Security guard for hire by night, courtroom bailiff by day, Joshua Helms is quite the Casanova. Engaged for nearly two years before his fiance suspects him of cheating, he returns to the bachelor life vowing to never again commit. That is, until he meets Cassidy McNickles, an intern court stenographer who makes him question whether the gigolo lifestyle was ever for him. Still, hell has no fury like that of a woman scorned, and despite Josh being torn between being a ladies' man and feelings for Cassidy, Honorable Darcy Pragowski, his ex and still boss, will not rest until everyone knows just how of a cheater he is.