Steve and Bucky are both invited to a party, unknowing of the other's invitation. They lie to the other in order to go to said party, which is a masquerade party. They both go and end up dancing together, but neither gives up their identity. They try to find their "Mystery Men" in a desperate a attempt to rid their crushes on each other. Steve discovers Bucky's mask while cleaning and contemplates is he should tell him, or forever keep up the lie.