What If? The Phantom of the Opera (fan-fiction) - Marlo Avidon - Wattpad

Story cover for What If? The Phantom of the Opera (fan-fiction) by MarloWrites

What If? The Phantom of the Opera (fan-fiction)

Reads 7,023
Votes 251
Parts 12
Time 1h 24m

Reads 7,023
Votes 251
Parts 12
Time 1h 24m

broadway christine creative daae erik fanfic love musical opera phanfic phanfiction phantom phantomoftheopera poto raoul showtunes theatre titanic what

After the events of the infamous Andrew Lloyd Webber music, The Phantom of the Opera, many rabid fans are left longing to know what happens next in the story of Christine Daae and her Angel of Music. While a sequel, Love Never Dies, does exist, this is my individual interpretation of the events following the tragic downfall of the Opera Populaire. 

"What If" is a thrilling take on the classic love story of the Phantom of the Opera, answering the age old question, "What if Christine and the Phantom were not truly separated?" With a flourish of colorful characters, "What If" channels the emotions of Christine, Erik, and a myriad of other characters, giving life to a new generation of Phantom fans. 

After the events of "Don Juan Triumphant", Christine is left longing for her Angel, as Erik, the Phantom, begins to lose hope of ever finding his love, or his soul. When Erik is taken in by a young girl and her family, he finds himself in a new, high society world, full 
deceit, lust, cruelty, and treachery. Christine finds herself struggling to adjust to a normal life, and she is terrified of the idea of raising a family, and she is waiting for the day when she will be saved from her life of normality.

For those interested in an enthralling work of Phantom of the Opera fan fiction, or a theatre lover of any sort, this fan fiction is a window into the whirlwind of events following the iconic musical.

All characters belong to Andrew Lloyd Webber and A Very Useful Theatre Company unless otherwise stated.

Events in the story are made from a combination of the Broadway musical, the 2004  Schumacher film, as well as my own imagination. Enjoy!All Rights Reserved

broadway christine creative daae erik fanfic love musical opera phanfic phanfiction phantom phantomoftheopera poto raoul showtunes theatre titanic what

Table of contents

12 parts

Sign up to add What If? The Phantom of the Opera (fan-fiction) to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Let Your Fantasies Unwind by TheMegaNut

What if the Phantom wasn't alone pulling off all those tricks? What if he had an assistant? And what if his assistant knew him? This is the story of Megan Williams, a girl from the future with a passion for Phantom of the Opera, the fictional world that she grew up with... is now her reality. ____________ This will be a 'slow burn' as my friend calls it. Most of the story is building the relationship between Erik and Megan, and then everything comes crashing down. ;-) Sunday, Wednesday, and Friday updates. Completed. Found the image on Google Images. Don't know who's the original artist. ^^;

Phantom's Journey (Phantom of the Opera/Love Never Dies) by GhostLoveWriter

A story of what happens after Love Never Dies, the sequel play to The Phantom of the Opera. When Christine is gone, she leaves behind three men who loved her: Gustave, her young son; Raoul, her faithful yet troubled husband; and Erik, her Angel of Music. Each one must learn to move on and live without her. I don't own the characters; all rights go to their creators. This is just a fanfiction. BEGUN: August 16, 2016 COMPLETED: October 1, 2016 FIRST EDITING: January 2017 SECOND EDITING: August 12, 2017

A Girl's Desire (Phantom Of The Opera x Reader) by LatestParis_Style

[COMPLETE] When Y/n signed a risky contract with the Phantom, then agreed to spend six months living in the basement with him, she was clueless about what the future held. Like the dutiful errand girl Y/n is, she follows his commands precisely-until lives tangle in a mess that she's responsible for. After Christine leaves forever, will Y/n build a life from the ashes of ruin, or will her dreams crumble around her? #1 in erikxreader 6/3/23 #1 in raouldechagny 5/28/23

