I Was An Island (Treebros)

Death shouldn't be worthy of love. Connor Murphy the literal incarnation of death has never loved anyone. He'd never found someone worth it, someone who could look past his exterior and could see who he really was. Until the day he hears singing, he follows the singing and finds a siren.
Sirens shouldn't be worthy of love. Evan Hansen breaks hearts every day with his beautiful voice. He is destined to draw those to him but they can never find him and he will never find love. Until one day a shadowy figure shows up.
Connor is unhappy with his lonely life and so he whisks Evan away from his island in order to add beauty and serenity to his world of decay. But overtime Evan grows weary and misses the life he once had full of sun and light.
But Connor is not so inclined to give up his songbird so easily.