Bewildered Heart
  • Reads 42
  • Votes 0
  • Parts 6
  • Time 1h 10m
  • Reads 42
  • Votes 0
  • Parts 6
  • Time 1h 10m
Ongoing, First published Sep 18, 2019
Mature
What happens when Sam and Dean Winchester are in love with the same woman?

**Disclaimer** This is a work of fanfiction using characters and themes from the Supernatural universe trademarked by the CW's Supernatural; Sam Winchester, Dean Winchester, Castiel, and other Supernatural characters are owned by the CW's Supernatural. I do not claim any ownership over them or the Supernatural universe. This story is a work of my own invention and is not believed or does not appear to be a part of the Supernatural canon. Any characters of my own invention will be indicated as such. This fanfiction is for entertainment only and I am in no way financially profiting from its publication. I want to thank the CW's Supernatural for their wonderful universe for without it my imagination would not soar and this story would never be.

**Remi Leverett, Lauren and Zach are characters of my own invention and do not appear in the Supernatural canon. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, is coincidental.
All Rights Reserved
Sign up to add Bewildered Heart to your library and receive updates
or
Content Guidelines
You may also like
Home (Jack Kline x Reader) [[COMPLETE]] by ToHellWithReality
20 parts Complete Mature
I'm back at it again with another Supernatural reader insert story. I just can't stray away from some good old Supernatural imagines! And Jack is just the cutest, most wholesome character. Love him to death. That being said, this will be fluffy, a little bit of angst, MAYBE a bit lemony. I just find it hard to write full-on smut about Jack. He's just an innocent lil bean. ANYWHO, here is the description. ------------------------------------------------- You'd felt like something was missing in your whole 21 years of existence. You were just an only child, living a normal life with your single mother. Eventually, she had fallen ill. She felt it appropriate to finally tell you about your absentee father whom you'd never met, on her deathbed. All she gave you was a name. "John Winchester". And a photo. Not long after she passed, you wasted no time in trying to find any information about your biological father. After all, you had nothing to lose, and no family left. After digging and digging for any details you could find on this man on the internet, you found phone numbers. You called a few, no answer at first. On the fifth call, someone finally answered. And you wanted answers. A few days later, you found yourself in Lebanon, Kansas, standing in front of some kind of bunker, and two older men. After that, the void you'd been feeling in your life would be filled with a world you'd never expected. And one person becomes the light in the darkness that is your life.
Natural Born Sinner: A Dean X Female Reader X Sam Fic by xBeautifullyHauntedx
41 parts Complete Mature
Y/N was a civilian who lived a pretty straight-forward, boring, apple-pie lifestyle. She was incredibly smart...in fact, despite her being so young, she graduated top of her class and was now a Theology Professor at an Ivy League university. Lately, however... she felt like she was in desperate need of a change. After all... she was always a straight-A student, always kept her nose clean and stayed as far away from trouble as possible... a perfect goody two-shoes. Despite all this, Y/N knew there was something deep inside of her....something dormant; uncharted territory that kept calling to her. And once she crosses paths with two mysterious and insanely handsome "FBI Agents"... Y/N quickly discovers what it is she's been missing...and her world may just get rocked in an intense, dark, dangerous...incredibly fun...way. ----------------------------------------------- As per several requests, here is my take on a Dean X Reader X Sam fic! I overly appreciate all the love 'Dark Tendencies' received, and I hope this one lives up to expectation! This is an 18+, HEAVY SMUT, semi-slow burn read. As always, there will be some fluff to move the story along, but intense smut is the general idea! A polyamorous, trio thing is the endgame here. There will be NO favoritism! This book is written in first person, but YOU are the main character! (This does not follow the show storyline to a T, I'm just being creative lol) If you wanna bypass the story build-up and get right into the spice, (It's okay, I get it!), those chapters will be marked with ** around the chapter numbers! WARNING: My smut writing is VERY GRAPHIC!! ---------------------------------------------------------- I do not own the rights to Supernatural, Supernatural characters, the Supernatural storyline, or anything like that. This is just a fanfiction written purely for entertainment!
The Girl Behind The Garden by ExodusNymph
48 parts Complete Mature
