Shy From The Spotlight - Alexander Hamilton x Reader - I’d rather not, thx. - Wattpad

Shy From The Spotlight - Alexander Hamilton x Reader

Reads 202,128
Votes 5,803
Parts 128
Time 8h 39m

Reads 202,128
Votes 5,803
Parts 128
Time 8h 39m

alexanderhamilton andpeggy angelica eliza fanfic fanfiction forgotten hamilton historical schuyler texttospeech wattys2022 whatif xreader

"But we can't!" Margarita insisted. Angelica faced her little sister, but something caught her eye. "Y/N, come out from the corner." She insisted. You sigh in defeat and step out from the shadows.

<><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>

Your entire life is clouded by three names. Angelica, Eliza, and Peggy. Those three names became famous, while you hid from the spotlight. 

You are noticed by few. You, Y/F/N Schuyler, are the true forgotten sister. You life is filled with damage after a single man enters your eldest two sister's lives. Though he brings damage, he brings you light. He takes notice to you. You quickly grow on him, until he asks for something more. Is he worth your sisters?All Rights Reserved

alexanderhamilton andpeggy angelica eliza fanfic fanfiction forgotten hamilton historical schuyler texttospeech wattys2022 whatif xreader

Table of contents

128 parts

Sign up to add Shy From The Spotlight - Alexander Hamilton x Reader to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

A Jeggy story (Soulmates AU)✔️ by fr0zen-y0gurt

*THIS BOOK IS NOT EDITED EXPECT A LOT OF GRAMMAR MISTAKES AND CRINGY WRITING* Imagine a world were you have a tattoo of something that means the most to the person you are meant to be with. Peggy Schuyler thought she might never find that person. Till John Laurens showed up. Maybe if they got over all the complications. They could be the perfect couple. That's what soulmates are supposed to be after all. Started: April 27th, 2019 Finished: June 30th, 2019 Best ranking: #1 Jeggy

Walk On The Wild Side ♡ JEGGY ✓ by xo-charlii

❝You're Margarita Schuyler, aren't you?❞ ❝Peggy.❞ I correct. ❝Just Peggy.❞ The freckled face boy tilts his head and smirks at me. ❝Hmm. No.❞ ❝No? You can't just tell me you aren't going to call me by my preferred name.❞ ❝I can, actually.❞ Who does this guy think he is? And, why is he so attractive while he's being a jerk? ♡ John Laurens is angry. Peggy Schuyler is fed up. John is stormy and hot-headed. Peggy is bright and loving. Though her sisters tell her he's bad news, Peggy can't stay away from him. She doesn't want to. She sees something in him no one else does. John absolutely adores Peggy. She's the first person that's ever stuck up for him since his mother died. Peggy is his everything and he'd be damned if anyone tries to take her away from him. No one wants them together, and they're going to find out just how far their friends will go to break them up. John and Peggy made a pact that they'd do anything for each other. The lengths they go to, to protect each other will inevitably be their downfall. While they're both trying to grasp onto something real, they'll end up losing it all in the end. ------------------------------- Contains strong language, drug use, violence, explicit sex scenes, vulgar language, sexual assault, mentions of sex, and rape and death. I'll put trigger warnings at the start of each chapter! But read at your own risk! This is for mature audiences! --------------------- Started - 03/29/21 Published - 4/02/21 Completed - 9/29/21 Rankings: #4 in hamiltonmusical - 8/20/21 #4 in laurens - 6/10/21 #12 in hamliza #3 in andpeggy - 8/10/21 #86 in hamilton - 9/22/21 #2 in johnlaurens - 10/4/21 #4 in jeggy - 10/4/21 #1 in jeggy - 10/17/21 #1 in peggyschuyler - 10/17/21 #2 in hamiltonmusical - 11/22/21 #3 in jeggy - 01/21/22 #1 in jeggy - 07/01/22

That Boy is Mine by DannyandAnnie

Peggy was never the popular one out of the Schuyler Sisters. Angelica was the perfect one that everyone loved. Eliza was the sweet doll that was always admired by boys. Peggy was... just Peggy. Then, at a ball her father hosts, she meets a soldier named John Laurens. He loves everything about her. The rest is history.

Moving in : A Hamilton Fan - fic by AlivePringles

Alexander is the new boy with a dark past. John can't decide who to love. Angelica doesn't want to give her love up. Eliza gets easily manipulated. Peggy has always been forgotten. Maria gets abused. As for Hercules and Lafayette? They have it pretty good. But what happens when all 8 are forced to share a college dorm room? Join them on an emotional journey through love, loss, friendship, and more in this modern telling of Hamilton. *Modern Times* Cover is mine, made from canva!

