Past Lives

Most know the story of Eyeless Jack and Bloody Painter. But what if some of the details in the stories were left out? Like Eyeless Jack having a girlfriend and Bloody Painter actually had a very caring friend? Well, what if I told you that these two people are sisters and their father happens to be someone in the mansion?
Let me explain. Eyeless Jack's girlfriend, Heather, went to MIT with Jack; studying to be an engineer while Jack was studying to be a doctor. They had started dating in high school, when Heather was a junior and Jack was a senior. By the time Heather had made it to MIT, Jack was already two semester's in, and when their three year anniversary came by; Jack proposed. However, only a few days went by before Jack disappeared. This sent Heather into a spiral, attempting to figure out just what had happened to him and denying he was gone...
Now, onto Bloody Painter's story. Sure, Bloody Painter had known Puppeteer just before both of them turned to Creepypasta's, but Bloody Painter had another friend by the name of Skylor. She was only a couple of years younger than him and was considered a sister to him. The two had stuck together since the middle of their high school years and were in college for the same major: art. Though, when she heard the news of kids being killed, their blood used for murals and then him not showing to class made her worry. After a few days, she started to hear rumors of a 'Bloody Painter' and went to search online, finding that the story was the same as her friend and made it her mission to contact him and figure out a way for her to help him.
While the two had good intentions, some things should be left alone. Otherwise, things may not go exactly according to plan.