Double-sided

Mamma always said there was two sides to a story but when it comes to the brooks brothers there's either 3 (or 1 if the law are involved.) "Sir, I was with my brothers that night." Everyone in town knew that line off by heart. They were known for getting in trouble with the police alongside their two friends, James and Daniel. Nobody knew exactly how dangerous they were until a girl goes missing and all clues point to them.