Sam or Dean Girl?
- Reads 887
- Votes 38
- Parts 14
MatureComplete Wed, Dec 30, 20201h 51m
The reader has been staying at the bunker with the Winchesters for a few years now and secretly has a crush on Dean and Sam but she never told them because she knows it would be very awkward to choose one but she felt so much for them both... They all give each other hints but they take it as playfulness and when the bags are switched The boys find her journal and read it one night when they are drunk after a hunt, while she is asleep in the impala. They both have liked her just as much and get in a fight over her but in the end decide to surprise her with a fun sexy night.. This leads to a love triangle maybe even more. Y/N means Your Name! Have fun and enjoy reading
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Still falling for you - Destiel
This is my favorite roleplay I have ever done with a amazing girl :) The roleplay have been going on since June and we are still going. It is a very detailed, drama, smut and fluff filled roleplay. I couldn't bare the thought of it only being the two of us getting to enjoy this story, so I'm re writing it into a fan fiction, sadly you won't get the amazing writing from her since I'm rewriting it myself by memorie, but I'll try and get as much as what she has written and the way she writes into the story. I don't want to talk much about the story.. Its a highschool AU.Complete
Saving His Girl-Dean Winchester x Reader
You and Dean Winchester have been close friends since the two of you met. So close that the lines of friendship/dating can be blurred, memories that the two of you have created together play torturously in your mind at times. Dean knows things about you that you have never shared with any other man. Even with the 10 year age gap you trust him. He saved your life, which created a special bond between the two of you, especially with how extra protective Dean is over his girl. Now that Dean and Sam are back in Sioux Falls for a case, the feelings for one another are stronger and harder to resist. Nothing comes easy though...not for a man who believes he does not deserve happiness. ***Possible daddy kink. ***Disclaimer: You know the drill-I do not own Supernatural, the characters, storylines, or anything related to the series. This is for pure fanfiction only. Enjoy!!!Complete
Wet and Gushy
The boys go on many hunts, along the way, Dean and Cas's love unfolds before your eyes. WARNING: CONTAINS SMUT!! (Yes Sam is in here because we can't leave the moose out!!) Also leave any suggestions you guys may have in the comments below, I would love to hear your requests and ideas for new stories!! Don't forget to vote as well, that would help me so much!! Make sure to follow me so you don't miss any new content!! Thank you Supernatural fans!!Complete
Destiel high school kidney
This is a Destiel story. Dean have a big crush on Cas. He have had it for a while. He have given up on thinking Cas likes him back. He tries to get over him. Dean thinks Cas thinks he is annoying and Cas ignores him as a answer for what Dean thinks. Mary and John have divorced. John comes home drunk after a week waisting him self again.Complete![I Don't Bite [Dean Winchester x Reader] Book 2](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/256110453-256-k628651.jpg)
I Don't Bite [Dean Winchester x Reader] Book 2
After a year and a half as the Winchester's companion, Y/N finds herself tangled in their messy world of demons, psychic children and an unavoidable apocalypse. Together, she works with them and her ever growing pack to solve her own mysteries of skinwalker life, and help the troublesome Winchesters prevent the end of days. --- "You know I'm still mad at you, right?" He hummed, pressing a lingering kiss to my throat. "I bet I could make you forget about it for a while." "I think I'd like that." --- "I thought I told you not to do anything stupid!" "You told me not to do anything stupid until you got back. And now you're back." --- "If you don't stop pissing me off, Winchester, I'm going to kick your sorry ass all the way to Alaska and let you freeze to death." "If it makes you happy, I'd do it for you." Please note that none of the chapters are edited, unless it says so at the end of the chapter in bold. That being said, I'm sure there are plenty of typos throughout the story, and I will fix them eventually. Highest Rankings: #2 in winchesterxreader (08/09/24) #5 in spnxreader (08/09/24) #176 in dean (08/09/24)
Four Wishes For The Angel // Destiel AU
Castiel Novak didn't want to go to the dinner. But his parents told him to be there, he couldn't skip it. His life was okay at this point. He had a couple of friends, did good at school, his parents were cool (well as cool as they can be when you are a single child and adopted), he didn't have panic attacks anymore, he managed to hide his wings and no one bullied him anymore, almost. At this point he didn't want anything to change, but he usually didn't get what he wished for. That night everything changed. He knew he shouldn't have gone to that dinner, but that doesn't mean he regret it. He met his best friend that night, a best friend he might be falling for. It was at the dinner he met the boy who asked for his four wishes, Dean Winchester. ～～～～～～ AN: English is not my first language so I'm sorry for any grammar mistakes. Its also my first fan fiction! (I do not own any of the characters)Complete
Gemini (Supernatural Rewrite Sam x Reader x Dean)
Saving people. Hunting things. That's the family business you were born into, whether you want it or not. You grew up next to Sam and Dean Winchester, and now you're chasing monsters and trying to outrun the ghosts of your past. But secrets don't stay buried forever. The truth about what and who you are threatens to tear everything apart. Now, with the apocalypse on the horizon, you're fighting more than demons. You're fighting yourself. Because the closer you get to saving the world, the closer you come to losing yourself... and the two brothers who'd burn it all down to save you. OR a SPICY why choose reader insert about saving the world. One monster at a time. DONT BE A GHOST READER, i live for your comments. currently at ≈ 800k words 👀 this work has a playlist! https://open.spotify.com/playlist/49o0VYt5n3pWM98KECvVlA?si=l-DItSsaT2ipWoOmVKZrfQ&pi=Hi_0cVeLS1e-1 Top 3 in SamxReader 7/24/24 🏆 Top 10 in DeanxReader 7/27/24 🏆 Top 30 in Dean 7/28/25 🏆 Top 3 in Supernatural 06/10/26 🏆 Top 5 in SPN 12/12/24 🏆 #1 in Sam Winchester 07/13/26 🏆 Disclaimer: I don't like the Y/N thing when writing so, reader has a name (SORRY). I also do not own or claim to own any Supernatural OC's or concepts.
