypasta fan fiction that doesn't give into the stereotypes. You portray each character as if they were your own, honestly. I've never seen someone get their personalities so down pat." ~Anonymous "Omg!!! Literally all I can say is oh my gosh!...this was such a beautifully written story. I can't even put into words how good it was." ~lizthecraze

A Dark Mind (sequel to A Sally Creepypasta Story) by BoneyardHorizons

(Sequel to A Sally Creepypasta Story) After Jeff's death everyone is still hating Sally, but she soon gains their trust and love back, from some. One day when she's out killing she finds a new family member? Who is the family member? And will Sally finally kill uncle Johnny? Read to find out! (Cover picture does not belong to me)

Come Little Children by TheBookWorm1215

A young girl who has lost her parents, her siblings, and her sanity has become a murderer. She meets Slenderman and some of his "family". Will she find love, a new family, and start to love herself instead of just hating? Can she gain or will she fall even further into hate? Creepypasta X Reader. Violence and swearing.

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Sing a Song of Sixpence (CreepyPasta X Reader) cover

The daughter of Slenderman cover

Heartless with a heart cover

Sally's Story (Romance) cover

Jeff The Killer x Reader Book One cover

Your My Sister?! (siren x creepypasta ) cover

Her Story cover

For All Of Eternity (A Sally Creepypasta Fanfiction) cover

A Dark Mind (sequel to A Sally Creepypasta Story) cover

Come Little Children cover

Sing a Song of Sixpence (CreepyPasta X Reader)

(Y/N) was just an ordinary(ish) girl, she was happy for the first 5 years of her life. After that, her father left her and her mother. Her mother started to hate (Y/N). (Y/N) didn't care, she had an aunt and uncle and two cousins that were about her age, soon her aunt,uncle, and cousins die. One night (Y/N) wakes up to see a shape with a knife, as it got closer she realized it was her (Dead) cousin...