Fatal Flaw - ForgivenAtTheCross - Wattpad

Story cover for Fatal Flaw by ForgivenAtTheCross

Fatal Flaw

ForgivenAtTheCross

Reads 55,739
Votes 3,103
Parts 60
Time 2h 31m

Reads 55,739
Votes 3,103
Parts 60
Time 2h 31m

ForgivenAtTheCross

christianity christine erik erikxchristine eristine fanfiction fatalflaw feels fluff operaghost phanfiction phantom pheels phluff poto

On the night the Opera Populaire was consumed by fire, Erik rode into the wilderness on horseback, discovering an expansive castle that... 
Belonged to him? 

He lived there, all alone... 
Until Christine happened to show up at his doorstep. 

But why was she there? 
Where was Raoul?
What if Erik and Christine both had... 
A fatal flaw?

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Other Information:
• In introducing Erik to Christianity in this fanfiction, I do not mean to play the part of God. "Fatal Flaw" is just a fictional story, and I really wanted to see Erik find the Light. In real life, however, only the Lord can make this happen.

• The characters in this story belong to their rightful owners (such as Gaston Leroux and Victor Hugo), not to me. All I've done is taken them and written a fanfiction about them.All Rights Reserved

christianity christine erik erikxchristine eristine fanfiction fatalflaw feels fluff operaghost phanfiction phantom pheels phluff poto

Table of contents

60 parts

Sign up to add Fatal Flaw to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Always there singing songs in my head (A Phantom of the Opera fanfiction) by TheCreator900

Erik has been searching for his soulmate for a long time. You see, he can hear his soulmate singing in his mind but he's never known whose the voice belongs to. For a while, he thought it was Christine because she could hear a voice too. But he later learned it was her childhood sweetheart, Raoul. After his many murders and accidentally burning down the Opera House, he searches for his mysterious soulmate. As he searches for a way to leave Paris, he meets a young sailor named (Y/N) (L/N). She is part of a crew of a trading ship that she escaped on when she was only ten years old. When (Y/N) lets Erik leave and work on the ship, Erik sees and learns things he never thought he'd learn. But his soulmate has gone silent since he met her. Has something happened to her? Only by traveling into the unknown will give him the answers he needs. DISCLAIMER! I don't own you, Erik, Phantom of the Opera, any songs, pictures, videos, etc. This is a Soulmate AU. I got inspiration from a YouTube comment on a duet of Into the Unknown sung by Elsa and Panic! At The Disco. So, credit to this idea goes to that comment. I don't remember the username or if they want to be mentioned. So credit that comment should you find it. Enjoy the book.

Christine, That's all I ask of you by _another_phangirl

{Follows the 2004 film} Christine got married to Raoul and they seemed to be happy together. But in a few months Christine realized that maybe something was wrong. Raoul cheated on her. She thought that maybe she made a wrong choice and continued thinking of Erik... Her poor unhappy Erik. Is he still down there? Is he even alive? (I'm so sorry for some errors, I'm not English actually. Thanks for understanding)

Her Innocence || Phantom of the Opera by SimpleSav

"Christine, I love you." The phantom's voice played a sweet tune in my mind. It was the first time he had confessed his love, but sadly, I couldn't return the favor. He had given me everything, fame, fortune, and a life of excitement and curiosity. Still, he had threatened to hang my beloved Raoul and sentence me to an eternity locked away from the world. My clammy hands shook with emotion as I slid the beautiful, diamond ring off my finger. The disfigured man helplessly gazed into my eyes, transforming my soul. I was the only one to look past his hideous physical appearance, to know how to comfort a creature of darkness; I couldn't bare holding in my emotions any longer. Tears plunged down my pale cheeks and I looked down to take his hand. Making sure not to drop the small item, I closed his rough fingers around the ring. "Goodbye," all sadness echoing through my word. I spun around and dragged my wedding dress through the foggy water to meet Raoul's awaiting boat. *** UPDATE 2020: Hello, all! I realized that this book recently gained traction in the fanfic world of Wattpad, again. Unfortunately, I wrote this back in 2014 and have yet to go through and edit. At one point, I planned on making a sequel to this. I don't expect to do so any time soon, but I appreciate the reads and the comments!