Destiel prison memory loss and Sabriel rehab
This story is about Cas losing his memory after getting almost killed and Dean being accused of it. Dean walked into the scene. He went to Cas. He was still awake at the time but he blacked out slowly after. The cops came in a little after. They accused him of doing it. He went to jail for 3 years. Cas doesn't remember anything. He doesn't know who Dean is. Gabriel didn't want him to know anything. Because they think Dean did it and that he just tricked Cas because he is gay. The story goes in after he has been in jail. Its also Sabriel in the story. It says when it starts if you dont wanna read it or thats what you want to read:) Hope you guys like it💗Complete
ᏚᎪᎷ ᏔᏆNᏟᎻᎬᏚᎢᎬᎡ X ᎡᎬᎪᎠᎬᎡ 📚 🍻💘
When the Winchester brothers travel to the bad place to save their mother they run into Y/N who insists that her and Sam are in a relationship.Complete
Natural Born Sinner: A Dean X Female Reader X Sam Fic
Y/N was a civilian who lived a pretty straight-forward, boring, apple-pie lifestyle. She was incredibly smart...in fact, despite her being so young, she graduated top of her class and was now a Theology Professor at an Ivy League university. Lately, however... she felt like she was in desperate need of a change. After all... she was always a straight-A student, always kept her nose clean and stayed as far away from trouble as possible... a perfect goody two-shoes. Despite all this, Y/N knew there was something deep inside of her....something dormant; uncharted territory that kept calling to her. And once she crosses paths with two mysterious and insanely handsome "FBI Agents"... Y/N quickly discovers what it is she's been missing...and her world may just get rocked in an intense, dark, dangerous...incredibly fun...way. ----------------------------------------------- As per several requests, here is my take on a Dean X Reader X Sam fic! I overly appreciate all the love 'Dark Tendencies' received, and I hope this one lives up to expectation! This is an 18+, HEAVY SMUT, semi-slow burn read. As always, there will be some fluff to move the story along, but intense smut is the general idea! A polyamorous, trio thing is the endgame here. There will be NO favoritism! This book is written in first person, but YOU are the main character! (This does not follow the show storyline to a T, I'm just being creative lol) If you wanna bypass the story build-up and get right into the spice, (It's okay, I get it!), those chapters will be marked with ** around the chapter numbers! WARNING: My smut writing is VERY GRAPHIC!! ---------------------------------------------------------- I do not own the rights to Supernatural, Supernatural characters, the Supernatural storyline, or anything like that. This is just a fanfiction written purely for entertainment!Complete
Christmas Angel {Destiel/Sabriel}
Dean Winchester lived on Maple Road in a small town in Indiana. His younger, much taller brother, Sam, lived on Creek circle the next town over. His father was an old drunk constantly in hospitals and jails from being over intoxicated. He had his old uncle Bobby there as a father figure but he lived three states away, making him hard to see often. Now both brothers were quite lonely despite the girlfriends they both had. Dean had Lisa, a women who has short term memory loss. Sam has Jess who was getting sick with fevers from left and right. Both Winchester boys were sick of all of this work. Dean with having to deal with taking Lisa out on first dates almost every week to try and spark her memory. Then Sam constantly in the hospital because Jess was burning up. They also had to deal with there jobs, the older one worked at his mechanics shop, the younger was a lawyer. Now both were planning on spending Christmas alone. Dean in the shop and Sam in his library. Christmas was never something they could get into, everything was just too canny. But then they both get some new neighbors and began to discover some feelings they never knew were there.Complete
The Unknown Winchester
"Im your father." I said slowly. She smiled and said "nahh you're just a sperm donor." What happens when dean Winchester discovers he has a daughter? ☆ 3 in father-daughter on 27/4/2020 ☆ 4 in spnfamily on 19/6/2020 ☆ 6 in CWTV on 21/3/2021 (Im a new writer so please no judgement. Im trying to improve myself and hopefully sometime in the future i get better.)Complete
Lost boys
(Cover http://karacoon.deviantart.com/art/Destiel-Sabriel-TV-NIGHT-352515859 ) Cas and his brothers, Gabriel, Michael and Lucifer, had to move into another town for several reasons. A new town meant a new school and that happened right in the middle of the school year. At Castiel's first day of school he already got in real trouble with a group of mean students. -------- Sam and Dean didn't have the best life. Their Dad was almost always gone and if he was there, there was yelling and a lot of getting punched. In school Dean acted the bad boy but when he was alone his world broke together. He was soft and hurt. Even though he was Sam's protector. Never would he ever let anything happen to Sammy. He took blame for stuff Sammy did just to keep him safe. Safe from their Dad. Safe from everything. (probably Destiel&Sabriel ff)Complete
