A New Mystery at 221 Baker Street - AnyaStin - Wattpad

A New Mystery at 221 Baker Street

Reads 144,340
Votes 5,152
Parts 82
Time 9h 58m

Reads 144,340
Votes 5,152
Parts 82
Time 9h 58m

In need of a change of environment, Alice Whitmer finds herself travelling to London. On her first day in her new flat, she meets Sherlock Holmes and John Watson. What surprises Sherlock is that Alice is almost as clever and as good at deductions as the consulting criminal himself. Is there more to the young American than meets the eye?

Excerpt:

"No worries," Alice replied before turning to Sherlock. "I have no qualms with an arrogant man in his early thirties who believes himself to be a genius despite his obvious shortcomings. You obviously are eager to be leaving the building with John here. So I won't hold you up any longer. After all, I am rather boring," she smirked.

Highest Ranking:
#3 in Sherlock  13th December 2020
#1 in Sherlockbbc 25th February 2021
#2 in BBC Sherlock 23rd December 2020
#1 in Holmes 5th November 2020


*Cross-posted on Archive of Our Own*All Rights Reserved

Table of contents

82 parts

Sign up to add A New Mystery at 221 Baker Street to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

His Last Vow (Sherlock Holmes X OC) by VictoriaWhite77

A case of stolen letters leads Sherlock Holmes and Anita O'Malley to engage in a long conflict with the powerful Charles Augustus Magnussen, the Napoleon of blackmail. But, what about Sherlock and Anita's recent engagement? Well, those two were always known for being a bit dramatic, weren't they? Started: Finished: N/A -All characters belong to the BBC, excluding Anita O'Malley and any other characters I mention. I also owe credit @Layce25 for allowing me to use books as references. Her Sherlock books are amazing, and you guys should go check them out!

The boys upstairs by MissWho77

Set after season 4, a new character enters 221B Baker Street. You are cunning and clever- and trying your hardest to remain out of trouble. Problem is, with a photographic memory and addiction to adrenaline, you can't help but get caught up with the crimes upstairs. These are your content warnings for the novella, please proceed with caution! TW// violence, assault, adult and distressing themes, abuse, panic attacks, addiction, self harm I hope you enjoy- please leave comments and criticisms as everything helps! Of course all rights reserved to the BBC, all characters belong to the BBC, I choose to use them for creative and entertainment purposes only. MissWho77 x

The Consulting Daughter by Flew_From_Deathe

ᴀᴛʜᴇɴᴀ ᴊᴀɴᴇ ʜᴏʟᴍᴇs sʜᴇ ɪs ᴛʜᴇ ᴅᴀᴜɢʜᴛᴇʀ ᴏғ sʜᴇʀʟᴏᴄᴋ ʜᴏʟᴍᴇs ᴀɴᴅ ᴀʟɪɴᴀ ᴊᴀᴄᴋsᴏɴ. Sherlock Holmes had left Alina Jackson with their daughter and carried on with his life, forgetting about her. After her Mother's death, Athena is sent to live in the custody of non other than Sherlock Holmes. Sherlock was not fond of this young woman parading around his and John's flat, but what could he do? Athena found her Dad a very interesting, yet, irritating person. Even though, she didn't give a damn about what he thought about her, a part of her always wanted to impress him. And soon she would gain the trust and love of Sherlock Holmes. All they needed was time. John Watson was rather fond of the youngest Holmes. He looked out for her as if she were his own sister. The familiarity between Sherlock and Athena freaked him out, but, thankfully he managed to withstand, love and protect another Holmes. *I DON'T OWN ANY OF THE CHARACTERS EXCEPT FOR MY OWN OCs. TAKES PLACE IN AND FROM 'THE GREAT GAME'. Sherlock BBC fanfiction.*

The Hounds Of Baskerville (Sherlock Holmes X OC) by VictoriaWhite77

Sherlock Holmes, John Watson, and Anita O'Malley travel to Dartmoor to unravel the mystery of a hound from hell. Sherlock has still yet to do anything about his feelings towards Anita and John gets sick of waiting around. Will John's efforts to get the duo together work or will it all be for not? Started: 8-11-2021 Finished: 10-13-2021 -All characters belong to the BBC, excluding Anita O'Malley and any other characters I mention. I also owe credit @Layce25 for allowing me to use books as references. Her Sherlock books are amazing, and you guys should go check them out!

The Lying Detective (Sherlock Holmes X OC) by VictoriaWhite77

John Watson wrestles with a shocking tragedy. Anita Holmes is off the grid- pushing her way through her grief by herself. Meanwhile, Sherlock Holmes faces his most cunning adversary yet: a wealthy philanthropist with a dark secret. Will the divide trio be able to come back together, or is this the end of the Baker Street Trio? Started: Finished: N/A -All characters belong to the BBC, excluding Anita O'Malley and any other characters I mention. I also owe credit @Layce25 for allowing me to use books as references. Her Sherlock books are amazing, and you guys should go check them out!

