Shy From The Spotlight - Alexander Hamilton x Reader - I’d rather not, thx. - Wattpad

Story cover for Shy From The Spotlight - Alexander Hamilton x Reader by ImBaaaack

Shy From The Spotlight - Alexander Hamilton x Reader

Reads 221,893
Votes 6,098
Parts 128
Time 8h 39m

Reads 221,893
Votes 6,098
Parts 128
Time 8h 39m

alexanderhamilton andpeggy angelica eliza fanfic fanfiction forgotten hamilton historical schuyler texttospeech wattys2022 whatif xreader

"But we can't!" Margarita insisted. Angelica faced her little sister, but something caught her eye. "Y/N, come out from the corner." She insisted. You sigh in defeat and step out from the shadows.

<><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>

Your entire life is clouded by three names. Angelica, Eliza, and Peggy. Those three names became famous, while you hid from the spotlight. 

You are noticed by few. You, Y/F/N Schuyler, are the true forgotten sister. You life is filled with damage after a single man enters your eldest two sister's lives. Though he brings damage, he brings you light. He takes notice to you. You quickly grow on him, until he asks for something more. Is he worth your sisters?All Rights Reserved

alexanderhamilton andpeggy angelica eliza fanfic fanfiction forgotten hamilton historical schuyler texttospeech wattys2022 whatif xreader

Table of contents

128 parts

Sign up to add Shy From The Spotlight - Alexander Hamilton x Reader to your library and receive updates

or

Content Guidelines

You may also like

When Two Worlds Collide by queencaffeine_

Lafayette's a ragtag man, who can't keep his eyes off the Schuyler sister he's been yearning for. And Peggy? Ignored by her sisters, taken as an irresponsible little brat, a shadow of Angelica and Eliza. That was, until Lafayette came and stole her heart. Maybe it was doom... to be caught like this. To soon be broken hearted by the obstacles that lay ahead, and to be head over heels for a poor revolutionary. UPDATE! There may be some Alexander X Laurens action here and there...

The Colors of Soulmates {Jamilton} ~Completed~ by checkers65

AU where when you kiss your soulmate you can see colors. Here's the catch, after the kiss, you'll only be able to see them if you and your soulmate are touching. (the main ship here is jamilton so I think you can see where this is going) ;) {College AU and Soulmate AU} Have fun? i dont know how to end these summaries so ya... ___________________________ Ranking: #2 in jamilton

"Over a Book" [MODERN HAMLIZA] by ellabellaIou

COMPLETED Elizabeth Schuyler is a 21yr old woman who lives with her two sisters, 18yr old Peggy Schuyler and 23yr old Angelica Schuyler in a cosy apartment in New York. She works at a nearby coffee shop and frequents a library quite often where she loves to get lost in books. She's known around her small corner of the city for being pretty and kind-hearted. Aside from that, her life isn't abnormal; she graduated with succeeding marks and is now just a not-very-rich girl trying to make a living, whilst putting up with her two sisters that drive her insane. That is, of course, until she met the book boy, who would drag her into more than she had bargained for. ~~~ credits to szin for the book cover drawing & the drawings for each chapter TWs are in each chapter ! #2 in hamliza, 12/11/20 #1 in hamliza, 28/11/20 extra disclaimer: for the purpose of the story, i alter their ages slightly. for example, the sisters historically were only one year apart. here, they are 3&2 years Roughly 93k words!

Let Me Be a Part of the Narrative by FIORITE

""Excuse me, miss?" Looking up, Peggy saw something she definitely did not expect. A boy, standing right in front of her. Wild curly hair pulled into a ponytail, freckles all over his face, smart eyes, he was absolutely gorgeous. "Y-yes, sir?" Silently, Peggy scolded herself. After years of the three sisters all training each other to be confident in the presence of a man, all the 'training' had failed her. The man simply smiled at Peggy in response, which caused her to pretty much melt. "I couldn't help but notice a beautiful woman such as yourself alone on the fine night," He seemed to think through his next words, intriguing her. "And I was simply wondering if you needed even a little company."" Or: While Eliza and Angelica fall in love with Alexander Hamilton, Peggy Schuyler finds herself with a crush on John Laurens. Original photo on the cover is by Killuhime on DeviantArt Highest Ranking: #1 in Jeggy #24 in Hamliza