Phantom's Understudy by AmberForDays

**A Phantom of the Opera Fan Fiction** The Phantom's plan was perfect - get rid of the Prima Donna and surely Christine will be the only one that could play the part. It's been stated several times - "There is no understudy for La Carlotta!" ...but what if there is? Elizabeth Bell seems like she is just another chorus girl, but she steps up confirming that she is the understudy for the role. After a successful opening night, she learns that she has gotten in the way of the infamous Opera Ghost's plans and now has to abide by his rules or leave. What is she going to do now? Especially when she starts to get to know this mysterious man behind the mask? Does she stay in the shadows of the Opera or move on? **Author's note** I know I'm late to the game with these fanfictions but I have been obsessed with Phantom of the Opera for about 15 years and have been wanting to post something for a while. Feedback is more than welcome! And, of course, I do not own the Phantom of the Opera or its characters.

Last-Chance1A's Phantom Writer by Last-Chance1A

Hey welcome to Phantom Writer a modern version of Phantom of the Opera. Now please let me explain this help better understand the story, now originally this was gonna to be like Candyman and Phantom of the Opera, later on I added things from not only Conjuring but Insidious along with a few things from Phantom the Musical. I just wanted to let y'all know that this might be if not one of the hardest stories I had to write, but that's if you don't count Michiru x Nazuna (Original) which was a nightmare to write or Dead-End's Road which has me come up with new ideas for it. And that's not to put down anyone who wants to write or are writing a Phantom of the Opera, it's a beautiful story on love, music, and tragedy, it's what I love about Phantom of the Opera, and that shines through with the Characters. And I know I can't do Phantom of the Opera without saying something about the Phantom and I just want to say I understand he is misunderstood for his looks which is sad and is the reason he became the Phantom, but this Phantom was understood but became the Phantom for what can be an honestly be called a simple mistake, Christine and Raoul are also a big part of the story for Christine being the only one to truly understand the Phantom, Raoul has trouble trying to understand yet wants to help Christine with the Phantom which is one of the great parts of the story. On a side note is this will get Mature at some points, and don't mistake this on "it's because he based it on three horror movies." Buddy that's not it, the reason is that how all my new stories are gonna be like going forward, it gives me more freedom to get away with things I normally can't with a normal story Anyway I'll stop stalling you and start the reading

Between Mirrors and Roses (A Phantom of the Opera Fanfiction) ✓ by persephone7913

The life of an ordinary girl is turned upside down when she is transported into her favorite musical, "The Phantom of the Opera," in the place of the elegant heroine. Negotiating life in 19th-century Paris is challenging enough without a diva scheming for leads, a sarcastic Persian's input, and two very different men battling for her affections! Should she stay faithful to the plot of the story or rewrite history? Should she choose a safe path with a reliable husband or risk her future following her mysterious Phantom? Told from the points of view of Erik - the Phantom - and the newly-made Christine, this story follows them both as they work through their respective demons to find love in the person that is a little different from all their imaginings. "A really well-written Erik/OC, with a lovely, smart, likable heroine. If you ever fantasized about taking Christine's place in POTO, read this." - @olivesky "I am literally crying right now. That was so good!" - @musicalsnmarkiplier "One of the best fan fictions I have ever read" - @elephant_hugger "I just discovered this today and finished it in one go. This is an extraordinary work, Erik deserves you to portray him 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻" - @Myatnoe123 "Sacrificing a few hours of sleep was worth finishing this." - @LiberDose "I must confess you've ruined all other Phantom of the Opera fanfictions" - @LilRed315 "Thank you for the 2-in-the-morning giggles, the falling-out-of-the-bed-blushing phangirl moments, and just writing this book in general! You are the best author!" - @ThatBabyQuinnDoh *Now available to read on archiveofourown.org* Disclaimer: I do not own The Phantom of the Opera or its characters. Highest rankings: #1 in PHANTOMOFTHEOPERA #1 in PHANFICTION #1 in Daae

