What Could Have Been... (Carmella & OC) - Stuey - Wattpad

What Could Have Been... (Carmella & OC)

Reads 43,057
Votes 432
Parts 20
Time 3h 29m

Reads 43,057
Votes 432
Parts 20
Time 3h 29m

bayley beckylynch carmella embermoon laceyevans mandyrose wwe

After Matt Watkins arrives on the WWE scene, the entire wrestling world is shook. The biggest free agent decided to persue new career goals and reach the top, as he felt the world was crumbling around him when he lost his childhood sweetheart, Katie, after she died after a tragic accident, but at the same time, doctors were able to save their unborn daughter, who Matt would name Amy. From then on, Matt vowed that any success in his life would be dedicated to her. 

Leah, or Carmella, as she's better known, has had a rollercoaster ride since the draft in 2016. First Miss Money In The Bank, becoming Smackdown Women's Champion, and most recently, the Women's Battle Royal Winner at Wrestlemania 35. But since then, she's fallen under the radar, in more ways than one. Ever since she called it off with her ex Big Cass, she's never really been one for finding love.

But will Matt and Amy change her views? Or will Leah continue to fly solo on life?

Ranked #1 in #mandyrose - 07-03-21

Ranked #1 in #carmella - 20-06-21All Rights Reserved

bayley beckylynch carmella embermoon laceyevans mandyrose wwe

20 parts

Sign up to add What Could Have Been... (Carmella & OC) to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Never Will Be The Same// Liv Morgan FanFic by xXxhufflepunkxXx

Zarlielyn was a tough person to crack and never let anything get to her. She grew up with no family and was always seen as an outcast until Finn Balor adopts her, now she is apart of the WWE family and has finally found out who she truly is. but will she be able to face the challenges ahead?... Or will she fail to make her weak points something like a boost of power against those who doubt her? --------------------------- Warning: This story contains self harm, I will put a warning to warn those who are sensitive to said subjects.

The Accident by Giraffe502

FIRST BOOK IN THE ACCIDENT SERIES One day everything is normal, things are finally taking off in Becky's career and she's feeling great. But then something happens that just changes everything... Word Count - 29,790

My Best Friend's Wedding [Bayley x Finn Bálor] by inzayn078

Bayley Martinez was never the one for relationships. She had had a few bad ones, and after her last one, she never wanted to date again. Until her best friend invites her to her wedding. Her best friend, Becky Lynch has been set to get married for over a year now. Bayley is her maid of honor and she couldn't be less excited. Bayley doesn't like to leave the house, and hates public outings. <><><><><> Finn Bálor is the most sweet and caring guy any girl could ever meet. He's been in two relationships before, but hasn't found his perfect girlfriend yet. Until his best friend invites him to his wedding. Sami Zayn has been set to marry the love of his life, Becky Lynch, for over a year now. Finn is asked to be the best man, and of course he accepts. <><><><><> When Finn and Bayley first meet, it's not the best meeting. Bayley can't wait to leave the event and Finn can't help but want to stay. While trying to make her stay and enjoy herself, he also captures her heart. <><><><><>

The Aftermath by Giraffe502

SECOND BOOK IN THE ACCIDENT Jail, a path Becky never thought she'd be walking down. Guilt, fear and even something most people consider to be a blessing...pregnancy. Becky is all alone and just doesn't know what to do, Colby blames her for her actions and Ashley can't help but feel guilty for letting her best friend go down for something she didn't do! Will things work out or will help they all fall apart when they need each other most? Word count: 44,404

Only We Say (Alexa Bliss x Male Reader) by CalebQuacknum

"Sometimes you sink so deep in this ocean of doubt and self-pity that you can't even see light anymore. It's okay to cry, but at some point you have to decide whether you're going to drown or start swimming back towards the surface." A young WWE superstar believes he's lost everything when the love of his life leaves him and tries to destroy his reputation. However, he'll soon find out that life has a way of guiding him exactly where he needs to be... right into the arms of a Goddess.

An IIcon's True Love (Peyton Royce & OC) by StueyBoii

After long time friend and tag team partner Billie Kay turned on her and eliminated her from the Royal Rumble, Peyton Royce had never felt more alone. She had felt betrayed and let down. So how will she react when an old penpal of hers comes back into her life... And also coincidentally happens to be Billie's ex?! Ranked #1 in #carmella and #embermoon, #3 in #candicelerae and #4 in #billiekay - 07-03-21 Ranked #1 in #peytonroyce - 15-06-21

Luck of the Irish (Becky Lynch x Male Reader) by CalebQuacknum

You just won the WWE Championship and had an incredible night with the newly-single Becky Lynch. Can you keep your title and create something beautiful at the same time?

MADNESS | FINN BÀLOR [1] by lahnistersden

❝He was everyone else's worst nightmare but her daydream.❞ After Finn Balor left NXT, A new rising talent took his place. Logan Perris had rose up to fame in her TNA days, and then clawed her way through the NXT Division. The Demon King rules the Raw Roster, bringing pure terror in his opponent's eyes. When Logan, who is just as sick and twisted as Finn Balor's alter ego gets moved into the main roster, there's only enough room for one Demon. |EXTENDED SUMMARY INSIDE| |BOOK ONE OF THE LOGAN PERRIS SERIES| HIGHEST RANKINGS #2 for finnbalor

The Runaway (Brollins) by tropicalpunch123

Rebecca Quin has never had it easy in life, especially in relationships. So after escaping from her abusive ex, Rebecca and her 3 year old daughter Saylor are trying to survive being alone. When Rebecca's best friend Colby let's them move in with him, they finally get to experience what love really is. *does contain verbal and physical abuse

$Always the Opposites {Brollins} by H_Ashbaugh$

Determination, hard work, and independence have always been the three key ingredients in the foundation of Rebecca's life. After all, they're all she's ever known. However, when everything seems to be piling up on her, and things get a lot tougher than they used to be, Rebecca realizes that maybe not every battle needs to be fought alone. Based on the "Unlikely Partnerships" one shot. Started- November 9th, 2021 Finished- March 4th, 2022

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Never Will Be The Same// Liv Morgan FanFic cover

The Accident cover

My Best Friend's Wedding [Bayley x Finn Bálor] cover

The Aftermath cover

Only We Say (Alexa Bliss x Male Reader) cover

An IIcon's True Love (Peyton Royce & OC) cover

Luck of the Irish (Becky Lynch x Male Reader) cover

MADNESS | FINN BÀLOR [1] cover

The Runaway (Brollins) cover

Always the Opposites {Brollins} cover

Never Will Be The Same// Liv Morgan FanFic

Zarlielyn was a tough person to crack and never let anything get to her. She grew up with no family and was always seen as an outcast until Finn Balor adopts her, now she is apart of the WWE family and has finally found out who she truly is. but will she be able to face the challenges ahead?... Or will she fail to make her weak points something like a boost of power against those who doubt her? --------------------------- Warning: This story contains self harm, I will put a warning to warn those who are sensitive to said subjects.