Creepypasta Would You Rather?

Reads 3,213
Votes 31
Parts 20

Ongoing<5 mins

Last published Fri, May 15, 2020

Would you rather kiss offender, or slender? Creepypasta would you rather questions? leave your answers in the comments!

Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.

I Got You ~Ticci Toby x Reader~
!Warning! May contain Inappropriate language, actions and killing !You have been warned!
Complete
𝚆𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚝𝚑𝚎𝚢? [✔] {Jeff the Killer x Gender Neutral Reader}
In order to save your life, Slenderman does what he swore he'd never do - he makes you his proxy. Little did you know how much it would change your life... - - - The reader is kept gender-neutral throughout the whole story and smut chapters always have two versions (one for male and one for female anatomy). Tldr; this is a creepypasta x reader fanfic, let's not take it *too* seriously. Characters here are probably very OOC, I shaped them as I wish to create a fun story ;3
Complete
Creepypasta boyfriend scenarios (Complete)
So..I am in love with creepypastas and I thought why not write a book..so here you go this will involve Slenderman Jeff the killer Ben drowned Hoodie Masky Ticci Toby Offenderman Eyeless Jack Laughing Jack Sorry if this is cringe, I wrote it when I was 12
Complete
Creepypasta Parent Scenarios
This is my first time doing one of these, so please please please let me know where I can improve! Also, I'm going to describe features, but feel free to change them to fit your appearance so that it's a self insert and not an X!Reader. Thank you for reading! A Star Notes is mentioned, until I figure out how to write the personality of them. When that's done, I'll edit where it'll be placed(Like the # it's placed under) and so updates for that will be like a spam update. (I'm using gender neutral terms like they/them/their because I don't like to put genders down, and especially since this is an x!reader and there could be males females and non binary's/genderfluid people reading this book.)
Complete
Our New Addition - A CreepyPasta Fanfiction. [DISCONTINUED]
I'm no longer working on this story. Truth be told, I don't like it. I kept telling myself that once I got it started I'd sort of warm up to it, but at this point I've given up on it. I have no motivation nor desire to continue it. I do, however, have other CreepyPasta-related story ideas. Stay tuned for those. <3
Complete
Masky x reader: Behind the Mask [DISCONTINUED]
November 2018- 1st in maskyxreader (wow) -------- Some notes before we start: Yes I know that Masky is not part of creepypasta but I love creepypasta and I just want to have it in the story. - - - - - - - - - Blurb: y/n, a fearless girl who loves exploring the woods next to her and getting into trouble. One day, her and her friends stumble upon a house in the woods. But not just any house, a mansion of incredible looks. After a mysterious man attacks her friends, y/n is left to explore the mansion by herself and finds herself in an unlikely situation
Complete
The Innocent Eyes (Jeff The Killer X Reader)
*100,888 words* Strange things happen under strange circumstances and sometimes the most unsafe people make you feel the most safe. When you meet Jeff, he's not exactly like the stories you've heard. Perhaps he's just broken, but aren't we all? Can you fix each other? Will he finally be able to love something, despite his insanity? What are the true stories of him and other creepypastas?
Complete
My Killer Of A lover (eyeless x reader)
you're a new rookie killer, and slender takes notice of you right away. You get ready to kill the news reporter that was talking shit about you, but someone beat you to it. the one and only Jeff the killer. Jeff tries to kill you but fails. this really got Slender's attention. suddenly your taken hostage by the creepypasta group, and slender keeps talking about you secret.will you tell him? You meet EJ and for some reason you don't feel afraid when you're with him. He is basically your babysitter now. You start having feeling for him and he acts really sexual towards you. What?
Complete
Killers Love Too - Reader x Creepypasta
Hey guys! This is my 2nd story. If you haven't read my 1st, it's called Fnaf: Foxy Finds His Mate . Anyways, this is about a girl who comes face-to-face with none other than JTK ( if you don't know who that is your not a real creepypasta fan ) He takes you to Slender Mansion and you meet all of the creepypastas. Who will you fall in love with? Will it be the right choice? Read to find out =3
Complete

I Got You ~Ticci Toby x Reader~

!Warning! May contain Inappropriate language, actions and killing !You have been warned!

More details

Content Guidelines

Creepypasta Would You Rather?

You may also like

I Got You ~Ticci Toby x Reader~

𝚆𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝚊𝚛𝚎 𝚝𝚑𝚎𝚢? [✔] {Jeff the Killer x Gender Neutral Reader}

Creepypasta boyfriend scenarios (Complete)

Creepypasta Parent Scenarios

Our New Addition - A CreepyPasta Fanfiction. [DISCONTINUED]

Masky x reader: Behind the Mask [DISCONTINUED]

The Innocent Eyes (Jeff The Killer X Reader)

My Killer Of A lover (eyeless x reader)

Killers Love Too - Reader x Creepypasta