Fatal Flaw
- Reads 56,059
- Votes 3,125
- Parts 60
On the night the Opera Populaire was consumed by fire, Erik rode into the wilderness on horseback, discovering an expansive castle that...
Belonged to him?
He lived there, all alone...
Until Christine happened to show up at his doorstep.
But why was she there?
Where was Raoul?
What if Erik and Christine both had...
A fatal flaw?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Other Information:
• In introducing Erik to Christianity in this fanfiction, I do not mean to play the part of God. "Fatal Flaw" is just a fictional story, and I really wanted to see Erik find the Light. In real life, however, only the Lord can make this happen.
• The characters in this story belong to their rightful owners (such as Gaston Leroux and Victor Hugo), not to me. All I've done is taken them and written a fanfiction about them.
All Rights Reserved
#53
erik
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Hunter in the Dark
Raoul's older sibling returns to Paris and is instantly fascinated by the Phantom, Erik in turn is just annoyed to have one more de Chagny in the picture. So they go for a hunt, each with their own motives. It turns out differently as each of them expected. This story begins at the end, kinda. ------------------ This is an older story of mine I overhauled and therefore already finished! Rating: NC-17 hetero Genre: Romance Pairing: E/OC Words: around 10'000 Status: Complete Warnings: Wild mix of all the phantom-verses, mainly Kay and definitely AU A lot of OOC'ness from Raoul's and Philippe's part (even if we never see him in persona). The Persian too and Erik... Oh heck, Erik... Erik is just my version Erik. Means, he's a medley of all the Eriks/Phantoms I know in literature, films, musicals mixed with a good brush of my own dirty, insane, phantasies and memories. But, he always looks like Leroux/Kay Erik, only his eyes just reflect in the dusty light of darkness and seem to be yellow-cattish; in peaceful daylight they're from the color like of the midnight-sky, with golden sparkles, like falling stardust... With this I bid you goodbye and let you read...Complete
Little Phantom on Adventure
Emma is tired of life in the Phantom's lair. Her father's lair. Erik kept his daughter in the catacombs under the Opera Populaire in fear of losing her, but what if keeping her locked away from the outside world is exactly what makes him lose her. As Emma steps out of the Opera she meets and befriends Eponine and the Barricade boys, Emma fights at the barricade, almost all her friends dying before her, but her love for the infamous (dead) Leader, Enjolras, still grows. And will Christine ever come into her life? And what about Gustave and Raoul? Oh well... Love Never Dies.Complete
Love Isn't Always Beautiful || A Phantom Of The Opera Fanfiction
After Christine Daee leaves the phantom, Erik, with Raoul she feels regret as she drifts away in the boat. She already promised Raoul a lifetime of commitment, but her heart was left with Erik. The next morning he police have a mysterious mission that no one knows about that involves them running around the entire city. Perhaps it's a... Search party? Maybe someone who Christine knows personally?Complete
A Second Chance in Love (Erik X OC)
The great fire, it cost Erik everything he ever knew. His house, his only love... everything. He roamed the streets for almost four years, staying hidden in the shadows he made himself familiar with only to find his way back to the abandon and burnt opera house. He stayed there and the first few months were nothing but peace, silence and his inner demons ripping him apart. He had no power for life anymore, no muse to write songs and compose miracles. He simply spent his days looking at the cave walls, not able to think, to see, to feel. All that changed when his ear perked the sound of a child's laughter, informing him of people entering his house but he had no power to kick them out. He saw no reason too. The Phantom was dead after all. He assumed they were the new owners, a word he heard a few times during the past 2 weeks. He mentally scoffed, wondering what they would do with the destroyed opera. Open it again? Fix it? He could care less. All he wanted was his solitude. #1 in phantomoftheopera (10/3/21)Complete
1 | Shrouded In Mystery (HIATUS)
