What If? The Phantom of the Opera (fan-fiction) - Marlo Avidon - Wattpad

What If? The Phantom of the Opera (fan-fiction)

Reads 7,005
Votes 251
Parts 12
Time 1h 24m

Reads 7,005
Votes 251
Parts 12
Time 1h 24m

broadway christine creative daae erik fanfic love musical opera phanfic phanfiction phantom phantomoftheopera poto raoul showtunes theatre titanic what

After the events of the infamous Andrew Lloyd Webber music, The Phantom of the Opera, many rabid fans are left longing to know what happens next in the story of Christine Daae and her Angel of Music. While a sequel, Love Never Dies, does exist, this is my individual interpretation of the events following the tragic downfall of the Opera Populaire. 

"What If" is a thrilling take on the classic love story of the Phantom of the Opera, answering the age old question, "What if Christine and the Phantom were not truly separated?" With a flourish of colorful characters, "What If" channels the emotions of Christine, Erik, and a myriad of other characters, giving life to a new generation of Phantom fans. 

After the events of "Don Juan Triumphant", Christine is left longing for her Angel, as Erik, the Phantom, begins to lose hope of ever finding his love, or his soul. When Erik is taken in by a young girl and her family, he finds himself in a new, high society world, full 
deceit, lust, cruelty, and treachery. Christine finds herself struggling to adjust to a normal life, and she is terrified of the idea of raising a family, and she is waiting for the day when she will be saved from her life of normality.

For those interested in an enthralling work of Phantom of the Opera fan fiction, or a theatre lover of any sort, this fan fiction is a window into the whirlwind of events following the iconic musical.

All characters belong to Andrew Lloyd Webber and A Very Useful Theatre Company unless otherwise stated.

Events in the story are made from a combination of the Broadway musical, the 2004  Schumacher film, as well as my own imagination. Enjoy!All Rights Reserved

broadway christine creative daae erik fanfic love musical opera phanfic phanfiction phantom phantomoftheopera poto raoul showtunes theatre titanic what

Table of contents

12 parts

Sign up to add What If? The Phantom of the Opera (fan-fiction) to your library and receive updates

or

#865phantomoftheopera

Content Guidelines

You may also like

The Treasure *Phantom of the Opera* (sequel to The Quest) by AngelofMystery145

1871- Two lost souls found their dreams in Seville, but the dangers are far from eliminated, while in France a new terror has arisen. *some fantasy* based on 2004 movie- STRONG sexual situations E/C, R/M. All usual disclaimers apply; I don't own the PotO characters or music, but the original songs and characters are mine. Based solely on the Erik/Christine of 2004 movie (how I perceived them)- but still a high fantasy with Erik as a King of Music and Christine his Queen. Please note the M/MA rating - it's there for a reason. This story is very explicit at times as far as sex goes, increasing as story progresses- no-holds-barred- so please be warned. There are also other adult situations that warrant the M... All pictures/ book covers shown are my creation - E/C manips I made to go with scenes in my story.

Last-Chance1A's Phantom Writer by Last-Chance1A

Hey welcome to Phantom Writer a modern version of Phantom of the Opera. Now please let me explain this help better understand the story, now originally this was gonna to be like Candyman and Phantom of the Opera, later on I added things from not only Conjuring but Insidious along with a few things from Phantom the Musical. I just wanted to let y'all know that this might be if not one of the hardest stories I had to write, but that's if you don't count Michiru x Nazuna (Original) which was a nightmare to write or Dead-End's Road which has me come up with new ideas for it. And that's not to put down anyone who wants to write or are writing a Phantom of the Opera, it's a beautiful story on love, music, and tragedy, it's what I love about Phantom of the Opera, and that shines through with the Characters. And I know I can't do Phantom of the Opera without saying something about the Phantom and I just want to say I understand he is misunderstood for his looks which is sad and is the reason he became the Phantom, but this Phantom was understood but became the Phantom for what can be an honestly be called a simple mistake, Christine and Raoul are also a big part of the story for Christine being the only one to truly understand the Phantom, Raoul has trouble trying to understand yet wants to help Christine with the Phantom which is one of the great parts of the story. On a side note is this will get Mature at some points, and don't mistake this on "it's because he based it on three horror movies." Buddy that's not it, the reason is that how all my new stories are gonna be like going forward, it gives me more freedom to get away with things I normally can't with a normal story Anyway I'll stop stalling you and start the reading

