Shy From The Spotlight - Alexander Hamilton x Reader - I’d rather not, thx. - Wattpad

Story cover for Shy From The Spotlight - Alexander Hamilton x Reader by ImBaaaack

Shy From The Spotlight - Alexander Hamilton x Reader

Reads 221,157
Votes 6,098
Parts 128
Time 8h 39m

Reads 221,157
Votes 6,098
Parts 128
Time 8h 39m

alexanderhamilton andpeggy angelica eliza fanfic fanfiction forgotten hamilton historical schuyler texttospeech wattys2022 whatif xreader

"But we can't!" Margarita insisted. Angelica faced her little sister, but something caught her eye. "Y/N, come out from the corner." She insisted. You sigh in defeat and step out from the shadows.

<><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>

Your entire life is clouded by three names. Angelica, Eliza, and Peggy. Those three names became famous, while you hid from the spotlight. 

You are noticed by few. You, Y/F/N Schuyler, are the true forgotten sister. You life is filled with damage after a single man enters your eldest two sister's lives. Though he brings damage, he brings you light. He takes notice to you. You quickly grow on him, until he asks for something more. Is he worth your sisters?All Rights Reserved

alexanderhamilton andpeggy angelica eliza fanfic fanfiction forgotten hamilton historical schuyler texttospeech wattys2022 whatif xreader

Table of contents

128 parts

Sign up to add Shy From The Spotlight - Alexander Hamilton x Reader to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

The Opposite Rebirth [Hamilton Reincarnation AU][DISCONTINUED][BEING REWRITTEN] by trulee_emberrr

ANGST WARNING BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT I'M BEST AT! The Hamilton characters but they have switched genders. They are all classic teenagers in high school and live pretty Average lives. Alexis is also a huge theater nerd and fangirl with health problems so when she hears that theres a feild trip in a month to go see Hamilton she gets super excited. Once they go to see the play however their world changes. Is it for better or worse? Or thats what the story was supposed to be. Instead its just hospital visit after hospital visit and the worst thing I've ever written. Continue at your own risk. Started: May 5th, 2020 Discontinued on June 18th, 2020 NOT MY ART

That Boy is Mine by DannyandAnnie

Peggy was never the popular one out of the Schuyler Sisters. Angelica was the perfect one that everyone loved. Eliza was the sweet doll that was always admired by boys. Peggy was... just Peggy. Then, at a ball her father hosts, she meets a soldier named John Laurens. He loves everything about her. The rest is history.

Yellow (A Hamilton (Jeggy) Fanfiction) by QCollins

I gave up saying "And Peggy" A long time ago. Let's be real, it hadn't worked. Nobody noticed the middle sister, even when I wore yellow 24/7. But something changed after I met Maria Lewis. She became my first real friend. Then there was the party. The party where I got to know John Laurens. Then there was the hospital. #1 in Jeggy #1 in Lafayette #2 in Eliza #2 in Peggy #4 in Yellow

Flowers Amongst the Garden | John Laurens Love Story by solitude_sof

~ "Schuyler." The name has formality, grace, elegance, charm and riches... Four daughters. A sassy know-it-all, a kind cinnamon roll, a bittersweet rule-follower and a girl who doesn't even care. All four daughters are unique, different, but similar in different ways. One yearns for something, something no woman or girl has ever thought of wanting. Her freedom. ~ I don't own Hamilton I just own my OCs. All credit goes to Lin Manuel Miranda

She'd Be Lying by hcmiltcn_schuyler

A modern day story about the Schuyler Sisters. Angelica, the oldest, is in her senior year of high school, and is constantly applying to all the top notch colleges. Eliza, the second oldest, is in her junior year of high school, and is a member of her schools choir. She's dating the schools newspaper writer, Alexander. And Peggy, the youngest sister, is in her sophomore year of high school, struggling to make the grade. She looks up to her darling older sisters, but often feels cast aside. The Schuyler's, being as wealthy as they are, are more than able to provide for their wants, needs, and expenses. They live a very organized house structure; each family member has their own color. Angelica is pink, Eliza blue, and Peggy yellow. When Angelica and Eliza walk into their closet, (the sisters share a room with a large closet), looking for something to wear out, they notice some red articles of clothing in their baby sisters size and start to grow curious. (Collaboration with @theogschuylersisters. They asked for me to help them so it's now here!)