Like Father, Like Son | Phantom of the Opera by nerdywriter36

Christine is dead and the Phantom is alone once more. But this time...not completely. He now has Gustave, their child, with him. After learning the truth, he is determined to stay with his true father. Though talented in many areas, will fatherhood be the one skill Erik cannot master? A collab with my awesome IRL friend @Buddy_2002! Gif banner and cover by the amazing @BrendaDaaeDestler! Winner of Best General Phanfic and Best Summary in The Phantom's Rose Awards hosted by @BrendaDaaeDestler! Cover also by @BrendaDaaeDestler <3 Elements pulled from both 'Phantom of the Opera' as well as 'Love Never Dies', written by Andrew Lloyd Webber, with heavy influence from 'Phantom' by Susan Kay

Unconditional Love || A Phantom of the Opera Fanfiction || by Phantom_Christine_5

One event changed everything in Christine Daae's life. Erik Destlar fell in love with her and decided to take her to live with him. Will she ever love him back? Modern day, E/C... COMPLETED ___________________________________________________________ I do NOT claim the original work of Gaston Leroux "The Phantom of the Opera." I also do NOT condone things discussed, written, or otherwise made known through my work such as stalking, kidnapping, marrying kidnappers/stalkers, or the like. My only wish is to make Leroux's book accessible to modern readers with a few plot twists here and there. I can only hope I have done his acclaimed work justice with my retelling.

Remembering the Angel by Phangirl1905

What if the curtain never fell? What if that bullet had never killed Christine? Could it be too good to be true? Christine Daae wakes up on a pier surrounded by frightened faces. She recognizes no one. She is thrown back into her life with out being able to remember what it was. She is a mother? She was a wife? Who is it she feels, but never fears, always standing by her side? The Phantom must fight himself now. How can he help Christine to remember their love without showing her the monster he once was? And their son...He needs her back. His world, his light, his Angel will remember their story. He will write the songs of their other time brought to life. (All rights to songs/ Characters/ Mentions of previous story lines go to Andrew Loyd Weber & whom ever else those rights concern.)

The Treasure *Phantom of the Opera* (sequel to The Quest) by AngelofMystery145

1871- Two lost souls found their dreams in Seville, but the dangers are far from eliminated, while in France a new terror has arisen. *some fantasy* based on 2004 movie- STRONG sexual situations E/C, R/M. All usual disclaimers apply; I don't own the PotO characters or music, but the original songs and characters are mine. Based solely on the Erik/Christine of 2004 movie (how I perceived them)- but still a high fantasy with Erik as a King of Music and Christine his Queen. Please note the M/MA rating - it's there for a reason. This story is very explicit at times as far as sex goes, increasing as story progresses- no-holds-barred- so please be warned. There are also other adult situations that warrant the M... All pictures/ book covers shown are my creation - E/C manips I made to go with scenes in my story.

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Let Your Fantasies Unwind cover

Phantom's Journey (Phantom of the Opera/Love Never Dies) cover

A Girl's Desire (Phantom Of The Opera x Reader) cover

Phantom's Understudy cover

Last-Chance1A's Phantom Writer cover

Between Mirrors and Roses (A Phantom of the Opera Fanfiction) ✓ cover

Like Father, Like Son | Phantom of the Opera cover

Unconditional Love || A Phantom of the Opera Fanfiction || cover

Remembering the Angel cover

The Treasure *Phantom of the Opera* (sequel to The Quest) cover

Let Your Fantasies Unwind

What if the Phantom wasn't alone pulling off all those tricks? What if he had an assistant? And what if his assistant knew him? This is the story of Megan Williams, a girl from the future with a passion for Phantom of the Opera, the fictional world that she grew up with... is now her reality. ____________ This will be a 'slow burn' as my friend calls it. Most of the story is building the relationship between Erik and Megan, and then everything comes crashing down. ;-) Sunday, Wednesday, and Friday updates. Completed. Found the image on Google Images. Don't know who's the original artist. ^^;