Her Innocence || Phantom of the Opera by SimpleSav

"Christine, I love you." The phantom's voice played a sweet tune in my mind. It was the first time he had confessed his love, but sadly, I couldn't return the favor. He had given me everything, fame, fortune, and a life of excitement and curiosity. Still, he had threatened to hang my beloved Raoul and sentence me to an eternity locked away from the world. My clammy hands shook with emotion as I slid the beautiful, diamond ring off my finger. The disfigured man helplessly gazed into my eyes, transforming my soul. I was the only one to look past his hideous physical appearance, to know how to comfort a creature of darkness; I couldn't bare holding in my emotions any longer. Tears plunged down my pale cheeks and I looked down to take his hand. Making sure not to drop the small item, I closed his rough fingers around the ring. "Goodbye," all sadness echoing through my word. I spun around and dragged my wedding dress through the foggy water to meet Raoul's awaiting boat. *** UPDATE 2020: Hello, all! I realized that this book recently gained traction in the fanfic world of Wattpad, again. Unfortunately, I wrote this back in 2014 and have yet to go through and edit. At one point, I planned on making a sequel to this. I don't expect to do so any time soon, but I appreciate the reads and the comments!

Let Your Fantasies Unwind by TheMegaNut

What if the Phantom wasn't alone pulling off all those tricks? What if he had an assistant? And what if his assistant knew him? This is the story of Megan Williams, a girl from the future with a passion for Phantom of the Opera, the fictional world that she grew up with... is now her reality. ____________ This will be a 'slow burn' as my friend calls it. Most of the story is building the relationship between Erik and Megan, and then everything comes crashing down. ;-) Sunday, Wednesday, and Friday updates. Completed. Found the image on Google Images. Don't know who's the original artist. ^^;

Like Father, Like Son | Phantom of the Opera by nerdywriter36

Christine is dead and the Phantom is alone once more. But this time...not completely. He now has Gustave, their child, with him. After learning the truth, he is determined to stay with his true father. Though talented in many areas, will fatherhood be the one skill Erik cannot master? A collab with my awesome IRL friend @Buddy_2002! Gif banner and cover by the amazing @BrendaDaaeDestler! Winner of Best General Phanfic and Best Summary in The Phantom's Rose Awards hosted by @BrendaDaaeDestler! Cover also by @BrendaDaaeDestler <3 Elements pulled from both 'Phantom of the Opera' as well as 'Love Never Dies', written by Andrew Lloyd Webber, with heavy influence from 'Phantom' by Susan Kay

Always there singing songs in my head (A Phantom of the Opera fanfiction) by TheCreator900

Erik has been searching for his soulmate for a long time. You see, he can hear his soulmate singing in his mind but he's never known whose the voice belongs to. For a while, he thought it was Christine because she could hear a voice too. But he later learned it was her childhood sweetheart, Raoul. After his many murders and accidentally burning down the Opera House, he searches for his mysterious soulmate. As he searches for a way to leave Paris, he meets a young sailor named (Y/N) (L/N). She is part of a crew of a trading ship that she escaped on when she was only ten years old. When (Y/N) lets Erik leave and work on the ship, Erik sees and learns things he never thought he'd learn. But his soulmate has gone silent since he met her. Has something happened to her? Only by traveling into the unknown will give him the answers he needs. DISCLAIMER! I don't own you, Erik, Phantom of the Opera, any songs, pictures, videos, etc. This is a Soulmate AU. I got inspiration from a YouTube comment on a duet of Into the Unknown sung by Elsa and Panic! At The Disco. So, credit to this idea goes to that comment. I don't remember the username or if they want to be mentioned. So credit that comment should you find it. Enjoy the book.

