Story cover for Shy From The Spotlight - Alexander Hamilton x Reader by ImBaaaack
Shy From The Spotlight - Alexander Hamilton x Reader
ImBaaaack
  • WpView
    Reads 221,610
  • WpVote
    Votes 6,098
  • WpPart
    Parts 128
  • WpHistory
    Time 8h 39m
  • WpView
    Reads 221,610
  • WpVote
    Votes 6,098
  • WpPart
    Parts 128
  • WpHistory
    Time 8h 39m
ImBaaaack
Complete, First published Feb 11, 2021
alexanderhamiltonandpeggyangelicaelizafanficfanfictionforgottenhamiltonhistoricalschuylertexttospeechwattys2022whatifxreader
"But we can't!" Margarita insisted. Angelica faced her little sister, but something caught her eye. "Y/N, come out from the corner." She insisted. You sigh in defeat and step out from the shadows.

<><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>

Your entire life is clouded by three names. Angelica, Eliza, and Peggy. Those three names became famous, while you hid from the spotlight. 

You are noticed by few. You, Y/F/N Schuyler, are the true forgotten sister. You life is filled with damage after a single man enters your eldest two sister's lives. Though he brings damage, he brings you light. He takes notice to you. You quickly grow on him, until he asks for something more. Is he worth your sisters?
All Rights Reserved
alexanderhamiltonandpeggyangelicaelizafanficfanfictionforgottenhamiltonhistoricalschuylertexttospeechwattys2022whatifxreader
Table of contents