It Started With Stealing | Sherlock Holmes by Mickey_Fable

Elizabeth Parrish is a thief but not just any thief - She is Moriarty's personal thief. She made a deal with a devil and she enjoyed it: the thrill, the challenge, the money. Every job he gave her left her on a high that she couldn't get enough of. She's never been caught before either. But when a job goes wrong, Elizabeth is left with a choice: Help Sherlock & John hunt down Moriarty and potentially get a clean slate afterwards or be locked away in prison for the rest of her life for attempting to steal top-secret government files. Which will she choose? And will her choice help her win or lose the game? DISCLAIMER: I do not own BBC Sherlock or any characters/plotlines related to/used in the show. What I do own is Elizabeth Parrish, her story and her associates. Also some crimes (not that I committed them myself lmao). Also, the picture on the cover isn't mine so credits to whoever made that picture - I merely put a title on it. :) Started: Feb 2019 Finished: May 2021 #1 in The Reichenbach Fall - 10/06/2020 #1 in The Great Game - 20/06/2020 #3 in Sherlock Holmes - 27/06/2020 #1 in Benedict Cumberbatch 06/07/2020 ❤❤❤ #1 in Irene Adler - 16/07/2020 #1 in Sherlock BBC - 31/07/2020 #1 in Sebastian Moran - 03/08/2020 #1 in Moriarty - 15/08/2020 #1 in Greg Lestrade - 02/09/2020 #1 in Mrs Hudson - 28/10/2020 #1 in Baker Street - 01/11/2020 #1 in Sherlock Love Story - 01/12/2020 ❤❤❤ #1 in Lestrade - 01/12/2020 #1 in 221B - 16/12/2020 #1 in BBC Sherlock - 31/01/2021 #1 in Detective - 19/03/2021 😲 #1 in John Watson - 10/05/2021 #2 in Jim Moriarty - 12/12/2021 #1 in OC Story - 20/12/2021 #1 in Thief - 04/05/2023

The Blind Banker (Sherlock Holmes x OC) by VictoriaWhite77

Now with John Watson tagging along with Anita O'Malley and Sherlock Holmes, nothing could go wrong...right? After John moved in with Sherlock, he quickly learned that life with Sherlock and Anita never is dull. Even a seemingly normal visit to the bank keeps the doctor on his toes. Started: 3-24-2021 Finished: 4-2-2021 -All characters belong to the BBC, excluding Anita O'Malley and any other characters I mention. I also owe credit @Layce25 for allowing me to use books as references. Her Sherlock books are amazing, and you guys should go check them out!

Hunter (Sherlock Fanfiction) by annaspatula

#1 in ynstories (17/07/2022) You are the best assassin in history, the most ruthless, the most efficient of them all. The day you were sent to kill Sherlock Holmes, was the day your life changed. The moment he told you the truth, your whole life changed. What happens when, instead of assassinating the world's best consulting detective, you join him in taking down the organisation who employed you? The organisation that has kept the truth about your whole life a secret? How deep does the rabbit hole go? I've rewritten some of the plot in order for this story to make sense, the start of the story is set in the time inbetween S2E2-E3. Majority of the plot will stay the same. I do not own any of the BBC sherlock characters. I have created OCs (I don't own you obviously but I made the personality for this story). !!SHERLOCKXFEM READER!! !!MENTION OF DRUGS!! !!Trigger warnings: some sensitive topics may be discussed!! !!Maybe smut!! Also it's written in first person view, I find that easier in the moment but in the future if I write other books or a sequel I'll probably try second person or third person This is my first story lol so we'll see where this goes, most characters in the show will be appearing, Sherlock and John being those you spend the most time with but yeah if you like it please share with others :)

His flower || Tewksbury x fem!reader ❁ by Soph1e_s4urus3

❝ 𝐴 𝑤ℎ𝑖𝑡𝑒 𝑟𝑜𝑠𝑒， 𝑠𝑡𝑎𝑛𝑑𝑠 𝑓𝑜𝑟 𝑠𝑒𝑐𝑟𝑒𝑡 𝑙𝑜𝑣𝑒. ❞ Anna read out loud, while I was staring at the flower that Lord Tewksbury gave me. ❁ I always was sort of different. It wasn't my looks, my health or my social status. It was my mind. I am sick of men telling us, women, what to do. I am sick of my mother telling me to find myself a rich husband. I am sick of my Father being a member of the house of lords but I still won't be the person following him, even though I am the oldest. And why is that? Because I am a woman and that is the only reason. But I decided to defend myself. I decided to make a difference. My plan was to make women join protests against the sexism going on. To inspire them to defend themselves and I was going to achieve my goal even if it meant that I would have to leave behind everything. I only made one rule for myself to follow: don't fall in love. But when I met the Viscount Tewksbury of Basilweather, I quickly knew that I had to focus so I wouldn't break that rule. #5 in SherlockHolmes (16th January 2023) #6 in enolaholmes (4th February 2023) #3 in runningaway (4th February 2023) #5 in emmawatson (28th May 2023) #2 in Tewksbury (10th July 2023) #1 in womensrights (6th June 2024-29th July 24) #1 in Sherlockholmes (17th August 2023) #2 in runningaway (26th November 2023) (All the characters except my own belong to the owners of Enola Holmes) About 30.000 words have been used in this book