Flowers Amongst the Garden | John Laurens Love Story by solitude_sof

~ "Schuyler." The name has formality, grace, elegance, charm and riches... Four daughters. A sassy know-it-all, a kind cinnamon roll, a bittersweet rule-follower and a girl who doesn't even care. All four daughters are unique, different, but similar in different ways. One yearns for something, something no woman or girl has ever thought of wanting. Her freedom. ~ I don't own Hamilton I just own my OCs. All credit goes to Lin Manuel Miranda

"Over a Book" [MODERN HAMLIZA] by ellabellaIou

COMPLETED Elizabeth Schuyler is a 21yr old woman who lives with her two sisters, 18yr old Peggy Schuyler and 23yr old Angelica Schuyler in a cosy apartment in New York. She works at a nearby coffee shop and frequents a library quite often where she loves to get lost in books. She's known around her small corner of the city for being pretty and kind-hearted. Aside from that, her life isn't abnormal; she graduated with succeeding marks and is now just a not-very-rich girl trying to make a living, whilst putting up with her two sisters that drive her insane. That is, of course, until she met the book boy, who would drag her into more than she had bargained for. ~~~ credits to szin for the book cover drawing & the drawings for each chapter TWs are in each chapter ! #2 in hamliza, 12/11/20 #1 in hamliza, 28/11/20 extra disclaimer: for the purpose of the story, i alter their ages slightly. for example, the sisters historically were only one year apart. here, they are 3&2 years Roughly 93k words!

Abandoned by exulansis_writes

You think Peggy Schuyler is the forgotten sister? Ha. No it's Victoria. The forgotten Schuyler sister, Victoria Schuyler, she's always been more of a boy than that of a lady, so that's why at the Winters Ball- which her sisters held so they could find love and leave her behind- when 3 men have their attention on her the whole night, they ask her an unbelievable question. How could she say no? Of course her sisters would abandon her like everyone else has in her past. Hopefully these men would stay for a while. Maybe her whole life.. Angelica~! Peggy~! Eliza~! And Victoria.... wORK Completed: 12-3-20

Violet (Marliza) [Completed] by alycias_adelaide

(Used to be Modern Marliza Social Media Au) The Schuyler Sisters are very well known not only are they huge YouTube and Instagram stars their father owns a very huge business and is even friends with George Washington who owns many universities and is mayor of the town the Schuyler sisters are very popular and the envy of all but will things change when Maria Reynolds walks into there life?

Yellow (A Hamilton (Jeggy) Fanfiction) by QCollins

I gave up saying "And Peggy" A long time ago. Let's be real, it hadn't worked. Nobody noticed the middle sister, even when I wore yellow 24/7. But something changed after I met Maria Lewis. She became my first real friend. Then there was the party. The party where I got to know John Laurens. Then there was the hospital. #1 in Jeggy #1 in Lafayette #2 in Eliza #2 in Peggy #4 in Yellow

Who Tells Our Story? by hcmiltcn_schuyler

Alexander Hamilton and Eliza Schuyler are the exact opposite of each other. Though they have their differences, their love prevails. Alexander Hamilton has been on his own for as long as he could remember. Even since he was a child, some of his earliest memories are those of being alone on the island he was born on, Nevis. His father left when he was a young child, and his mother fell ill and died when he was only the tender age of 12. Those experiences shaped Alexander into the man he is now; a hard working, loyal, strong, independent, dedicated, intelligent, man. His writing is what got him off the island, but it's his gang, The Sons Of Liberty (SOL) with his pals John, Laf, Hercules, and Washington that keep him going. Until he met Eliza.. Eliza Schuyler was born into wealth, and into a safe, loving, caring home. She's always surrounded by her family. Eliza is most commonly found alongside her sisters, Angelica, and Peggy. Though it seems as if Eliza has everything one could want, there is one thing she wants and doesn't have; love. She wants nothing more than to fall in love. Eliza is a hard working, caring, shy, talented, passionate, young lady with a heart of gold. It isn't until she falls for a certain bad boy that things start to change.. A modern day Hamliza fan fiction. Can Eliza separate the good from the bad? Can she change Alexander? Will Alexander change her? Are they too opposite to even work? *This story may contain sensitive or heavy subjects, and I will try to do my best to add trigger warnings*