She'd Be Lying by hcmiltcn_schuyler

A modern day story about the Schuyler Sisters. Angelica, the oldest, is in her senior year of high school, and is constantly applying to all the top notch colleges. Eliza, the second oldest, is in her junior year of high school, and is a member of her schools choir. She's dating the schools newspaper writer, Alexander. And Peggy, the youngest sister, is in her sophomore year of high school, struggling to make the grade. She looks up to her darling older sisters, but often feels cast aside. The Schuyler's, being as wealthy as they are, are more than able to provide for their wants, needs, and expenses. They live a very organized house structure; each family member has their own color. Angelica is pink, Eliza blue, and Peggy yellow. When Angelica and Eliza walk into their closet, (the sisters share a room with a large closet), looking for something to wear out, they notice some red articles of clothing in their baby sisters size and start to grow curious. (Collaboration with @theogschuylersisters. They asked for me to help them so it's now here!)

Forgotten || A Hamilton x Schuyler!Reader Fanfiction || ✔️ by saimaa_lima_bean

If you thought Peggy was the forgotten sister, you're terribly wrong. • • • Aaron chuckled a bit as he saw (Y/N) running around with the energy everyone expected from her. Just like her older sisters, she was beautiful and selfless, with big doe eyes that seemed to show friendliness to whoever she met. Her lavender dress flattered her figure and her shiny (H/C) hair framed her face in a way that men chased after her everywhere she went. However, her most defining quality was her smarts. She loved to debate and talk politics; if she weren't a girl, Aaron bet she could've become something great. • • • Status: completed, small edits might be made as needed Rankings: 4 in #alexanderhamilton (7/30/19) 7 in #hamilton (9/29/19) 1 in #schuylersisters (9/7/19) 2 in #hamiltonxreader (10/6/19) 3 in #philiphamilton (10/6/19) 1 in #peggyschuyler (3/28/20)

Wasn't Meant To Be : Jamilton [Completed] by ABornAndRaisedWriter

Alexander and Thomas Hamilton and Jefferson Two entirely different people. Enemies... possible lovers? Alexander silently waited by Thomas's locker, arms crossed. It isn't his fault that he and Thomas were paired together for a debate assignment. Mr. Washington probably just wanted to see Alexander suffer. AND, doing this assignment means that it gives Thomas more time to tease him. Alexander's crush on Thomas was probably the most childish thing in the world, but Thomas just teases him about it, and it is the worst thing ever! The older boy even groped him earlier that day! Alexander clicked back into reality as Thomas started to walk towards his locker.

Satisfied || A Hamgelica Fanfic by live_fully

"But when I fantasise at night it's Alexander's eyes, As I romanticise what might have been if I hadn't sized him up so quickly ..." And until then, I will never be satisfied. ::: It was clear from the beginning that Eliza was madly in love with Alexander Hamilton. But what if the story was different? What if Eliza didn't get her happy ending? What if Angelica did? ::: #1 in angelicaschuyler - 15/5/18 *(This is appropriate for all ages)*

You may also like

Slide 1 of 8

When Two Worlds Collide cover

The Colors of Soulmates {Jamilton} ~Completed~ cover

"Over a Book" [MODERN HAMLIZA] cover

Let Me Be a Part of the Narrative cover

She'd Be Lying cover

Forgotten || A Hamilton x Schuyler!Reader Fanfiction || ✔️ cover

Wasn't Meant To Be : Jamilton [Completed] cover

Satisfied || A Hamgelica Fanfic cover

When Two Worlds Collide

Lafayette's a ragtag man, who can't keep his eyes off the Schuyler sister he's been yearning for. And Peggy? Ignored by her sisters, taken as an irresponsible little brat, a shadow of Angelica and Eliza. That was, until Lafayette came and stole her heart. Maybe it was doom... to be caught like this. To soon be broken hearted by the obstacles that lay ahead, and to be head over heels for a poor revolutionary. UPDATE! There may be some Alexander X Laurens action here and there...