Elizabeth, Katelyn, and Connor Eubanks are all grown, but none of them have fully outgrown keeping secrets from their parents. Elizabeth hasn't even told her husband, Malik, that she's worried she won't be able to have a second child. Katelyn, not wanting to let her mother know about her recent break up, has recruited Dylan Kim, her coworker, to pretend to be her boyfriend. Connor's boyfriend, Theodore, wants to meet Connor's family, but Connor can't introduce him without also outing himself to his parents. When all three Eubanks children return home for the holidays, their secrets become at risk for exposure.
It's Christmas time, and all Mackenzie wants is her family to stop bugging her about not having a boyfriend.
Johnny needs a date to a dance, and has a hard time finding one.
When the two meet, they come to find a way to solve both problems for their Christmas wishes.
But will they just be friends in the end?