A Study in Pink (Sherlock Holmes X OC) by VictoriaWhite77

Detective Inspector Anita O'Malley has known Sherlock Holmes for years. Sherlock had always thought of Anita as just a friend, but maybe he was wrong. Anita, on the other hand, couldn't be more in love with him if she tried. Maybe they'll find their way into each other's arms, maybe they won't. But when a woman in pink becomes the fourth in a series of seemingly unrelated suicides, Sherlock Holmes deduces that the deaths are actually murders. Started: 2-11-2021 Finished: 3-17-2021 -All characters belong to the BBC, excluding Anita O'Malley and any other characters I mention. I also owe credit @Layce25 for allowing me to use books as references. Her Sherlock books are amazing, and you guys should go check them out!

Unfixed by stressed-to-impress

"Dear God, what is it like in your funny little brains? It must be so boring!" ~COMPLETED ~ BBC SHERLOCK ~ S3-S4 ~ YOUNG SHERLOCK ~MYCROFT HOLMES x OC FIRST PLACE SPRING AWARDS 2018 ~"Definitely an amazing book that is 100% worth reading" - @MissyMarshmallow for the spring awards

The Great Game (Sherlock Holmes x OC) by VictoriaWhite77

Despairing of the ingenuity of London's criminals, Sherlock Holmes accepts what appears to be an ordinary case and discovers that a mastermind is at work. As usual, John Watson and Anita O'Malley tag along on the journey. But, in unusual turn of events, will Sherlock and Anita's friendship persevere? Or will something shift and change everything they thought they knew about each other? Started: 4-14-2021 Finished: 5-26-2021 -All characters belong to the BBC, excluding Anita O'Malley and any other characters I mention. I also owe credit @Layce25 for allowing me to use books as references. Her Sherlock books are amazing, and you guys should go check them out!

You Are My Mystery {Sherlock Holmes} by stinkytootsies

#1 in #sherlock #5 in #sherlock #7 in #johnwatson #1 in #sherlockholmes 8/9/22 (All rankings are out of 1,000+) A witty and worldly woman moves to London with plans to shape her life into something new. On her first day in London, she discovers there has been a murder. What happens when she bumps into a tall man with resembling traits and a prestigious army doctor with a big cane? Sherlock x OC COMPLETED (NOW BEING EDITED) __________ +I don't own any characters except for Rachelle Baines and a few others+ ENJOY!

Lost and Found (Sherlock x Reader) by CrazygirlP13

Imagine yourself in the TV show Sherlock Holmes. You live in the flat just below Sherlock Holmes and Doctor Watson. It has been many years since you last saw the consulting detective, seeing as you were just kids when he moved away. But now, you are disappointed find that he doesn't remember you. It becomes your goal to make him remember and in the process you find that you have fallen in love with him. Will he love you back, though? That question haunts you every day when you show up at his door to help him solve cases. The game in on! (I do not own any of the Sherlock characters!)

The Vacancy: Sherlock x Fem!reader by 221b_blogger101

When a vacancy opens for a decent flat in central London, and for such a good price, who are you to decline it? While expecting a peaceful living arrangement to develop paintings for the gallery you work for, instead you're dragged into unexpected adventures with your flatmates. ~~~ All characters belong to BBC for portrayals and original characters have been written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle

𝓜𝓮 & 𝓜𝓲𝓷𝓮 ｟ BBC Sherlock ｠ by TheGameIsOn97

The world's only consulting detective, an ex-army doctor, an art therapist, and an American who loves music. These sound like four very different people, right? Definitely. Em isn't quite sure what she expects to deal with when she decides to leave her home in the US to go and live with her half-sister (Athena) all the way over in London at the address of 221C Baker Street. Being woken up from trying to sleep off her red-eye flight jet lag by all the ruckus being made by her and her sister's new 221B neighbor was not something she wanted to have to deal with right away. However, she storms up the stairs and gives Mister Sherlock Holmes a piece of her mind. How does he respond? What happens when the landlady (Mrs Hudson) suggests Sherlock look for a new flatmate in order to make paying the rent a bit easier on himself? And how does Em and Athena's dynamic with Sherlock change when Doctor John Watson walks into their lives? Something dark and eerie lurks in the shadows, watching our team of four mystery solvers take the world of crime solving by storm. Eventually, things will be revealed about one of our Baker Street Four that will make the other three see them in a whole new light. Well, might as well get started because... the game is on! ▇ ▇ ▇ Pairings: • (Sherlock Holmes x OFC) • (John Watson x OFC) Cover by Timelady2013

