[ This is a Sallyface x Reader fanfic, in this timeline the cult does not exist, leaving only the paranormal events as the strange happenings in the story. Characters are aged up, Sal being 17 and Larry being 18, etc. I hope everyone enjoys this budding love story between themselves and Sallyface! <3 ]
Moving is always difficult, especially when your new home is an eerie building within a grim town. You didn't have high expectations, or any expectations at all really, this was just another uneventful chapter in your life. At least, that's what you thought before encountering an unusual person adorned with blue pigtails, a prosthetic mask, and ghost stories to tell. Strange people, strange events, strange feelings begin to appear in your life. Your love story definitely isn't normal, but hey, nothing is in Nockfell.
💌
━━━━━━
When you were young, you gained a small pen-pal who lived in New Jersey. Letter after Letter, you grew to care for your pen pal. Until, the letters suddenly stopped coming and over time, this pen pal seemed to become a vivid memory in your mind. Then, a boy and his father move next door to your apartment.
Who would've guessed what was to come next?
━━━━━━
RANKINGS:
#417 in female
#500 in femalereader
#126 in videogames
#12 in sallyface 🥇
(NOTE: I do not own Sally Face or any of the characters mentioned in the story, all rights belong to the creator Steve Garby.)
Enjoy! :D