Our Love is Evergreen by BrendaDaaeDestler

In this sequel to The Phantom of the Opera (2004 film), Christine Daaé decides to run away and marry her Angel of Music, Erik Destler, and leave former lover, the Viscount Raoul de Chagny, behind. What new adventures await the couple as they adjust to their new home and married life? Old book title: Together At Last

Love Never Dies by mehhudson

The Phantom fled France with Madame Giry, Meg Giry, and a small child to America in hopes of starting over in life. No one knew of the little girl or even where she came from, but the Phantom kept it a secret, refusing to tell anyone, especially his daughter. But when his daughter comes to him begging for information about her mother, he finally reveals who she is: Christine Daae. When he learns of his daughter's problem of voices in her head, he knows Christine must meet her child. As well as this meeting should have gone, it is ten times worse. Revenge plots are made, murder is attempted and relationships are tested. Who will come out on top once the smoke has cleared?

The Phantom Ascending |✔| [Phantom of the Opera Fanfiction] by olivesky

Christine left and the Phantom of the Opera sank into despair. Yet when he discovers something magical in Cornwall, it will set him on the road toward Christine again. And she now resides in Venice, the city of gondolas, carnivals and mists... A tale of anguish, heartbreak, hope and love; of obsession and redemption. The story of the Phantom of the Opera continues, and the everlasting emotions unravel once again. Act I -- A short story about Erik after the final lair Act II -- A brief insight into Christine's time with Raoul Act III, IV & V -- Main plot unravels and new mysteries arise. Packed with romance and all the feels. -- Cover by the wonderful @Juliette_Aurora :) -- The Phantom of the Opera (2004) fanfiction, set after the final lair scene, and best enjoyed after you've watched the movie or the stage musical. -- The Phantom of the Opera was originally created by Gaston Leroux, and the musical adaptation belongs to Lloyd Webber/Hart/Stilgoe. All concepts and characters belong to their respective owners, and this work is nonprofit. It's intended for entertainment and wish fulfillment only, not being a part of the official storyline.

If Can Fix an Opera House, I Can Fix You by Djalidagoat77

{TRIGGER WARNINGS WILL BE AT THE TOP OF CHAPTERS WHERE IT APPLIES} Erik X OC Moving to Paris can erase the past, right? That is what Flint Hatcherfield is hoping to happen. If buying an opera house and moving away from your home of London is a good way to get over a horrible breakup then Flint is doing the right thing! It's just an abandoned opera house, how bad can it be? ++++ But when your plans to rot there as a forgotten ghost is interrupted by some bubbly Londoner, you aren't the most sociable. Erik's angel Christine Daae is gone forever, and now he plans to slowly die alone. He has to get Flint away somehow, and he knows what he has to do. {With betrayal, plot twists, drama, new beginnings, and hope that can either be cherished or shattered?..} Will this Opera House get new life, and will these broken men get one along with it? Because if I can fix an Opera House, then I can fix you.

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

The Treasure *Phantom of the Opera* (sequel to The Quest) cover

Last-Chance1A's Phantom Writer cover

Her Innocence || Phantom of the Opera cover

Let Your Fantasies Unwind cover

Like Father, Like Son | Phantom of the Opera cover

Always there singing songs in my head (A Phantom of the Opera fanfiction) cover

Our Love is Evergreen cover

Love Never Dies cover

The Phantom Ascending |✔| [Phantom of the Opera Fanfiction] cover

If Can Fix an Opera House, I Can Fix You cover

The Treasure Phantom of the Opera (sequel to The Quest)

1871- Two lost souls found their dreams in Seville, but the dangers are far from eliminated, while in France a new terror has arisen. some fantasy based on 2004 movie- STRONG sexual situations E/C, R/M. All usual disclaimers apply; I don't own the PotO characters or music, but the original songs and characters are mine. Based solely on the Erik/Christine of 2004 movie (how I perceived them)- but still a high fantasy with Erik as a King of Music and Christine his Queen. Please note the M/MA rating - it's there for a reason. This story is very explicit at times as far as sex goes, increasing as story progresses- no-holds-barred- so please be warned. There are also other adult situations that warrant the M... All pictures/ book covers shown are my creation - E/C manips I made to go with scenes in my story.