At least I keep his eyes in my life

This story is based on the Hamilton musical song Satisfied but has a happy ending.

Alec and Magnus were together for three years but broke up. They meet again at a party two years later, Alec never stopped loving Magnus and realizes this is his chance to win Magnus back. He reconnects with Magnus but just as he hopes that Magnus still loves him back, Magnus still loves him back, Alec realizes that Izzy is in love with Magnus. Alec loves Izzy so much and can't bear the thought of being the reason she would loose her chance of happiness with Magnus. So he sets Magnus up with her even though it devastates him.

But ten years later Izzy and Magnus end their marriage and Magnus meets Alec again. Magnus discovers Alec's sacrifice and realizes he still loves Alec. After reconciling Alec and Magnus get back together.