Zoe Smart is an average 17 year old who hates confrontation. After her mother came into big money with her fathers life insurance, it seems like all people ever wanted her for is money. All except her best friend, Andrew Sweet, who she has known since 2nd grade. When she ends up throwing a party at her house, she ends up falling for a mysterious stranger who she kissed while playing 7 minutes in heaven. Her world is turned upside down once she finds out that this mysterious stranger had been Andrew, and he now is dating the girl he thinks he kissed in the closet! Andrew Sweet has it all: he's popular, kindhearted, and has two loving parents learning to work it out, but the one thing he doesn't have is love. Ever since his last girlfriend cheated on him, he has had trust issues. So, when his best friend Zoe urges him to come to her party, he isn't expecting much. But when he falls for a mysterious stranger he meets in a closet, his number one mission is to find the girl who stole his heart. Enter Rachel Masters, a confident nerd who convinces him that she is the one he kissed in the closet. Will Zoe find the courage to tell Andrew the truth? Or will Andrew continue to fall for a lie? It all comes down to this.