Rival
- Reads 325
- Votes 1
- Parts 17
Ongoing3h 18m
Last published Fri, Jul 18, 2025
Sophie Foster has spent the past three years recovering from the tragic disaster that took her parents' lives.
All the while, she was thrown into a new home and life. Her adoptive parents put her in a prestigious school called Foxfire. Making new friends and losing old ones, after three years of struggling, Sophie's finally starting to settle in.
Then the nightmares start. Horrible flashes of some other life Sophie never lived.
But with weird things going on, someone new coming to Foxfire, and strange memories recovered, soon Sophie doesn't know what to believe anymore. Sophie remembers two different lives and isn't sure which is the truth.
❀ ▫ ❀ ▫ ❀
This story is a Keeper of the Lost Cities fanfiction, so it's advised you read them (book one through Unlocked) before reading this, to avoid confusion. There will be QUITE A FEW references and SPOILERS to past events of the series.
Most of these characters (except the ones I created) rightfully belong to Shannon Messenger, author of KotLC!
All Rights Reserved
#457
sophiefoster
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Light It Up | ✔ | #2
Keefe's departure took a toll on Sophie. She's been in a bad place, her life spiraling downhill. Deciding that she can't stay at Foxfire for the Elite levels because everything reminds her of him. But when she unrolls in a new school because of her troubles a few year later, she's shocked to find the last person she thought she would find there: Keefe. She ran because of him, and now he's here again, complicating things by a million. Is there anything really worth living for any more? ------------------------ This is a Keeper of the Lost Cities fanfiction, meaning that most characters belong to Shannon Messenger. This story is the second book in the Playing with Fire series. It can be read as a standalone, but some parts might make a lot less sense without context. All Right Reserved. #2 in foster-keefe, #1 in teamfosterkeefe, #1 in keephie If you are reading this book on a website other than Wattpad you may be at risk of a malware attack. The following is the link to the original platform that is safe to use: https://www.wattpad.com/story/127170840-light-it-up-%E2%9C%94-2 Part of the Playing With Fire Series: Set A Torch To Flame Light It Up Dear Keefe, Love Foster You Can't Burn Ashes [Bonus Chapters]Complete
Not Your Moonlark/ A KotLC FanFiction
Sophie Foster finds herself in a fight with everyone she knows- and it's all because of a misunderstanding. Sophie was accused of something she had nothing to do with, but not even Grady and Edaline believed her. And with nothing to lose- and nowhere to go- she decides it's time to just stop- disappear- and hope that starting a new life will help her forget about it all. But not everything comes that easy. She faces challenges and obstacles- times that are good and bad- but what will happen when everyone realizes that Sophie had nothing to do with it? Will they just let go? Or will they do everything in their power to bring Sophie home? (Disclaimer! All characters *except for mine, go out to the amazing Shannon Messenger!)Complete
Misfit |KotLC AU|
Sophie knew first hand what it felt like not being able to fit in. She lived with it for most of her life; since her parents died, and she skipped grades more than once, she was used to people looking at her weird. But it's the moment they don't when it gets to you. ********* Keeper of the Lost Cities AU in which Sophie's parents are dead, Fitz smiles too much, Dex is just...there, Keefe is an artist, Biana spends money everywhere, and somewhere in there is a story with a bad ending. Most chapters will be pretty short. Sorry 'bout that. ********* abandoned story, I'm sorry 🤡Complete
When the Stars Fall
When Sophie finds out that she is pregnant she doesn't know what to do. Does she tell the dad? Her parents? Her friends? She's in her 2nd year in the Elite Levels. She and her friends are still fighting the Neverseen, them being mostly gone, but still in the shadows. Sophie and her friends endure struggles, family issues, fight through the backlash and the hard 9 months of pregnancy. Until something horrible happens... A/ N - All characters from the official KOTLC series belong to Shannon messenger, other than the ones I have created. Please do not plagiarize or copy my characters into your own fan-fiction without asking first. Disclaimer: pls pls pls finish the series before reading this fanfic... I REALLY don't want to spoil anything for u guys 1st in kotlc (08/04/2022) 1st in keeperofthelostcities (8/12/2021) 1st in sophiefoster (05/09/2021) 1st in sokeefe (05/10/2021) 1st in foxfire (26/02/2022)Complete
Silently Screaming (Kotlc human AAU)
Sophie Foster is sweet, unique, kind, and afraid. She was bullied her whole life, and has never had a friend except her cousin Dex. Once he moves away Sophie's life turns to hell. To make her life worse, her adoptive parents abuse, mistreat, and neglect Sophie because they are always on drugs. Sophie now has to tolerate everyone who bully's and abuses her, while trying to free herself from this chaos. *Warning mentions of blood and abuse*Complete
Keeper Of The Lost Cities Oneshots
This is a Keeper of the Lost Cities oneshots book! All Kotlc characters belong to the lovely Shannon Messenger, This book contains LGBTQIA+ ships, and I will not tolerate homophobia. Thank you for reading!!-Clover🍀Complete
Living in a Blur: a Sokeefe University/Road Trip AU
Keefe's parents may be rich, but their fortune isn't his to spend. His father made it very clear that if his grades drop and he loses his scholarship at Foxfire University, his parents will pull him from university and his offer from Judge Emery to forget his... run-ins with the law will expire. Sophie was in foster care with Emma and William Foster before she was adopted by Grady and Edaline Ruewen. She was homeschooled for most of her life, but decided she wanted to go to a real University-Foxfire University, right near their home in California! Luckily for Keefe, grades come easy. Luckily for Sophie, she's about to run into friends that will forever change her life. But both of their goals are turned upside down when the circumstances of their meeting spiral into a cross-nation road trip, just the two of them. They both came to college with a plan. Sophie plans to explore and learn. Keefe plans to get his degree and then his revenge. Neither of them are planning to fall in love. Updates every Thursday! Read on ao3: https://archiveofourown.org/works/56969809/chapters/144870070Complete
Reborn
Due to unknown reasons, Sophie Foster has just woken up in Book 1 at the museum with all her memories still intact. Now as a 12-year-old, Sophie must figure out how to make everything go right this time and try to stop the Neverseen in the process. This fanfiction was started in late 2018, right before Flashback was published. Please keep in mind that some of the ideas will reflect this. Everything in this fanfiction takes place before Legacy to avoid any confusion. Some ideas, wording, and dialogue are taken straight from Shannon Messenger's Keeper of the Lost Cities in order to make the plotline make sense. All rights for characters and general plot belong to Shannon Messenger.Complete
Keefe's departure took a toll on Sophie. She's been in a bad place, her life spiraling downhill. Deciding that she can't stay at Foxfire for the Elite levels because everything reminds her of him. But when she unrolls in a new school because of her troubles a few year later, she's shocked to find the last person she thought she would find there: Keefe. She ran because of him, and now he's here again, complicating things by a million. Is there anything really worth living for any more? ------------------------ This is a Keeper of the Lost Cities fanfiction, meaning that most characters belong to Shannon Messenger. This story is the second book in the Playing with Fire series. It can be read as a standalone, but some parts might make a lot less sense without context. All Right Reserved. #2 in foster-keefe, #1 in teamfosterkeefe, #1 in keephie If you are reading this book on a website other than Wattpad you may be at risk of a malware attack. The following is the link to the original platform that is safe to use: https://www.wattpad.com/story/127170840-light-it-up-%E2%9C%94-2 Part of the Playing With Fire Series: Set A Torch To Flame Light It Up Dear Keefe, Love Foster You Can't Burn Ashes [Bonus Chapters]
More detailsContent Guidelines