$Your Music Fills My Soul {Erik Destler x Reader} by purple_glass_hearts$

The Vicomte and Vicomtesse de Chagny have come to visit the Opera Populaire for the first time. Little did they know that the moment they stepped into that opera house, their lives would change from then on. ♡ I hope you enjoy this book. Please feel free to comment. I am completely fine with critiques or any. I apologize if I have made any grammatic errors. All songs used in this book have been written and the end of the chapter. All Phantom of the Opera songs are by Andrew Lloyd Webber. I only own this book and the characters I have created. This book is mainly based from the Phantom of the Opera musical and the 2004 movie. There are slight references to the book but I unfortunately didn't make many since I don't know alot about the book. ♡ Started Writing Book: Nov. 2, 2023 (Part 1) Completed: Nov. 19, 2023 (Part 2) Started: Nov. 20, 2023 Completed: Dec. 10, 2023 (might be made. we'll see :3 ↓) (Part 3) Started: - Completed: - Finished Editing: May 5, 2024 Published: May 5, 2024 ♡ May 5, 2024: Oh my god- I finally published it- *freaking out*

(BEING REWRITTEN) An Opera Ghost- A Phantom of the Opera Fan Fiction by cashleykate

((Currently, I am rewriting this story to fit my current writing style, given this was written when I was in high school and I am in college now. There are a lot of changes, but I am leaving the original because I still like looking back on it. You can find the new & improved rewrite here: https://www.wattpad.com/433738666-an-opera-ghost-a-phantom-of-the-opera-fanfiction )) Florence was supposed to be the first child to Raoul and Christine de Chagny. Sadly, that wasn't the case. From the moment her parents saw her black eyes they knew Raoul was in no way the father. They knew it was the Phantom who had given Christine the child to make them suffer. Raoul, unable to keep this ghost of his past, takes Florence to the Opera Populaire knowing the Phantom still was lurking there as they tried to restore the place.The Phantom was in fact still there and he gladly took his daughter, hoping to raise her to be one of the opera's greatest singers. And as she grew, it was obvious his plans would succeed. But when Florence begins to fall for one of her patrons, will the Phantom allow her to love? *Just so you know, this is not just about the Phantom's daughter, but also about the Phantom himself, the Giry's, and the de Chagny's*

A Second Chance in Love (Erik X OC) by Vigilante24

The great fire, it cost Erik everything he ever knew. His house, his only love... everything. He roamed the streets for almost four years, staying hidden in the shadows he made himself familiar with only to find his way back to the abandon and burnt opera house. He stayed there and the first few months were nothing but peace, silence and his inner demons ripping him apart. He had no power for life anymore, no muse to write songs and compose miracles. He simply spent his days looking at the cave walls, not able to think, to see, to feel. All that changed when his ear perked the sound of a child's laughter, informing him of people entering his house but he had no power to kick them out. He saw no reason too. The Phantom was dead after all. He assumed they were the new owners, a word he heard a few times during the past 2 weeks. He mentally scoffed, wondering what they would do with the destroyed opera. Open it again? Fix it? He could care less. All he wanted was his solitude. #1 in phantomoftheopera (10/3/21)

The Treasure *Phantom of the Opera* (sequel to The Quest) by AngelofMystery145

1871- Two lost souls found their dreams in Seville, but the dangers are far from eliminated, while in France a new terror has arisen. *some fantasy* based on 2004 movie- STRONG sexual situations E/C, R/M. All usual disclaimers apply; I don't own the PotO characters or music, but the original songs and characters are mine. Based solely on the Erik/Christine of 2004 movie (how I perceived them)- but still a high fantasy with Erik as a King of Music and Christine his Queen. Please note the M/MA rating - it's there for a reason. This story is very explicit at times as far as sex goes, increasing as story progresses- no-holds-barred- so please be warned. There are also other adult situations that warrant the M... All pictures/ book covers shown are my creation - E/C manips I made to go with scenes in my story.

