When Brooke Johnson transfers to Oakland High School in Long Valley, New Jersey, she thinks her life is over. She is finally a senior in high school and she wanted to savor it with her friends back in New York. Now she's in a new place where she doesn't know anyone. When she finally starts meeting people, she becomes really close friends with Ethan Dolan. Then when she meets his twin brother, Grayson, she can't stop thinking about how much she wants him. However, Grayson barely knows she exists. Can she get his attention, or will she just have to let go?
Kristen moves into town hoping for a new and simple life after the death of her parents but when she ends up moving in next door to twins, Ethan and Grayson, things get a little complicated for her.
As both boys almost instantly fall for her she finds it difficult to choose which one is right for her... Can she even choose between the identical twins that have opposite personalities?