The Sign of Three (Sherlock Holmes X OC) by VictoriaWhite77

While moral danger stalks John and Mary Watson's wedding reception, Sherlock Holmes faces his biggest challenge of all: delivering a best man's speech! With Anita O'Malley and Sherlock Holmes at their side, the Watson's have nothing to worry about on their big day. There will be more then one shocking thing revealed at (or after) this wedding but that's the fun part!...Right? Started: Finished: N/A -All characters belong to the BBC, excluding Anita O'Malley and any other characters I mention. I also owe credit @Layce25 for allowing me to use books as references. Her Sherlock books are amazing, and you guys should go check them out!

Eyes On You: Book-1 [A Mycroft Holmes Fanfiction] by atqarxia

[COMPLETED]- 70K WORDS Book-2 Is Out!!! Here is the link- https://www.wattpad.com/story/278535595-eyes-on-you-book-2 Caring is not an advantage, he knows because he has always cared. Chaos ensues in the life of the Elder Holmes when a mysterious woman moves into 221c Baker Street. Watch as their lives entangle and they get caught in a web of endless mysteries. If you like the book, please vote, comment, and follow.😊❤️ Other Works- Marlin's Sword [A Mycroft Holmes Fanfiction]- https://www.wattpad.com/story/288048730-marlin%27s-sword-a-mycroft-holmes-fanfiction The Descent of a Holmes [A Mycroft Holmes Fanfiction]- https://www.wattpad.com/story/289037190-the-descent-of-a-holmes-a-mycroft-holmes

A Scandal In Belgravia (Sherlock Holmes X OC) by VictoriaWhite77

A royal scandal brings Sherlock Holmes into a tough duel of wits against a peculiar woman. Now that Sherlock has started to understand his feelings towards his best friend, Anita O'Malley, what will he do? Even if he were to confess everything, how would Anita react? So many questions that Sherlock does not have the answer to. Started: 6-2-2021 Finished: 7-21-2021 -All characters belong to the BBC, excluding Anita O'Malley and any other characters I mention. I also owe credit @Layce25 for allowing me to use books as references. Her Sherlock books are amazing, and you guys should go check them out!

Bouquet of Thorns: Sherlock x fem!reader by 221b_blogger101

A thorn by any other name would hurt just as deep, or whatever the saying is. ~~~ Greg Lestrade would say Sherlock Holmes was always the smartest in the room. Whether at 221B or Scotland Yard, no ordinary person ever came close to compete with his... intellectual prowess. Well, no one but you. So when work guides you back to London, there was no surprise when the D.I. welcomed you back with open arms. ~~~ All characters belong to BBC for portrayals and original characters have been written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle

You may also like

Slide 1 of 20

His Last Vow (Sherlock Holmes X OC) cover

The boys upstairs cover

The Consulting Daughter cover

The Hounds Of Baskerville (Sherlock Holmes X OC) cover

The Lying Detective (Sherlock Holmes X OC) cover

It Started With Stealing | Sherlock Holmes cover

The Blind Banker (Sherlock Holmes x OC) cover

Hunter (Sherlock Fanfiction) cover

His flower || Tewksbury x fem!reader ❁ cover

A Study in Pink (Sherlock Holmes X OC) cover

The Great Game (Sherlock Holmes x OC) cover

You Are My Mystery {Sherlock Holmes} cover

Lost and Found (Sherlock x Reader) cover

The Vacancy: Sherlock x Fem!reader cover

𝓜𝓮 & 𝓜𝓲��𝓷𝓮 ｟ BBC Sherlock ｠ cover

The Sign of Three (Sherlock Holmes X OC) cover

Eyes On You: Book-1 [A Mycroft Holmes Fanfiction] cover

A Scandal In Belgravia (Sherlock Holmes X OC) cover

Bouquet of Thorns: Sherlock x fem!reader cover

His Last Vow (Sherlock Holmes X OC)

A case of stolen letters leads Sherlock Holmes and Anita O'Malley to engage in a long conflict with the powerful Charles Augustus Magnussen, the Napoleon of blackmail. But, what about Sherlock and Anita's recent engagement? Well, those two were always known for being a bit dramatic, weren't they? Started: Finished: N/A -All characters belong to the BBC, excluding Anita O'Malley and any other characters I mention. I also owe credit @Layce25 for allowing me to use books as references. Her Sherlock books are amazing, and you guys should go check them out!