If Things Were Different - DrownedTrying - Wattpad

If Things Were Different

Reads 579
Votes 24
Parts 6
Time 1h 19m

Reads 579
Votes 24
Parts 6
Time 1h 19m

bendrowned creepypasta eyelessjack hoodie hoodieandmasky jackxreader jeffthekiller masky maskyandhoodie proxies proxy readerxcharacter readerxcreepypasta slenderman slenderthearrival ticcitoby ticcitobyxreader tobyxreader

Twenty-one. The age everyone waits eagerly for, the day you discover who your soulmate and who your enemy are. Two different people, two different stories.
Everything changes the night of your twenty-first birthday when something unexpected happens. Your luck has always been shit, but this time, it'd be bad enough to kill you.
Considering, of course, they don't do it first.
(Dark!Ticci Toby x Reader)All Rights Reserved

bendrowned creepypasta eyelessjack hoodie hoodieandmasky jackxreader jeffthekiller masky maskyandhoodie proxies proxy readerxcharacter readerxcreepypasta slenderman slenderthearrival ticcitoby ticcitobyxreader tobyxreader

Table of contents

6 parts

Sign up to add If Things Were Different to your library and receive updates

or

#59ticcitobyxreader

Content Guidelines

You may also like

Imposter (Ticci-Toby X Reader) by VikingMetalToby

This story is also available in its partially edited form on Quotev: https://www.quotev.com/story/15711430/Imposter-Ticci-Toby-X-Reader/1 You're just a kid that happens to look like Ticci-Toby and the low IQ pastas think you're actually him while your low IQ dads think Toby is you. Read to find out what happens! (cover art is by Lynnarty.) ¡ W A R N I N G S ! • Poor Storyline • cursing (what do you expect in a CP story?) • happy ending? hahah, nope. • Kinda doesn't make any sense. Start: February 5, 2022 Fin: October 11, 2022

Sounds So Sweet - Ticci Toby X Reader by omorfa

The goggles blinding your view sends fear tickling down your spine. The mouth guard mimics a smile worth a thousand words. This threat is here to kill you. Although you want to welcome it with open arms, the one in front of you still scares you. More neck turns, although now it sounds like it's the cracking of a neck rather than swift head turns. Each click makes you push further back into the arm gripping your side.... DISCLAIMERS : -Toby is not dialogued in accordance to his ticks, but stutters and stumbling over words are mentioned! It's just a lot to put in and I want my readers to be focused on the plot rather than his Tourette's. -if you aren't comfortable with many scenarios that involve injury or sensitive thoughts or cursing, please read at your own risk. the point is for fun, and I don't want to trigger anything for my readers :( -I drew the cover :) but it was when I had my old username and i'm definitely not redrawing that LOL

You've Missed Mouthy by The_AllyGator

"Jeff, this is Mouthy. She's my proxy." Slender waves his hand at the girl. Jeff grows frustrated. "Another one! I thought you would stop gathering them after picking up Toby! How many proxies do you need?" "I currently have six on hand." Jeff's jaw drops and he starts counting on his fingers. "So, Masky, Hoody, Toby, and her. So there's still two I don't know of. Boss, why haven't you told anyone else about her or the other two?" "Jeff, I haven't told you becau-" Slender begins his explanation but the hotheaded teen interrupts. "I wouldn't be surprised if you haven't even told the other three." Jeff stands off his chair screaming at the tall man as he turns his head to the girl on the floor and she looks up to him, pausing her stitching to nod in silence.

Camp Creepypasta {Ticci Toby x Reader} [BOOK 1] by deepinecstasy

Basically, you're 18. You were homeschooled your entire life but you were fine with that, you preferred to be alone. Your parents never cared to spend time with you and they neglected you which was part of the reason you were so used to being alone. You loved creepypastas and read them whenever your parents would neglect you. One night, when you snuck out of the house and towards the lake to go clear your mind, some girls pushed you in and you almost drowned but you were saved by who you thought was a fictional character. Then, you receive a letter, telling you about a camp that was perfect for you. You went and even made some friends, but more and more happens and everything keeps getting worse. You need to try and fix things before things spiral beyond your control, There has to be a way to stop this, right? Read the story to find out what happens! -------- « Book Status: COMPLETE » completed on 03/11/2020 This is a series of books, this book is the first thus why it says 'BOOK 1' in the title. The second book and the rest of them will be on my profile. - BOOKS OUT SO FAR: 2/7 [ also, this is a Marble Hornets and Creepypasta crossover, so expect some Marble Hornets related chapters :) ] [ cover art by Lynnarty ] (!) [TW/CW: strong language, self-harm, suicide, drugs, described gore, long mf chapters lmao] (!) All your support truly means a lot to me! -------- Rankings: hoodieandmasky - #1 ! [wOW] hoodieandmasky - #4 😔 Creepypasta - #595 ouch :,( hoodieandmasky- #3 👀 Creepypasta - #820 seriously- hoodieandmasky- #3 👁-👁 hoodieandmasky - #2 ! Toby - #148 hoodieandmasky - #326 (HOW THE FU-) Toby - #114 :D ticcitobyxreader - #5 ! proxy - #1 ! proxies - #1 !✨ creepypasta - #279 sally williams - #1 (why tho lmao she's like not mentioned once i don't think) creepypasta - #592 toby - #23 :)

