A Second Chance {Nightmare x Reader}
- Reads 57,722
- Votes 1,954
- Parts 21
Ongoing1h 30m
Last published Thu, May 30, 2024
You and Nightmare were best friends. With her unique soul, Nightmare always found it easy to talk to her. They were both outcasts, in a way. After her untimely death, Nightmare ate one of his apples from the tree he and his brother guarded, becoming corrupted.
Several hundred years later, while collecting negative energy, Nightmare saw a new soul that was similar to yours. Is it just a coincidence or... is it a second chance at a relationship cut short?
(Cover not mine)
All Rights Reserved
#95
nightmarexreader
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Crossmare Valentine Special
(I do not own Undertale or the AUs, I just own this story!) Cross never did believe he would receive love. Nightmare never thought he would find love. Maybe they both were wrong, on a number of things. And just maybe, they can share an apple together at last.Complete
The sweet lilac behind the cold cyan
What if the corruption that invaded Nightmare's mind after eating the apples disappeared? When he woke up after a long sleep Nightmare found himself in a place he didn't know. He couldn't sense his brother or mother anymore and was covered in some weird goo. The last thing he remembers was the fight he had with the villagers that wanted the apples. Will he be able to go home back to his family? Does he even truly want it? This fic had been inspired by little-inky night switch Au! I can only recommend you to see their art!Complete
The King's Queen (Nightmare Sans x Reader)
PLEASE READ BEFORE GETTING INTO THE STORY Description: Your name is (Y/n) and you are originally from an au called Dreamtale! Your life hadn't been the easiest however, but you were quick to always move forward despite this... Before Nightmare had become corrupted, you were his best friend and lover. You kept him from his breaking point, you maintained his sanity and most importantly... returned his love. One thing that is definitely important about yourself is that you are a selective mute... And your only desired partner for conversation is the King of Negativity himself... But what will happen once the true evil lurking within your lover drowns out whatever light he had left? What will happen when you discover that the Nightmare you knew was replaced by a monster that still somehow holds love for you? "And even with the evil finally in control of Nightmare, if both his sinister side and his old self agreed on something- then it would always be his priority... They both love her." This is practically my first story that I have ever decided to share online. It is quite a terrifying experience for me, so I hope that anyone who decides to read this will enjoy it. Anyway, I should probably inform my readers about a few things. First off, my primary language is not English, however, I will still be making an effort with my grammar! Second off, I will try and update this as frequently as possible... Even though I can get somewhat shy or concerned about how my work goes. Otherwise, all you will need to know is this: (Y/n): Your name (F/n): Friend name (E/c): Eye color (H/l): Hair Length (H/c): Hair color (S/c): Skin color (F/c): Favorite color Some things I will likely determine for the reader, but what is posted above will be the basics. Please also note that this story may contain some content that would be best for more mature audiences. Also, the cover image belongs to me, please do not use it without permission or steal it.Complete![The Night & Day [DISCONTINUED] - A Dreamtale Crossover Story](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/252439513-256-k806340.jpg)
The Night & Day [DISCONTINUED] - A Dreamtale Crossover Story
One day, a boy who goes by Night, travels farther than he should.. Ending up in a multiverse that isn't his own, and meeting someone named, Dream. Dream, having lost his brother to an *Unknown Cause*. In the end, these two stick together, but in the long run.. Would Night choose to go back to his AU..? Or would Night choose to stay with Dream forever.. Stuck with the worry of his brother. ..Join us on this journey, with the troubles, the terrors, and of course, to see how this story ends. This was a RP with my friend. They like angst, so, be warned. Keep in mind, this was also my first roleplay with Sans AUs, as well as for my friend.Complete
Stuck Together (Nightmare!Sans x Reader)
(First wrote this on Quotev loll) Humans and Monsters. Most people despise monsters, but not you. In fact, you fell in love with one. A king. And a Human. Who knew that a monster made of negativity could feel love. Who knew a person could love someone like that. Who knew that you being a negativity battery, would lead to a love story. Who knew that *he* would fall for someone as simple as you. #3 in #nightmare - 5/23/22 #3 in #xsans - 5/23/22Complete
Given An Unwanted Second Chance
(TW: unaliving thoughts and memories at the beginning. It gets better over time, don't worry! Trauma is difficult to overcome...) You didn't want a second chance. You didn't want to survive. You wanted the sweet release of death. But it seemed like the universe was far too cruel to allow you even that. It took away your memories, your free will to choose whether you live or die...hell, it took the one thing in life you owned! Your own name! And now it seemed like you had to live yet another cruel life, doing things you never wanted done to others. But...at least you could do things your way. Maybe this second chance wouldn't be so bad... (Reincarnated as Nightmare Sans, but unlike other stories, you have no clue what Undertale even is) (WE REACHED NUMBER 1 IN THE UNDERTALE TAG YOOOOOOOO) (9/13/25)Complete
Become Mine And Mine Alone