Running Out of Time by Vjewells

Being immortal always sounds like a cool idea at first. Dying and being reincarnated with all of your memories sounds twice as cool. However, after so many times it's not so cool. It's repetitive and a little bit boring. Still, nothing lasts forever and, at some point, everything changes. Whether it's for the better or for the worst isn't always an easy call to make, especially in the case of Alexander Hamilton. Peggy Schuyler has always been close with Hamilton but she never thought that they would be like this. When things take a turn and she is the only one who can see him, it makes her question how Eliza didn't lose her mind while being married to him. It becomes partially her job to figure things out for him while she also tries to keep his presence a secret. Just when Peggy thinks her life is back to normal, something else comes up. With the help of a few friends, she manages to find some answers but there's still questions left at the end of the day. Peggy is still looking for answers long after Hamilton is finally capable of finding them himself. His answers are found in John Laurens. Her answers are found in potato chips and a strange, old book. She just hopes she can find all the answers she needs before time runs out on all of them.

When Two Worlds Collide by queencaffeine_

Lafayette's a ragtag man, who can't keep his eyes off the Schuyler sister he's been yearning for. And Peggy? Ignored by her sisters, taken as an irresponsible little brat, a shadow of Angelica and Eliza. That was, until Lafayette came and stole her heart. Maybe it was doom... to be caught like this. To soon be broken hearted by the obstacles that lay ahead, and to be head over heels for a poor revolutionary. UPDATE! There may be some Alexander X Laurens action here and there...

She'd Be Lying by hcmiltcn_schuyler

A modern day story about the Schuyler Sisters. Angelica, the oldest, is in her senior year of high school, and is constantly applying to all the top notch colleges. Eliza, the second oldest, is in her junior year of high school, and is a member of her schools choir. She's dating the schools newspaper writer, Alexander. And Peggy, the youngest sister, is in her sophomore year of high school, struggling to make the grade. She looks up to her darling older sisters, but often feels cast aside. The Schuyler's, being as wealthy as they are, are more than able to provide for their wants, needs, and expenses. They live a very organized house structure; each family member has their own color. Angelica is pink, Eliza blue, and Peggy yellow. When Angelica and Eliza walk into their closet, (the sisters share a room with a large closet), looking for something to wear out, they notice some red articles of clothing in their baby sisters size and start to grow curious. (Collaboration with @theogschuylersisters. They asked for me to help them so it's now here!)

The Colors of Soulmates {Jamilton} ~Completed~ by checkers65

AU where when you kiss your soulmate you can see colors. Here's the catch, after the kiss, you'll only be able to see them if you and your soulmate are touching. (the main ship here is jamilton so I think you can see where this is going) ;) {College AU and Soulmate AU} Have fun? i dont know how to end these summaries so ya... ___________________________ Ranking: #2 in jamilton

The Opposite Rebirth [Hamilton Reincarnation AU][DISCONTINUED][BEING REWRITTEN] by trulee_emberrr

ANGST WARNING BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT I'M BEST AT! The Hamilton characters but they have switched genders. They are all classic teenagers in high school and live pretty Average lives. Alexis is also a huge theater nerd and fangirl with health problems so when she hears that theres a feild trip in a month to go see Hamilton she gets super excited. Once they go to see the play however their world changes. Is it for better or worse? Or thats what the story was supposed to be. Instead its just hospital visit after hospital visit and the worst thing I've ever written. Continue at your own risk. Started: May 5th, 2020 Discontinued on June 18th, 2020 NOT MY ART

marliza/jasippa oneshots by w0nderland_z0

MOVED TO (@tay20052005) NO LONGER UPDATING ON THIS ACC

Satisfied by zynger7ing

"He walked over slowly to me and I couldn't move. I couldn't push him away, I couldn't say no. He grabbed my face and stroked my cheek. "You hurt me" I whispered. "I know. And if I can get a chance to make it up to you I will. I never forgave myself. I never will until you can forgive me." He slowly leaned in and I still couldn't move. I didn't want to. I needed to feel his lips against mine. The intensity crept up my spine and we were so close I felt his breath on my lips..."

Forgotten || A Hamilton x Schuyler!Reader Fanfiction || ✔️ by saimaa_lima_bean

If you thought Peggy was the forgotten sister, you're terribly wrong. • • • Aaron chuckled a bit as he saw (Y/N) running around with the energy everyone expected from her. Just like her older sisters, she was beautiful and selfless, with big doe eyes that seemed to show friendliness to whoever she met. Her lavender dress flattered her figure and her shiny (H/C) hair framed her face in a way that men chased after her everywhere she went. However, her most defining quality was her smarts. She loved to debate and talk politics; if she weren't a girl, Aaron bet she could've become something great. • • • Status: completed, small edits might be made as needed Rankings: 4 in #alexanderhamilton (7/30/19) 7 in #hamilton (9/29/19) 1 in #schuylersisters (9/7/19) 2 in #hamiltonxreader (10/6/19) 3 in #philiphamilton (10/6/19) 1 in #peggyschuyler (3/28/20)

