two sweaters one indecisive gal

Damon Salvatore (your band mate, along with two others), Rachel Berry (your best friend) and Edward Cullen (your lab partner) go to the same school as you, you guys talk on a daily basis, and you don't remember a time where you and Rachel didn't sit together, however it's only recently that Damon and Edward had joined your miniature friendship group. Things recently have been eerie in your humble town, and you can sense something's up, but what exactly is it?