More Than a Pretty Face (Jeff x Reader)

BrittMyerz1997

Reads 1,739
Votes 81
Parts 4
Time 10m

Reads 1,739
Votes 81
Parts 4
Time 10m

BrittMyerz1997

creepypasta jeff jeffthekiller jeffxreader reader

Every girl that Jeff the Killer meets and murders hasn't been afraid of him for the past 6 years. All he wants is for someone to be afraid of him, but love him at the same time. Then you show up. And his whole world changes.All Rights Reserved

creepypasta jeff jeffthekiller jeffxreader reader

Table of contents

4 parts

#209jeffxreader

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Jeff... Jeff the Killer by Tori_Berry157

Jeff tells himself that he will never fall in love and only kill. What happens when he finds the right girl that can make him love again?

Forever Alone (Book 1 of the Misguided Killer Series) by Unseen-and-unspoken

Jeff has always felt the weight of being alone. Even with the other Creepypasta, he was the freak; the outcast. They believed he was demented and insane, and maybe he was. Did it matter? Did that insanity, something they all shared, make him undeserving of emotion? He felt. He wasn't cold and emotionless like people believed. He was a person and while he might be demented that didn't mean he couldn't feel. He could laugh, he could cry, he could feel fear. He could feel love. But never in front of others. Never. Despite the hand reaching for him through his darkness, he felt Forever Alone. Could that change? Could someone like him find someone to love?

Killers Can't Love (A Jeff The Killer Romance) by MrsTesstheKiller

Jeff is a cold-blooded, insane murderer who only feels the urge to kill. But what happens when he meets a girl that couldn't relate to him more? Now Jeff has this strange feeling in his chest that he can't seem to identify. Could it be...love? But his arch rival soon finds out about his love for the girl and uses it against him. What will happen when Jeff has to rescue the love of his life in less than 24 hours?

Jeff The Killer - The real story. by poisonedcoffee

How did Jeff become who he is now? Read on and find out the true story of how he came to be.

The Need (Jeff x Jane Love Story) by AlaricaAnge

I thought I saw it and felt it all. Turns out there's a lot more to be seen, even for me. Jeff the Killer.

The Innocent Eyes (Jeff The Killer X Reader) by MusicIsGreat678

*100,888 words* Strange things happen under strange circumstances and sometimes the most unsafe people make you feel the most safe. When you meet Jeff, he's not exactly like the stories you've heard. Perhaps he's just broken, but aren't we all? Can you fix each other? Will he finally be able to love something, despite his insanity? What are the true stories of him and other creepypastas?

My Life with Jeff the Killer by SilentNight5

A girl named Amy who meets a killer. Not knowing that there is a future to him with her.

Jeff the Killer x Reader: Don't Go to Sleep by BrideofCipher

Prepare for your somewhat ordinary life to be altered by the one and only Jeff the Killer, but is it just Jeff that is turning your whole life around? With years of having the same nightmares and strange mind-reading abilities, it seems Jeff is just the start of what comes next. Jeff x Reader: Stay Awake! is the continuation of this story.

I Found You {Jeff The Killer X Reader} by XxTheFairyQueenxX

『 #8 ɪɴ ᴊᴇғғ ᴛʜᴇ ᴋɪʟʟᴇʀ 』 The blood rushed over my body, heart beating, world spinning. It was a whole new world, I never knew something so bad could feel so good. The blood on my hands, the scream of their voices- I've done it. I've killed my first victims. This was the first murder in 2 years in our small town since Jeffery.. Now I know why he did it. The feeling, eating inside you, craving to get out. I stood there, staring at the bodies. I heard the sirens- growing closer, closer... And that when I saw him. Standing in the back yards corridor. Smiling, eyes not moving from my sight. "Found You." And that's when he grabbed my hand and ran. A new adventure began; [Trigger warnings: Murder; Rape; Prostitution]

A Jeff the Killer Story - by Fairyboi_666

After murdering his whole family, Jeff creates his own world of memories, realizing he is in love, with a very morbid boy. Trigger warning - FOR MATURE AUDIENCE - includes extreme violence, sexual themes, self harm, suicide and abuse

Jeff... Jeff the Killer

Jeff tells himself that he will never fall in love and only kill. What happens when he finds the right girl that can make him love again?

More details