Walk On The Wild Side ♡ JEGGY ✓ by xo-charlii

❝You're Margarita Schuyler, aren't you?❞ ❝Peggy.❞ I correct. ❝Just Peggy.❞ The freckled face boy tilts his head and smirks at me. ❝Hmm. No.❞ ❝No? You can't just tell me you aren't going to call me by my preferred name.❞ ❝I can, actually.❞ Who does this guy think he is? And, why is he so attractive while he's being a jerk? ♡ John Laurens is angry. Peggy Schuyler is fed up. John is stormy and hot-headed. Peggy is bright and loving. Though her sisters tell her he's bad news, Peggy can't stay away from him. She doesn't want to. She sees something in him no one else does. John absolutely adores Peggy. She's the first person that's ever stuck up for him since his mother died. Peggy is his everything and he'd be damned if anyone tries to take her away from him. No one wants them together, and they're going to find out just how far their friends will go to break them up. John and Peggy made a pact that they'd do anything for each other. The lengths they go to, to protect each other will inevitably be their downfall. While they're both trying to grasp onto something real, they'll end up losing it all in the end. ------------------------------- Contains strong language, drug use, violence, explicit sex scenes, vulgar language, sexual assault, mentions of sex, and rape and death. I'll put trigger warnings at the start of each chapter! But read at your own risk! This is for mature audiences! --------------------- Started - 03/29/21 Published - 4/02/21 Completed - 9/29/21 Rankings: #4 in hamiltonmusical - 8/20/21 #4 in laurens - 6/10/21 #12 in hamliza #3 in andpeggy - 8/10/21 #86 in hamilton - 9/22/21 #2 in johnlaurens - 10/4/21 #4 in jeggy - 10/4/21 #1 in jeggy - 10/17/21 #1 in peggyschuyler - 10/17/21 #2 in hamiltonmusical - 11/22/21 #3 in jeggy - 01/21/22 #1 in jeggy - 07/01/22

You Will Be Found || Lams || COMPLETED by starstruckham

John Laurens wish he could say that he loved Peggy. After all, they have been a pair since high school. Although he couldn't deny that he cared for the Schuyler sister, in his third year of college, a new potential number jumps into the equation, leaving a helpless John Laurens confused and breathless. ~ Alternating POVs between Alexander and John. Alex only speaks through his journal entries, and John's POV is entirely narrative. ~ REGULAR UPDATES!!!

The Past { Slight Jamilton} ~Completed~ by checkers65

Before his dad left, Alex and his brother used to be a part of their dad's secret spy agency. He loved that life. Thanks to his dad's wealth, he and his brother had non-human hearing, sight, and strength. They were superhuman. But his dad left when he was 10, and he's in his last year of college now. He missed the thrill. But what if people from his past want him to give up what he has now for the life he loved? yes, this is jamilton (kinda) i think i'll change the title...i dont rlly like it college au soulmate au (when you touch, you see colors) spy au (i got the inspiration for a spy au from @jamsandhams or Ava on instagram but its not totally the same.)

Abandoned by exulansis_writes

You think Peggy Schuyler is the forgotten sister? Ha. No it's Victoria. The forgotten Schuyler sister, Victoria Schuyler, she's always been more of a boy than that of a lady, so that's why at the Winters Ball- which her sisters held so they could find love and leave her behind- when 3 men have their attention on her the whole night, they ask her an unbelievable question. How could she say no? Of course her sisters would abandon her like everyone else has in her past. Hopefully these men would stay for a while. Maybe her whole life.. Angelica~! Peggy~! Eliza~! And Victoria.... wORK Completed: 12-3-20

marliza/jasippa oneshots by w0nderland_z0

MOVED TO (@tay20052005) NO LONGER UPDATING ON THIS ACC

You may also like

Slide 1 of 10

The Opposite Rebirth [Hamilton Reincarnation AU][DISCONTINUED][BEING REWRITTEN] cover

That Boy is Mine cover

Yellow (A Hamilton (Jeggy) Fanfiction) cover

Flowers Amongst the Garden | John Laurens Love Story cover

She'd Be Lying cover

Walk On The Wild Side ♡ JEGGY ✓ cover

You Will Be Found || Lams || COMPLETED cover

The Past { Slight Jamilton} ~Completed~ cover

Abandoned cover

marliza/jasippa oneshots cover

The Opposite Rebirth [Hamilton Reincarnation AU][DISCONTINUED][BEING REWRITTEN]

ANGST WARNING BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT I'M BEST AT! The Hamilton characters but they have switched genders. They are all classic teenagers in high school and live pretty Average lives. Alexis is also a huge theater nerd and fangirl with health problems so when she hears that theres a feild trip in a month to go see Hamilton she gets super excited. Once they go to see the play however their world changes. Is it for better or worse? Or thats what the story was supposed to be. Instead its just hospital visit after hospital visit and the worst thing I've ever written. Continue at your own risk. Started: May 5th, 2020 Discontinued on June 18th, 2020 NOT MY ART