What We Could Have
- Reads 21,923
- Votes 513
- Parts 21
Ongoing3h 52m
Last published Wed, Apr 1, 2026
Becky Lynch has loved wrestling ever since she could remember, when she was called up from NXT to the main roster was a dream come true. She soon learned that she had to step up and show everybody who she was. Yes she was the first woman to be drafted to Smackdown back in 2016, and she was the first Smackdown's women champion but ever since she lost it, people had lost interest in her. Now that she has her champion back after beating her best friend Charlotte at Hell in a Cell. She has been the underdog for year and she is tired of being there for her friend while she gets nothing. Now that she has changed her attitude, people cannot see her hanging out with her best friend Charlotte so she has to be riding with other superstars instead of her. What happens when Becky starts riding and training with Cesaro and Seth?
Becky is recently single and wants to stay single for a while only focusing on her career, she is finally getting noticed by the fan but she has also caught someone's eye. Seth is also recently single and wasn't looking for anything but when he started hanging out with Becky, he starts to see her as more than a friend. They are both stubborn about not dating within the company, and agree to just be friends but as time passes they are figuring that they really shouldn't be fighting their feeling for one another.
What happens when they finally give in and decide to try to give it a shot, of course not everything is perfect but will they be able to get through it?
All Rights Reserved
#583
wrestler
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
The Mad Queen & The Psychotic King
Considered the most dangerous man in the business. Daniel started his career in the Indies of the U.S. then traveling all around the world. Only to find a temporary home in Japan. Daniel is considered the living embodiment of a modern psycho as he uses his broken psyche to his advantage in the ring. Garnering a reputation for doing whatever it takes to get his point across. Going by the ringname of 'Madhouse' Boyce a nickname he earned during his time in the European Indie's. Quickly climbs to the top of the mountain in Japan only for tragedy to strike in the form of his second girlfriend in his life to be killed in the ring due to a botched spot by her opponent. This causes him to let his 'True Psycho' loose onto the entire roster. Two years later he is picked up by WWE. And since he wasn't there long enough to some's liking. Daniel wasn't put on the card of Super Showdown in Melbourne, Australia. Only to be invited along by the Queen herself Charlotte Flair. And after having a fun time in Melbourne not only with the fact he made his impromptu debut and spent the day as a tourist around Melbourne. Daniel comes back to the States with WWE and soon finds himself put in the US Title bracket. And also is lucky enough to be put on SD Live's Survivor Series team. After a grand showing by Charlotte at Evolution against Becky. Eventhough she lost. Daniel feels that she deserves more respect since proving she could go to the wall with the best of them. During the traditional invasion of Raw by SD Live. Becky who was slated to go against Rousey gets injured by Nia Jax and is put on the injured list even though she said she was fine. The next night on SD Live. Lynch chooses Charlotte to replace her in the match against Rousey at Survivor Series. During said match Charlotte goes off the rails and not only beats the hell out of Rousey but gives 'Madhouse' a reason to pursue her as his girl. Will she accept being his girlfriend or will she refuse? Read and find out...Complete
Legit Business
Sasha Banks. Who has been somewhat unable to reach the number one contenders spot was growing tired of how Alexa Bliss was getting all the preferential treatment you could imagine. Instant title matches/rematches/title wins. But is never forced to face another talent that earned a shot. On the night of Alexa's confirmation as new Raw Women's Champion. Alexa who promotes how she won a 'fair' match to get the title is interrupted by Sasha Banks. The Legit Boss states her problems with how Alexa gets all the title shots or rematches and wins while other women wrestlers like her don't get anything. Alexa makes the mistake to rib if not point out the 'technicality' of Sasha not winning any important matches to garner her a shot at the title. That is until a forced out veteran of seven years comes back with not only a new purpose but also an axe to grind. After a short announcement or decree from the Board of Directors that he is the new sheriff or constable of Raw. He immediately takes Sasha's side of the argument that Alexa should have never gotten any more title shots after her second loss of the title. And he makes an example of Alexa and Steph (who presented Bliss with the title) that is sure to be felt throughout the entire WWE as this veteran exerts his will on Alexa and Steph even Constable Corbin later in the evening. With TLC just around the corner. The new Constable terrorizes Steph and Alexa until Steph agrees to give Sasha her long overdue title shot. But first Sasha has to win a mixed tag team match with Baron Corbin & Alexa Bliss vs. Daniel Boyce & Sasha Banks. However, the stipulation is that if Sasha's team wins she'll get her shot the following night on Raw. If she loses. Sasha will not be able to have another title shot as long as Alexa is champion. And while this war of who is the better champion rages, Sasha and Daniel get pretty close to each other. Will Sasha win the mixed tag match? Will Dan & Sasha become a pair? Read & see.Complete
Not All The Same ⭐(Completed)
Seth wishes for the life he had two years ago. The life with his father and his dog by his side. A life full of happiness and joy but hopes dim as the years fly by and the only thing he still has to give meaning to his life, is his passion to be a wrestler. Becky wants nothing more than for the life she had to fade away from memory. But with mistakes comes consequences and with her mother's constant distrust and her friends deserting her, she feels all alone. United States is a breath of fresh air for Becky, and for Seth, Becky is the person he needs for his life to feel complete again. Kind, understanding and with full of passion for wrestling like him. Parents hint at a possible obstacle and a secret obsession neither knows about, threatens to destroy everything. But life is perfect for Seth and Becky, so what can possibly go wrong when they have love on their side? This is my first ever story on Brollins. A tryout I must say so be kind Brollins fans. But I'm also open for criticism..Complete
Bálor
Finn Balor A.K.A. Fergal Devitt was at the top of the mountain having just become the first ever Universal Champion. But an injury has him forced to relinquish the title and receive surgery on his shoulder. Now with having been put on the shelf for 6 months Fergal is lost, he was at the top of the mountain and was quickly taking back down. That is until four women, Becky Lynch, Sasha Banks, Charlotte, and Bayley, re-enter his life and show him that he's still the same as he was when he was on top. Throughout it all he'll have to climb back up and retake his spot on the mountain but before that he has to enjoy what's been in front of him the whole time. That is if his alter ego Bálor will let him. Fergal wants to work on getting back into the ring but Bàlor is more focused on the women Fergal has surrounded himself with. Because of that Fergal feels himself slowly being influenced by Bálor and slowly feels himself developing feelings for the four women, because what's a Demon King without a queen. But when the consequences arise Fergal turns to Bálor for help and lets just say his assistance is something stuck out of time.Complete
'The Man' And The Outlaw.