(REWRITE OF THIS BOOK IS UP! It is called "Obsessive Love".) (I do not own the cover, Undertale nor any of the characters besides my OC's, they belong to their respectful owner. For some reason, I just see Error in the front instead of passive Nightmare.) Error, Forced God of Destruction and Destroyer of Universes was largely unknown unlike Ink, the Creator and God of Creation. Their fights were unseen by the AU's, none of the Monsters knowing about the Destroyer as Ink doesn't want them scared and Error gave no shits if anyone knew him or not. But Error's job is a complicated one, one that he is forced into, and he has to get involved to destroy the worlds. He doesn't touch the Original AU's, but the copies that Ink makes have to go. It was only a matter of time before something happened. Ink, in a middle of one of their fights, blinded Error, hurting him much more badly then ever before. In panic, Error ported into one of the Original AU's. Ink, fearing what Error would do, tells Dream about the Destroyer. Now the hunt is on for the broken, blinded skeleton. Meanwhile a blinded Error has been taken under the wing of another powerful Monster who has fallen for the broken Destroyer at first sight. But sweet love is truly beyond him. It is a obsessive love, a unhealthy love unlike any other. Nightmare would do anything for Error, and would do anything to keep him by his side as he goes about taking over all the AU's. Now to convince Error that he should be his and his alone.Complete
Expectations and a Golden Stitch-A DreamError/Insomnia Fanfic
Dream always felt the weight of expectations on his shoulders and they've only grown worse now that he's a Star Sans. Save this AU, rescue that person, stop Nightmare over there, and make X person smile! It's a never-ending cycle of tasks and he gets asked more about why he hasn't done it sooner or defeated his brother yet than thanked for what he accomplished. He feels trapped in this position and doubts if he didn't have his positive aura that anyone would care for him. Most like him for the joy he brings or what he can give them. Nobody around him ever feels genuine without a doubt in his head. Add in the stress of protecting one Star Sans(Swap) and keeping the other(Ink) from starting trouble and you have a positive guardian ready to break under expectations. Then you have Error, the destroyer of AUs. His reputation speaks for himself and builds all the expectations he needs whenever he steps foot into another AU. He's as bad an omen as a black cat crossing your path. Others assume he is bad because of his "freakish" or glitching appearance. He has accepted these but it gets tiring when he already has the voices bossing him around or Fate reminding him that he should do more destruction. But he doesn't limit himself to destruction. He watches UnderNovela, admires the stars, and appreciates what he can. He pushes the limits of what is expected of him or disregards them completely. A trait that Dream eventually finds himself admiring in him, the known enemy of his friend. He knows that Error's feelings are genuine since he doesn't change in his presence(still an angry manchild). So when Dream gets wounded and stuck with Error on a whim, where will it take them? Will it be a mistake remaining in a hatred of enemies or will it change them both for the better? Could this admiration open Error up to corrupting Dream or will he be the influence Dream needs to against expectations and live for himself?Complete
Black and White (Nightmare x reader????)
Y/N lives in a world of 2 brothers. Long ago, they were protectors of a tree, one that held both positive and negative energies. Dream, and Nightmare. Dream protected the positive emotions, whilst Nightmare protected the negative ones. These were in the form of light golden apples, and rough looking black ones. Dream was liked and cherished around the kingdom, while Nightmare was often injured by ignorance within the subjects. One day Nightmare got sick of it. He ate a apple. He destroyed everything. Dream and a few allies managed to escape and start their own kingdom. now there are 2 kingdoms. Nightmare's, And Dream's. And this my friends, is where our story begins. I want to give a big shout out to @childofbears for letting me use their unfinished idea! Thank u so much! So thanks for the adoption! The original title was "A Tainted Love" if you wanna check out the original. Y/N = your name. This is also aimed toward a female audience. I would've done they/them, but I was already 5 chapters in, and I didn't feel like changing it. Cover art is not mine, I will make some when I get the chance. This is also an empire verse story.Complete![[Shattered Dream Angst] Daymares ★](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/316475587-256-k588183.jpg)
[Shattered Dream Angst] Daymares ★
You know the story. Dream kept a dark apple hidden from Nightmare. And finally, in desperation to understand his dear brother's pain, he ate the dark apple in front of Nightmare and turned into a dark creature with tentacles that have the strength of whole armies. But. In this timeline. This alternate Multiverse. Nightmare takes his unconscious brother back to his castle and keeps him in the dungeon until he can find a way to cure his beloved little brother, and fix everything that he'd done wrong to their relationship that led to this. Unfortunately. Dream may already be too far gone to save. ~~~~ First and foremost WARNING ‼️‼️‼️ - rape (ya, no good) - torture (that will be fun) - hallucinations (trama 🤙🤟) - pregnancy (spoilers but for the warning) - miscarriage (oop) aaand ya know, this is not going to be a friendly story. Be warned. all art done by me SHIPS INCLUDED: Dark Cream Crossmare HorrorDust Hatemare aaand... teeeechnically ErrorInk????? but not really??? ANGST ENJOY ★Complete
(I do not own Undertale or the AUs, I just own this story!) Cross never did believe he would receive love. Nightmare never thought he would find love. Maybe they both were wrong, on a number of things. And just maybe, they can share an apple together at last.
More detailsContent Guidelines