"What would you do if you were trapped in your favourite musical?" *** Annika Knight has a relatively normal life in the twenty-first century - she goes to college, has two crazy friends, and has enough family drama to occupy her nights. However, this soon changes one night when she is drawn to a disembodied voice calling to her from behind the old mirror in her bedroom. Now in nineteenth-century Paris at the height of the Phantom of the Opera's antics, Annika is forced to navigate an unfamiliar world as she carves out her own narrative alongside the original story of her favourite musical. But as her love for the mysterious masked Phantom blossoms, she is forced with an impossible choice: allow the original story to play out as she has always known it, or divert the story in her favour? *** A Phantom of the Opera fanfiction set in the world of Andrew Lloyd Webber's musical of the classic French tale by Gaston Leroux. 🥉Third place in the Quilling It Awards 2025
(BEING REWRITTEN) An Opera Ghost- A Phantom of the Opera Fan Fiction
((Currently, I am rewriting this story to fit my current writing style, given this was written when I was in high school and I am in college now. There are a lot of changes, but I am leaving the original because I still like looking back on it. You can find the new & improved rewrite here: https://www.wattpad.com/433738666-an-opera-ghost-a-phantom-of-the-opera-fanfiction )) Florence was supposed to be the first child to Raoul and Christine de Chagny. Sadly, that wasn't the case. From the moment her parents saw her black eyes they knew Raoul was in no way the father. They knew it was the Phantom who had given Christine the child to make them suffer. Raoul, unable to keep this ghost of his past, takes Florence to the Opera Populaire knowing the Phantom still was lurking there as they tried to restore the place.The Phantom was in fact still there and he gladly took his daughter, hoping to raise her to be one of the opera's greatest singers. And as she grew, it was obvious his plans would succeed. But when Florence begins to fall for one of her patrons, will the Phantom allow her to love? *Just so you know, this is not just about the Phantom's daughter, but also about the Phantom himself, the Giry's, and the de Chagny's*Complete
Remembering the Angel
What if the curtain never fell? What if that bullet had never killed Christine? Could it be too good to be true? Christine Daae wakes up on a pier surrounded by frightened faces. She recognizes no one. She is thrown back into her life with out being able to remember what it was. She is a mother? She was a wife? Who is it she feels, but never fears, always standing by her side? The Phantom must fight himself now. How can he help Christine to remember their love without showing her the monster he once was? And their son...He needs her back. His world, his light, his Angel will remember their story. He will write the songs of their other time brought to life. (All rights to songs/ Characters/ Mentions of previous story lines go to Andrew Loyd Weber & whom ever else those rights concern.)Complete
The Treasure *Phantom of the Opera* (sequel to The Quest)
1871- Two lost souls found their dreams in Seville, but the dangers are far from eliminated, while in France a new terror has arisen. *some fantasy* based on 2004 movie- STRONG sexual situations E/C, R/M. All usual disclaimers apply; I don't own the PotO characters or music, but the original songs and characters are mine. Based solely on the Erik/Christine of 2004 movie (how I perceived them)- but still a high fantasy with Erik as a King of Music and Christine his Queen. Please note the M/MA rating - it's there for a reason. This story is very explicit at times as far as sex goes, increasing as story progresses- no-holds-barred- so please be warned. There are also other adult situations that warrant the M... All pictures/ book covers shown are my creation - E/C manips I made to go with scenes in my story.Complete
Raoul's older sibling returns to Paris and is instantly fascinated by the Phantom, Erik in turn is just annoyed to have one more de Chagny in the picture. So they go for a hunt, each with their own motives. It turns out differently as each of them expected. This story begins at the end, kinda. ------------------ This is an older story of mine I overhauled and therefore already finished! Rating: NC-17 hetero Genre: Romance Pairing: E/OC Words: around 10'000 Status: Complete Warnings: Wild mix of all the phantom-verses, mainly Kay and definitely AU A lot of OOC'ness from Raoul's and Philippe's part (even if we never see him in persona). The Persian too and Erik... Oh heck, Erik... Erik is just my version Erik. Means, he's a medley of all the Eriks/Phantoms I know in literature, films, musicals mixed with a good brush of my own dirty, insane, phantasies and memories. But, he always looks like Leroux/Kay Erik, only his eyes just reflect in the dusty light of darkness and seem to be yellow-cattish; in peaceful daylight they're from the color like of the midnight-sky, with golden sparkles, like falling stardust... With this I bid you goodbye and let you read...
More detailsContent Guidelines