Forgive But Never Forget: A Glee Story
Chickentoe01
  • Reads 172
  • Votes 2
  • Parts 11
  • Time 51m
  • Reads 172
  • Votes 2
  • Parts 11
  • Time 51m
Chickentoe01
Ongoing, First published Nov 29, 2020
betrayalcomedy-dramacomedy-romancefanfictionfinnhudsongleelesbiannoahpuckermanpregnancysantana
Evangeline and Nancy have been dating for two months, and they trust each other completely... most of the time. Tensions rise when Nancy reveals she is pregnant and doesn't know who the father is. It's either the infamous Noah Puckerman or the football ballerina Finn Hudson. Evangeline and Nancy must find out who the father is before it is too late and they are willing to do anything. Even Join the Glee club!
All Rights Reserved
betrayalcomedy-dramacomedy-romancefanfictionfinnhudsongleelesbiannoahpuckermanpregnancysantana
Table of contents

11 parts

Sign up to add Forgive But Never Forget: A Glee Story to your library and receive updates
or
#267santana
Content Guidelines
You may also like
santana and brittany by cactustravis
50 parts Complete Mature
santana, an in-closet lesbian, and brittany, an out of the closet bi-sexual, have a thing. a thing that is only kept in each other's bedroom. santana is head cheerleader and her boyfriend, noah puckerman, is co-captain of the football team and that makes them the "it" couple(something that she doesn't want to loose). brittany is also on the cheerleading team and just wants santana to come out so that they can be the gay "it" couple. but santana likes how people see her as the pretty, straight, cheerleader. brittany doesn't know how much longer she can hang on with this secret and santana doesn't know how much longer she's gonna keep her big secret, along with more of her little secrets that might hurt them in the future. * "ive been doing a lot of thinking. what i've realized is why i'm such a bitch all the time. i'm a bitch because i'm angry." she grabs onto my hand, "i'm angry because I have all of these feelings, feelings for you, that im afraid of dealing with." "why?" she asks, giving my hand a light squeeze "because i'm afraid of dealing with the consequences." i look at her and she bites on her bottom lip, "do you understand what i'm trying to say here?"
Monkeyface, Daddy, Daddy's Girlfriend, Mommy, And? by timesoftrouble
53 parts Complete
Puck raises little Beth on his own. Puck meets a girl and starts to let her in Beth's life. What happens when Quinn comes back with big news? DISCLAIMER: I DO NOT OWN GLEE OR ANY OF ITS CHARACTERS. ALL RIGHTS GO TO RYAN MURPHY, IAN BRENNAN, BRAD FALCHUK AND FOX *originally published summer 2016, edited January 2022* COMPLETELY REWRITTEN SEPTEMBER 2022
A PERFECT MISTAKE, 𝗇𝗈𝖺𝗁 𝗉𝗎𝖼𝗄𝖾𝗋𝗆𝖺𝗇 by _merliya_
117 parts Complete
what if Puck got another girl pregnant? #1 rachelberry #1 noahpuckerman #2 finnhudson #2 quinnfabray #1 willschuester
The Wrong One by MissMoncheleee
50 parts Complete Mature
Everyone thinks Quinn got pregnant. What if it was Rachel? This is a story were the roles are reversed. Rachel's head Cheerio dating the stud running back Noah puckerman. Quinn is the bottom of the Cheerio pyramid and has her eye on Puckerman. Finn is the quarterback but the biggest womanizer. For years Finn has had a crush on head Cheerio Rachel Berry. Quinn has been crushing hard on Puckerman. Both have a sticky situation, there crushes are dating each other. None can do anything about it. Finn can't because pucks his best friend, Quinn is just scared of the outcome. Find out what happens when everything is switched.
need you now by MemoriesStories
33 parts Complete
♥COMPLETED♥ rachel schuester is a senior student on mckinley high school. she has a boyfriend named puck since junior year. rachel and puck are both in glee club were rachel her dad will is teaching. but what happend if her dad gets another job and there is a new teacher: finn hudson 28 years old. who is very handsome, nice and helps rachel with glee practice. will there be romance?? or will puck and rachel stay together??