𝑇ℎ𝑒 𝑊𝑜𝑚𝑎𝑛 𝑖𝑛 𝑅𝑒𝑑 | 𝐴 𝑀𝑎𝑟𝑙𝑖𝑧𝑎 𝐹𝐹 by -nxvaa-

𝙸𝚗 𝚊 𝚠𝚘𝚛𝚕𝚍 𝚠𝚑𝚎𝚛𝚎 𝚢𝚘𝚞𝚛 𝚜𝚘𝚞𝚕𝚖𝚊𝚝𝚎𝚜 𝚒𝚗𝚒𝚝𝚒𝚊𝚕𝚜 𝚜𝚑𝚘𝚠 𝚞𝚙 𝚘𝚗 𝚢𝚘𝚞𝚛 𝚜𝚑𝚘𝚞𝚕𝚍𝚎𝚛 𝚠𝚑𝚎𝚗 𝚢𝚘𝚞 𝚝𝚞𝚛𝚗 𝟷𝟾, 𝚠𝚑𝚊𝚝 𝚠𝚒𝚕𝚕 𝙴𝚕𝚒𝚣𝚊 𝚍𝚘 𝚠𝚑𝚎𝚗 𝚜𝚑𝚎 𝚖𝚎𝚎𝚝𝚜 𝚊 𝚋𝚎𝚊𝚞𝚝𝚒𝚏𝚞𝚕 𝚜𝚝𝚛𝚊𝚗𝚐𝚎𝚛... 𝚆𝚑𝚘 𝚑𝚊𝚙𝚙𝚎𝚗𝚜 𝚝𝚘 𝚑𝚊𝚟𝚎 𝙴.𝚂. 𝚘𝚗 𝚑𝚎𝚛 𝚕𝚎𝚏𝚝 𝚜𝚑𝚘𝚞𝚕𝚍𝚎𝚛. 𝚂𝚝𝚊𝚛𝚝𝚎𝚍: 𝟺-𝟸𝟾-𝟸𝟶𝟸𝟷 𝙴𝚗𝚍𝚎𝚍: 𝟼-𝟷-𝟸𝟶𝟸𝟷

You Will Be Found || Lams || COMPLETED by starstruckham

John Laurens wish he could say that he loved Peggy. After all, they have been a pair since high school. Although he couldn't deny that he cared for the Schuyler sister, in his third year of college, a new potential number jumps into the equation, leaving a helpless John Laurens confused and breathless. ~ Alternating POVs between Alexander and John. Alex only speaks through his journal entries, and John's POV is entirely narrative. ~ REGULAR UPDATES!!!

You may also like

Slide 1 of 20

A Jeggy story (Soulmates AU)✔️ cover

Walk On The Wild Side ♡ JEGGY ✓ cover

That Boy is Mine cover

Moving in : A Hamilton Fan - fic cover

Flowers Amongst the Garden | John Laurens Love Story cover

"Over a Book" [MODERN HAMLIZA] cover

Abandoned cover

Violet (Marliza) [Completed] cover

Yellow (A Hamilton (Jeggy) Fanfiction) cover

Who Tells Our Story? cover

Running Out of Time cover

When Two Worlds Collide cover

She'd Be Lying cover

The Colors of Soulmates {Jamilton} ~Completed~ cover

The Opposite Rebirth [Hamilton Reincarnation AU][DISCONTINUED][BEING REWRITTEN] cover

marliza/jasippa oneshots cover

Satisfied cover

Forgotten || A Hamilton x Schuyler!Reader Fanfiction || ✔️ cover

𝑇ℎ𝑒 𝑊𝑜𝑚𝑎𝑛 𝑖𝑛 𝑅𝑒𝑑 | 𝐴 𝑀𝑎𝑟𝑙𝑖𝑧𝑎 𝐹𝐹 cover

You Will Be Found || Lams || COMPLETED cover

A Jeggy story (Soulmates AU)✔️

THIS BOOK IS NOT EDITED EXPECT A LOT OF GRAMMAR MISTAKES AND CRINGY WRITING Imagine a world were you have a tattoo of something that means the most to the person you are meant to be with. Peggy Schuyler thought she might never find that person. Till John Laurens showed up. Maybe if they got over all the complications. They could be the perfect couple. That's what soulmates are supposed to be after all. Started: April 27th, 2019 Finished: June 30th, 2019 Best ranking: #1 Jeggy