Evan and Jason have despised each other since they could remember and no one knows why. No one brought it up, until a young brunette by the name of Kimberly comes along.
Evan and Jason immediately take a liking to her and try to win her. Kim, however, refuses both of their advances and they continue fighting for her, even if she has feelings for one of them already.
Soon, Cassie tries to plays matchmaker but finds herself in the middle of her own drama. Either way, she still is helping one of the guys while the other is surprisingly succeeding on his own.
Soon, Kim has now fallen for Evan and Jason hard and can't get back on her feet. When they give her the ultimatum to choose one of them or none of them, she's hurt but with the help of her friends she found the one. Will she choose the bad boy gone good, Evan or the sweetheart hidden as a jerk, Jason? Who will she choose?