The Wrong Guitarist • Ray Toro x Reader

Besides the band, Ray hosts a podcast about guitar with the help of Gerard. When Y/N calls in and they click, Ray gets cold feet about meeting the woman he's been having such deep phone conversations with in person. Letting his insecurities win, he sends Frank in his place, who he believes is physically more what Y/N is looking for. When Frank as "Ray" and Y/N click a little too well, Ray is even more unsure about himself. Through this, can Y/N come to terms with the man she's falling for being so different in person? How can someone be so shy and thoughtful on the phone and so bold and loud in person?

The Truth about Cats and Dogs AU nobody asked for