Sam's p.o.v- My heart beat loudly in my ears. A soft smile played on my lips as I kissed all over her forehead, face, anywhere I could. She nuzzled into my chest and I sighed in content. Thoughtlessly, I placed my hand on her chest, covering her tattoo. She froze, glancing at my hand and then at me. I could feel her heart beat quicken, causing me to look up. "I don't think I can express how much I love you," I sighed, making her grin. "You can try," She prompted, causing a smirk to spread across my face. "I can," I agreed, gently pushing her down and hovering over her. "You know," She mumbled as she looked up at me, pushing my hair behind my ear, "I hate it when you're mad at me." "Me too," I admitted, leaning down and kissing her. Basically it starts off with Sam trapped in the basement of that crazy woman British Men Of letters person. He's all alone and he thinks Dean is dead, he doesn't know Marie is alive (obviously) and he doesn't know where Cass is. All of the sudden though, a woman he doesn't know comes to his rescue, seeming to know all about him). She takes him back home and meets Dean (who is very shocked to see this random lady with his tortured brother) She meets Cass and they know each other. A bunch of stuff happens, and she's got some dark secrets. Her and Sam's relationship blossoms into a fluffy ball of adorable that made me happy to write. (The overall theme fits the song Windows by Angel Oleson really well and I'd recommend you listen to it. Also, yes I know at some parts it's really cringey but I was a baby writer for the first parts of the book. It gets better and I'm really proud of it. I'm gonna try to go back and edit it but I'm really busy recently.)
Epiphany by winchester_fantasies
5 parts Complete Mature
Jael Rainwater has been a hunter all her life. When her father dies, she goes to live with Sam and Dean Winchester. As years pass, she develops feelings for Dean, but emotional scars from her past prevent her from giving her heart to any man. When Jael finally musters up the courage to admit her feelings, Dean's rejection is almost more than she can handle. With a serious case looming ahead Sam takes Jael on a road trip to clear her head and get her back on track. But when unexpected situations cause Jael's feelings to come into question she begins to wonder if her heart was ever really Dean's at all. Based on the song, "Teenage Dream" by Katy Perry. **Warning: triggers, smut. **Disclaimer** This is a work of fanfiction using characters and themes from the Supernatural universe trademarked by the CW's Supernatural; Sam Winchester, Dean Winchester, Castiel, and other Supernatural characters are owned by the CW's Supernatural. I do not claim any ownership over them or the Supernatural universe. This story is a work of my own invention and is not believed or does not appear to be a part of the Supernatural canon. Any characters of my own invention will be indicated as such. This fanfiction is for entertainment only and I am in no way financially profiting from its publication. I want to thank the CW's Supernatural for their wonderful universe for without it my imagination would not soar and this story would never be. **Jael Rainwater and Margo are characters of my own invention and do not appear in the Supernatural canon. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, is coincidental.
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
Dark Tendencies: A Female Reader x Dean Winchester Fic cover
Confessions Are For Fresh Starts [Destiel - AU] cover
Savior of the Saviors cover
Graceful Jack (Supernatural) cover
Home (Jack Kline x Reader) [[COMPLETE]] cover
Natural Born Sinner: A Dean X Female Reader X Sam Fic cover
The Girl Behind The Garden cover
Epiphany cover
As It Was - Dean Winchester cover
Nothing stays a secret forever (Destiel) cover

Dark Tendencies: A Female Reader x Dean Winchester Fic

41 parts Complete Mature

Y/N was an incredibly skilled hunter. Vamps, Werewolves, Shifters, you name it. She has conquered them all. Her cockiness was well-deserved given her impressive track record... until she crosses paths with renowned hunter Dean Winchester, and finds herself being humbled very quickly. Was this equally cocky, handsome stranger just some friendly competition? Or, was there something more to him, something darker, that would make Y/N question everything she knows about herself? ...................................................................... This is an 18+ smut-based, semi-slow burn read. There will be plenty of fluff for the sake of the story, but hardcore smut is the general direction we're heading here. Specifically, a bdsm-relationship/heavy romance kinda thing. Reader discretion is advised! This book is written in first person, but YOU are the main character! Note: For any readers who may just want to bypass the story build up and get right into the spicy... those chapters are marked with ** around the chapter number! WARNING: My smut writing is VERY GRAPHIC!! READ WITH CAUTION!!! ............................................................................... Disclaimer: I do not own any rights to Supernatural, the Supernatural characters, the Supernatural storyline or anything like that. This is just a fanfiction written for entertainment!