Accidentally in Love (Glee & Ryder Lynn Fanfiction) by ryderlynnfever
61 parts Complete
In my life, I've been playing with those jerks. I dated them because I wanted them and then I dumped them when I got bored with them. But then he came along and changed everything in me and made me feel special. He was annoying as hell at the first time we met but now I'm in love with him, something that I never feel to those jerks. Life is really beautiful and unpredictable sometimes. - Jade Puckerman. ~~~~ Jade Puckerman. Jake's twin sister and Noah Puckerman's half-sister. A tough girl who is like another Santana Lopez in William McKinley High School. The player and the one who never believe in love or trust a guy until everything is changed when she help Jake with his love problem. What happened? Read the story to find out.
My Brother's Best Friend by MissMoncheleee
40 parts Complete
Big Brothers always make fun of little sisters, even if they're only two minutes apart. You see Rachel Berry-Puckerman is the 'younger' sister of McKinley's badass Noah Puckerman, like all siblings, they fight. The only time they get along is when they have to go to the foster home on olive street. Outside of school Puckermans stick together, due to the terrible home life. So being a good big brother puck looks out for his little sis. Even if it's from keeping slushies away or to having boys 100 feet away from her precious existence. Including his best friend Finn Hudson. What happens when pucks worst fear comes true, and his best bro falls for his little sis? Heartbreak and tension rises within the three causing trust issues and disagreement between the two close siblings.
You, Him And I (Glee Fanfiction) by ryderlynnfever
76 parts Complete
For some people, love someone is not a big thing but what if you love two person at the same time and you have to choose one? And this is happen to Madison. Madison Collins is the head of cheerio in William McKinley High School. She is dating the quarterback, Finn Hudson. Everything was fine until one day, Finn and her join the glee club and there is some kind of "weird" feeling between Madison and Noah Puckerman. How come? What happen? Who will she choose? Finn Hudson or Noah Puckerman?
LABOUR PAINS ━ finn hudson by finnhudsonlvr
38 parts Complete Mature
━ 𝐥𝐚𝐛𝐨𝐮𝐫 𝒑𝒂𝒊𝒏𝒔 📓 ✶ 🜸 ﹕ ૮ 이 🖤 𝐆𝐋𝐄𝐄 & 𝐌𝐎𝐑𝐄 ҂ 𝟎𝟎𝐲 𓍯 𝖿𝗂𝗇𝗇 𓇼 𝗁𝗎𝖽𝗌𝗈𝗇 ♡̶ ゛𝗅𝗈𝗏𝖾 𝗶𝗻𝘁𝗲𝗿𝗲𝘀𝘁 🐈‍⬛
You may also like
Slide 1 of 9
santana and brittany cover
Monkeyface, Daddy, Daddy's Girlfriend, Mommy, And? cover
A PERFECT MISTAKE, 𝗇𝗈𝖺𝗁 𝗉𝗎𝖼𝗄𝖾𝗋𝗆𝖺𝗇 cover
The Wrong One cover
need you now cover
Accidentally in Love (Glee & Ryder Lynn Fanfiction) cover
My Brother's Best Friend cover
You, Him And I (Glee Fanfiction) cover
LABOUR PAINS ━ finn hudson cover

santana and brittany

50 parts Complete Mature

santana, an in-closet lesbian, and brittany, an out of the closet bi-sexual, have a thing. a thing that is only kept in each other's bedroom. santana is head cheerleader and her boyfriend, noah puckerman, is co-captain of the football team and that makes them the "it" couple(something that she doesn't want to loose). brittany is also on the cheerleading team and just wants santana to come out so that they can be the gay "it" couple. but santana likes how people see her as the pretty, straight, cheerleader. brittany doesn't know how much longer she can hang on with this secret and santana doesn't know how much longer she's gonna keep her big secret, along with more of her little secrets that might hurt them in the future. * "ive been doing a lot of thinking. what i've realized is why i'm such a bitch all the time. i'm a bitch because i'm angry." she grabs onto my hand, "i'm angry because I have all of these feelings, feelings for you, that im afraid of dealing with." "why?" she asks, giving my hand a light squeeze "because i'm afraid of dealing with the consequences." i look at her and she bites on her bottom lip, "do you understand what i'm trying to say here?"

More details