Masky x reader: Behind the Mask [DISCONTINUED] by The_Pseudonymous_One

November 2018- 1st in maskyxreader (wow) -------- Some notes before we start: Yes I know that Masky is not part of creepypasta but I love creepypasta and I just want to have it in the story. - - - - - - - - - Blurb: y/n, a fearless girl who loves exploring the woods next to her and getting into trouble. One day, her and her friends stumble upon a house in the woods. But not just any house, a mansion of incredible looks. After a mysterious man attacks her friends, y/n is left to explore the mansion by herself and finds herself in an unlikely situation

Masky X Reader X Hoodie by WildChild289

Alone in the forest, A runaway from your abusive ex bf, A savior named hoodie takes you to a mansion.... An outgoing guy and a cold hearted killer. 2 guys 1 heart... Who will you choose?.

Sinister love (creepypasta X fem!reader) by m1lfandD1lfl0v3r

A young, hot, but depressed college girl who only wishes someone would put her out of her misery accidentally stumbles upon an ongoing murder. She does the right thing...by getting the fuck out of there, it ain't her problem that person was getting stabbed. However it becomes her problem when said murderers were aware that she was a witness and one that they let get away. Now stopping at nothing, the killers agreed to find the woman and keep her mouth shut, the one that she was never going to open anyway💀 A creepypasta X fem!reader

Slenderman - Three Proxies by Multi-FandomFangirl2

This is a story about Slenderman and him talking about his three proxies; Masky, Hoodie, and Ticci Toby. Masky: Timothy Sutton grew up in a mental health asylym ever since he was a small child. He's been seeing things ever since. But now, the things he sees seem so real. Then, something happens that'll change his life forever. Hoodie: Ever since his bestest friend Tim disappeared, Brian has been looking for him and wondering where he has gone. Just when he thinks that Tim is dead, Brian receives a strange letter in the mail only to realize that it was from Tim. What shocking secrets will he find out about Tim and where he's been all along? Ticci Toby: Toby Rogers is an average 16 year old high schooler. Although, he can't feel pain and he twitches every once and awhile. Until one day, he and his older sister get into a car crash, killing her and leaving him with minor injuries and a broken arm. He slowly begins to lose his mind and he starts seeing a tall figure outside of his window. Where will fate leave Toby Rogers?

I've Finally Found Where I Belong...With The Killers. -Ticci Toby- by SketchaCreeps

Toby Rogers, otherwise known as Ticci-Toby, is a seventeen year old boy who's life is forced into the Creepypasta Mansion, after an incident that caused Toby to kill his father, and set his neighbourhood on fire. With his memory gone, and his long list of mental illnesses, Toby finds himself frightened and alone in the mansion, surrounded by serial killers, psychopath's, and monstrous creatures. But after a while, Toby finds himself feeling safer and more wanted, as he becomes friends with the Creepypasta's. Until his memories start to come back, giving him horrible visions of murders, and Toby is determined to get to the bottom of it all. When a figure from his past returns, and Toby is tricked and captured, the Creepypasta's must fight to save Toby... Or he will be murdered for his past.

The Devil's Demon [Ticci Toby X Reader] by SteveFromCorporate

Sometimes life doesn't go to plan. Sometimes the people you love, don't love you back. Sometimes, you get fed up with some people and take matters into your own hands. She's baack! By she, I mean you. (Y/N). You're back. The long awaited sequel to "A Dance With The Devil" is finally here! With a whole lot more drama and more. Dedicated to all the people who were so supportive in the first book! I hope you love it. *** (Y/N) has been through one hell of a time when she first encountered the love of her life,Toby. After the death of her friends and her own near death experience, (Y/N) can finally relax in the safety of the creepypasta mansion. Or so our sassy friend (you) thinks. A year has past and (Y/N) is now 19 years old. Her year long, rocky relationship with Toby has kept her happy. But when (Y/N) hears some bittersweet news, her excitement turns to rage when she gets fed up of how indecisive Toby is. What will she do? ** All credit for the amazing cover art goes to the artist!

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

Imposter (Ticci-Toby X Reader) cover

Sounds So Sweet - Ticci Toby X Reader cover

You've Missed Mouthy cover

Camp Creepypasta {Ticci Toby x Reader} [BOOK 1] cover

Masky x reader: Behind the Mask [DISCONTINUED] cover

Masky X Reader X Hoodie cover

Sinister love (creepypasta X fem!reader) cover

Slenderman - Three Proxies cover

I've Finally Found Where I Belong...With The Killers. -Ticci Toby- cover

The Devil's Demon [Ticci Toby X Reader] cover

Imposter (Ticci-Toby X Reader)

This story is also available in its partially edited form on Quotev: https://www.quotev.com/story/15711430/Imposter-Ticci-Toby-X-Reader/1 You're just a kid that happens to look like Ticci-Toby and the low IQ pastas think you're actually him while your low IQ dads think Toby is you. Read to find out what happens! (cover art is by Lynnarty.) ¡ W A R N I N G S ! • Poor Storyline • cursing (what do you expect in a CP story?) • happy ending? hahah, nope. • Kinda doesn't make any sense. Start: February 5, 2022 Fin: October 11, 2022