" Yeah, you could say you miss all that we had But I don't really care how bad it hurts When you broke me first You broke me first " - you broke me first: tate mcrae peter hale wasn't always the 'heartless' monster he was today. peter's eyes weren't always the cold blue they were today. he had someone he loved greatly, than he lost her. that was how he got the blue eyes he has now. so, when he runs into her niece, he soon discovers that everything wasn't what he thought. [lowercase intended]