Is This Just Fantasy?(DISCONTINUED)
!Destiel! !There will be some Sabriel references! !Sam Winchester X Reader! (A bit Gabriel X Reader too...) Cover is my edit😂 Sorry if it sucks I tried. •°Reminders°• Y/N = Your Name L/N = Last Name S/N = In Show Name (This is what your name would be during the show) H/C = Hair Color H/L = Hair length F/N = Friend Name H/T = Home Town •°•°•° Y/N L/N is an average from H/T. Not a fan of gay shit she sees. She then stumbles upon a certain app... Tumblr A social media app which fully supports LGBT, and also an app taken over by a so called show 'SuperWhoLock' Her having no idea what that is... What will she do? ~~~ O/C/N No worries I'll make it longer. So yeah! The characters may be a bit OOC. So yeah. The story might escalate quickly. No plot twist so don't expect much. A lot of swearing. Also a try hard comedy... JK! Shut up I'm hilarious. Started: December 17, 2018 Published: April 24, 2019 Finished: (N/A)Complete
Angel Wings (SPN) #Wattys2015
Dean Winchester is a musician, and well know at that. His brother Sam is always with him, and they travel the world on Dean's tours. Castiel Novak is a misfit of sorts, who wants to turn his life around after some trouble with the law. An avid dislike of the musician Dean Winchester is tested when his brother Gabriel wins a contest and gets to go on tour with the young star, and brings along Castiel as his plus one. After the tour ends, and they have all grown close, they move in together, Dean and Castiel, and Sam and Gabriel. But when Sam and Gabriel are in an accident, caused by Gabriel, Dean blames him and his brother, testing his relationship with Castiel like never before. Full of plot twists, drama, feels, and a bit of fun in bed, this Supernatural AU threatens to grip the hearts of all fans of the show, and shippers of either one of the pairings. No foul language or *extreme* bedtime fun.Complete
Love is Hell
Y/N is a hunter who has been hunting with Sam and Dean Winchester. They have given her a room in the bunker and she has become the little sister they never had, always looking out for her. So, when Dean, who is the over protective big brother finds out that Y/N has feelings for a supernatural being he is shocked and appalled. How had this happened? How could Y/N have feelings for a being she has never met? Not just any supernatural being. He is the demon with the British accent. The King of Hell himself. King Crowley! She knows his past. The stories are full of torture, pain and deals. She knows he is a being who cannot be trusted, who is evil, conniving and he is someone she can't get off her mind, even though she has never met him. How can this be? **This is a mature story for 18+** This story contains lots of "Smut!"Complete
Let Me Go
Last year Dean made a deal. Bring his brother back to life in exchange for his own. Now that has come to pass. One year later Dean is killed by hellhounds and taken to Hell. Cas teams up with his brothers to bring Dean back to life, but of course there are challenges along the way, and nothing goes to plan. Something is very wrong with Dean and it is not so easily fixed or forgotten. Full of twists and turns, follow along with Cas and Sam as they try and fix what's been broken and restore their family once more. And maybe... just maybe find something more. Relationships: Destiel (Cas/Dean) Sam/Cas (friendship)Complete
Just Friends? (Sam Winchester × Reader) Supernatural Season One
When you met Sam at Stanford, you knew your life would be filled with friendship and support. But you're pulled into the world of the supernatural after Jessica, Sam's girlfriend and your best friend dies. Mysteries unravel as you join Sam and his brother Dean on an adventure to find their father. Saving people, hunting things. And discovering your true past... Your road trip with the Winchester brothers brings you closer to Sam. Will you and the youngest Winchester be just friends or maybe more than that? Second book in the series-'More Than Friends.' (I suck at titles) Contains triggering content. I only own Y/n and her backstory! Book cover by me.Complete
This is my favorite roleplay I have ever done with a amazing girl :) The roleplay have been going on since June and we are still going. It is a very detailed, drama, smut and fluff filled roleplay. I couldn't bare the thought of it only being the two of us getting to enjoy this story, so I'm re writing it into a fan fiction, sadly you won't get the amazing writing from her since I'm rewriting it myself by memorie, but I'll try and get as much as what she has written and the way she writes into the story. I don't want to talk much about the story.. Its a highschool AU.
More detailsContent Guidelines