Come into the Light by Echuines

"I have realized... it is better to be alone, Meg. The people I love won't get hurt." He whispered to me and then I saw him. The man I know and love; the man torn between wanting to love and scared of it; the man wanting to feel but runs away from everything that makes him feel because he is afraid of losing it. "I learned with Christine that I cannot love, Meg. I cannot love anyone...I only hurt them. And no one can love me. Who could?" "I could." I couldn't believe I just said it. He froze and I just kept talking, afraid the words would stop coming out of my mouth. "That's where you're wrong, Erik. You've always believed that no one could ever love you, all of you, even with your deformity. And yet, I have loved you since I was seventeen years old. You hid yourself behind the "Phantom of the Opera" but I never saw a Phantom. I saw a man desperate to be loved, to be loved not only for his music but for himself. I thought Christine could be the one to finally show you that love since I was so afraid to do so. But not afraid of you but what I know you would say. Christine chose wrong, Erik. I would've chosen you in a heartbeat... I do choose you."

Love Is A Battle(Sequel to A Fallen Rose Behind a Hidden Mask) by VampireWarrior101

t has been ten year since the tragedy of the opera house, the "tragedy" of Erik and Angelique. Christine and Raoul are married and have their own son named Gustav. Erik and Angelique are married as well and have two sons and two daughters. Erik and Angelique have started a circus in Phantasma and they couldn't be happier with their new family there. But...unfortunately....an enemy from Angelique's past....a brother who is alive and seek revenge for Raoul....a bother by the name of Victor....what happens when Angelique and Erik find out he is alive? Will he be a threat? Also, what will happen when Raoul and Christine fin out that Angelique and Erik are alive? Will there be love? Hatred?....A battle for love?

Unconditional Love || A Phantom of the Opera Fanfiction || by Phantom_Christine_5

One event changed everything in Christine Daae's life. Erik Destlar fell in love with her and decided to take her to live with him. Will she ever love him back? Modern day, E/C... COMPLETED ___________________________________________________________ I do NOT claim the original work of Gaston Leroux "The Phantom of the Opera." I also do NOT condone things discussed, written, or otherwise made known through my work such as stalking, kidnapping, marrying kidnappers/stalkers, or the like. My only wish is to make Leroux's book accessible to modern readers with a few plot twists here and there. I can only hope I have done his acclaimed work justice with my retelling.

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Always there singing songs in my head (A Phantom of the Opera fanfiction) cover

Christine, That's all I ask of you cover

Her Innocence || Phantom of the Opera cover

Your Music Fills My Soul {Erik Destler x Reader} cover

(BEING REWRITTEN) An Opera Ghost- A Phantom of the Opera Fan Fiction cover

A Second Chance in Love (Erik X OC) cover

The Treasure *Phantom of the Opera* (sequel to The Quest) cover

Come into the Light cover

Love Is A Battle(Sequel to A Fallen Rose Behind a Hidden Mask) cover

Unconditional Love || A Phantom of the Opera Fanfiction || cover

Always there singing songs in my head (A Phantom of the Opera fanfiction)

Erik has been searching for his soulmate for a long time. You see, he can hear his soulmate singing in his mind but he's never known whose the voice belongs to. For a while, he thought it was Christine because she could hear a voice too. But he later learned it was her childhood sweetheart, Raoul. After his many murders and accidentally burning down the Opera House, he searches for his mysterious soulmate. As he searches for a way to leave Paris, he meets a young sailor named (Y/N) (L/N). She is part of a crew of a trading ship that she escaped on when she was only ten years old. When (Y/N) lets Erik leave and work on the ship, Erik sees and learns things he never thought he'd learn. But his soulmate has gone silent since he met her. Has something happened to her? Only by traveling into the unknown will give him the answers he needs. DISCLAIMER! I don't own you, Erik, Phantom of the Opera, any songs, pictures, videos, etc. This is a Soulmate AU. I got inspiration from a YouTube comment on a duet of Into the Unknown sung by Elsa and Panic! At The Disco. So, credit to this idea goes to that comment. I don't remember the username or if they want to be mentioned. So credit that comment should you find it. Enjoy the book.