Becky and I met in NXT, we clicked almost instantly. Like most relationships. We started out as friends. Two years after our main roster call ups, in the first part of 2017, we started dating. Barely over a year later, she changed little by little. Initially I thought she was going to tell me what was going on. But the more I tried to ask what was going on, the more she started to pull away. Finally, she just stopped talking to me in the summer of 2018. Close to a month later, I gave my notice and left the company. I returned to the indies for a year before taking a break from in-ring competition. Now it's the winter of 2019 and I'm not happy about going back to the WWE. But the fans wanted it. So I returned at Survivor Series. Another thing I was not looking forward to was running into my ex who was now engaged to former Universal Champion Seth Rollins. The only thing worse than her being engaged was how self absorbed egotistical she had become. Somehow, even though I hate what she's become or who she's willing to marry on a whim. I still love Becky and although it's futile to try and a fools errand as well. I'm going to try and get 'my' Becky back. I miss the readheaded ball of fire she used to be and I was proud to call my girlfriend and even if I don't succeed, I just want to be sure, the girl or woman I knew is really gone. And if she is. I'll have to just move on and find a new relationship. Even though I don't want to. (Cover by @undisputedtori)Complete
Ignition Point
When Becky Lynch and Seth Rollins started dating, everyone was surprised. Their sudden split was somewhat less of a shock, given Seth's relationship history. He does his best to give her the space she needs, but when he's ready to make amends, he realizes Becky may be on the verge of moving on. Have the friends-to-lovers reached their final stop, or can Seth convince Becky he's truly changed?Complete
Luck of the Irish (Becky Lynch x Male Reader)
You just won the WWE Championship and had an incredible night with the newly-single Becky Lynch. Can you keep your title and create something beautiful at the same time?Complete
Ice Hearts (Nikki Bella/ Seth Rollins)
When Nikki Bella won't let anyone in and love to reject people to make herself feel good. Seth just can't seem to fall in love and go with many of women only to dump the to make himself feel good. What will happen when Seth tries to get to know Nikki and see that apart from gorgeous looks outside she maybe just be as gorgeous on the inside. He will have to try and climb Nikki's skyscraper walls if he want to be with her but he is willing to try. Nikki on the other hand loves being cold. She is afraid to fall in love won't want to get her heartbroken, so if that means giving Seth hell, then so be it. She will lie if she haves to, she will try to make him go after other girls. She knows Seth is a what she hates most, a heartbreaker, she knows he is just as cold as her when it comes to relationships. Will the two ice hearts melt the next?Complete
Learning process- Becky Lynch+Seth Rollins
Some things take time, it's a learning process.. especially when it comes to thisComplete
House Rules
When Becky and Seth hook up after a long night, it was supposed to be a one-time thing. Then they come to an agreement: casual, no strings attached, and only at each other's houses. But as all the conditions they set get shoved to the side, will broken rules lead to broken hearts? (WARNING: Lots of sexual content. Seriously, it's basically just them having sex. If you're looking for a plot, that princess is in another castle, my friend.)Complete
Considered the most dangerous man in the business. Daniel started his career in the Indies of the U.S. then traveling all around the world. Only to find a temporary home in Japan. Daniel is considered the living embodiment of a modern psycho as he uses his broken psyche to his advantage in the ring. Garnering a reputation for doing whatever it takes to get his point across. Going by the ringname of 'Madhouse' Boyce a nickname he earned during his time in the European Indie's. Quickly climbs to the top of the mountain in Japan only for tragedy to strike in the form of his second girlfriend in his life to be killed in the ring due to a botched spot by her opponent. This causes him to let his 'True Psycho' loose onto the entire roster. Two years later he is picked up by WWE. And since he wasn't there long enough to some's liking. Daniel wasn't put on the card of Super Showdown in Melbourne, Australia. Only to be invited along by the Queen herself Charlotte Flair. And after having a fun time in Melbourne not only with the fact he made his impromptu debut and spent the day as a tourist around Melbourne. Daniel comes back to the States with WWE and soon finds himself put in the US Title bracket. And also is lucky enough to be put on SD Live's Survivor Series team. After a grand showing by Charlotte at Evolution against Becky. Eventhough she lost. Daniel feels that she deserves more respect since proving she could go to the wall with the best of them. During the traditional invasion of Raw by SD Live. Becky who was slated to go against Rousey gets injured by Nia Jax and is put on the injured list even though she said she was fine. The next night on SD Live. Lynch chooses Charlotte to replace her in the match against Rousey at Survivor Series. During said match Charlotte goes off the rails and not only beats the hell out of Rousey but gives 'Madhouse' a reason to pursue her as his girl. Will she accept being his girlfriend or will she refuse? Read and find out...
More detailsContent Guidelines