128 parts

Sign up to add Shy From The Spotlight - Alexander Hamilton x Reader to your library and receive updates
or
#1hamilton
Content Guidelines
You may also like
Walk On The Wild Side ♡ JEGGY ✓ by xo-charlii
22 parts Complete Mature
❝You're Margarita Schuyler, aren't you?❞ ❝Peggy.❞ I correct. ❝Just Peggy.❞ The freckled face boy tilts his head and smirks at me. ❝Hmm. No.❞ ❝No? You can't just tell me you aren't going to call me by my preferred name.❞ ❝I can, actually.❞ Who does this guy think he is? And, why is he so attractive while he's being a jerk? ♡ John Laurens is angry. Peggy Schuyler is fed up. John is stormy and hot-headed. Peggy is bright and loving. Though her sisters tell her he's bad news, Peggy can't stay away from him. She doesn't want to. She sees something in him no one else does. John absolutely adores Peggy. She's the first person that's ever stuck up for him since his mother died. Peggy is his everything and he'd be damned if anyone tries to take her away from him. No one wants them together, and they're going to find out just how far their friends will go to break them up. John and Peggy made a pact that they'd do anything for each other. The lengths they go to, to protect each other will inevitably be their downfall. While they're both trying to grasp onto something real, they'll end up losing it all in the end. ------------------------------- Contains strong language, drug use, violence, explicit sex scenes, vulgar language, sexual assault, mentions of sex, and rape and death. I'll put trigger warnings at the start of each chapter! But read at your own risk! This is for mature audiences! --------------------- Started - 03/29/21 Published - 4/02/21 Completed - 9/29/21 Rankings: #4 in hamiltonmusical - 8/20/21 #4 in laurens - 6/10/21 #12 in hamliza #3 in andpeggy - 8/10/21 #86 in hamilton - 9/22/21 #2 in johnlaurens - 10/4/21 #4 in jeggy - 10/4/21 #1 in jeggy - 10/17/21 #1 in peggyschuyler - 10/17/21 #2 in hamiltonmusical - 11/22/21 #3 in jeggy - 01/21/22 #1 in jeggy - 07/01/22
A Jeggy story (Soulmates AU)✔️ by fr0zen-y0gurt
30 parts Complete
*THIS BOOK IS NOT EDITED EXPECT A LOT OF GRAMMAR MISTAKES AND CRINGY WRITING* Imagine a world were you have a tattoo of something that means the most to the person you are meant to be with. Peggy Schuyler thought she might never find that person. Till John Laurens showed up. Maybe if they got over all the complications. They could be the perfect couple. That's what soulmates are supposed to be after all. Started: April 27th, 2019 Finished: June 30th, 2019 Best ranking: #1 Jeggy
"Over a Book" [MODERN HAMLIZA] by ellabellaIou
30 parts Complete Mature
COMPLETED Elizabeth Schuyler is a 21yr old woman who lives with her two sisters, 18yr old Peggy Schuyler and 23yr old Angelica Schuyler in a cosy apartment in New York. She works at a nearby coffee shop and frequents a library quite often where she loves to get lost in books. She's known around her small corner of the city for being pretty and kind-hearted. Aside from that, her life isn't abnormal; she graduated with succeeding marks and is now just a not-very-rich girl trying to make a living, whilst putting up with her two sisters that drive her insane. That is, of course, until she met the book boy, who would drag her into more than she had bargained for. ~~~ credits to szin for the book cover drawing & the drawings for each chapter TWs are in each chapter ! #2 in hamliza, 12/11/20 #1 in hamliza, 28/11/20 extra disclaimer: for the purpose of the story, i alter their ages slightly. for example, the sisters historically were only one year apart. here, they are 3&2 years Roughly 93k words!
That Boy is Mine by DannyandAnnie
9 parts Complete
Peggy was never the popular one out of the Schuyler Sisters. Angelica was the perfect one that everyone loved. Eliza was the sweet doll that was always admired by boys. Peggy was... just Peggy. Then, at a ball her father hosts, she meets a soldier named John Laurens. He loves everything about her. The rest is history.
The Past { Slight Jamilton} ~Completed~ by checkers65
22 parts Complete
Before his dad left, Alex and his brother used to be a part of their dad's secret spy agency. He loved that life. Thanks to his dad's wealth, he and his brother had non-human hearing, sight, and strength. They were superhuman. But his dad left when he was 10, and he's in his last year of college now. He missed the thrill. But what if people from his past want him to give up what he has now for the life he loved? yes, this is jamilton (kinda) i think i'll change the title...i dont rlly like it college au soulmate au (when you touch, you see colors) spy au (i got the inspiration for a spy au from @jamsandhams or Ava on instagram but its not totally the same.)
Flowers Amongst the Garden | John Laurens Love Story by solitude_sof
52 parts Complete
~ "Schuyler." The name has formality, grace, elegance, charm and riches... Four daughters. A sassy know-it-all, a kind cinnamon roll, a bittersweet rule-follower and a girl who doesn't even care. All four daughters are unique, different, but similar in different ways. One yearns for something, something no woman or girl has ever thought of wanting. Her freedom. ~ I don't own Hamilton I just own my OCs. All credit goes to Lin Manuel Miranda
marliza/jasippa oneshots by w0nderland_z0
69 parts Complete Mature
MOVED TO (@tay20052005) NO LONGER UPDATING ON THIS ACC
Forgotten || A Hamilton x Schuyler!Reader Fanfiction || ✔️ by saimaa_lima_bean
17 parts Complete
If you thought Peggy was the forgotten sister, you're terribly wrong. • • • Aaron chuckled a bit as he saw (Y/N) running around with the energy everyone expected from her. Just like her older sisters, she was beautiful and selfless, with big doe eyes that seemed to show friendliness to whoever she met. Her lavender dress flattered her figure and her shiny (H/C) hair framed her face in a way that men chased after her everywhere she went. However, her most defining quality was her smarts. She loved to debate and talk politics; if she weren't a girl, Aaron bet she could've become something great. • • • Status: completed, small edits might be made as needed Rankings: 4 in #alexanderhamilton (7/30/19) 7 in #hamilton (9/29/19) 1 in #schuylersisters (9/7/19) 2 in #hamiltonxreader (10/6/19) 3 in #philiphamilton (10/6/19) 1 in #peggyschuyler (3/28/20)
Moving in : A Hamilton Fan - fic by AlivePringles
32 parts Complete
Alexander is the new boy with a dark past. John can't decide who to love. Angelica doesn't want to give her love up. Eliza gets easily manipulated. Peggy has always been forgotten. Maria gets abused. As for Hercules and Lafayette? They have it pretty good. But what happens when all 8 are forced to share a college dorm room? Join them on an emotional journey through love, loss, friendship, and more in this modern telling of Hamilton. *Modern Times* Cover is mine, made from canva!
You may also like
Slide 1 of 9
Walk On The Wild Side ♡ JEGGY ✓ cover
A Jeggy story (Soulmates AU)✔️ cover
"Over a Book" [MODERN HAMLIZA] cover
That Boy is Mine cover
The Past { Slight Jamilton} ~Completed~ cover
Flowers Amongst the Garden | John Laurens Love Story cover
marliza/jasippa oneshots cover
Forgotten || A Hamilton x Schuyler!Reader Fanfiction || ✔️ cover
Moving in : A Hamilton Fan - fic cover

Walk On The Wild Side ♡ JEGGY ✓

22 parts Complete Mature

❝You're Margarita Schuyler, aren't you?❞ ❝Peggy.❞ I correct. ❝Just Peggy.❞ The freckled face boy tilts his head and smirks at me. ❝Hmm. No.❞ ❝No? You can't just tell me you aren't going to call me by my preferred name.❞ ❝I can, actually.❞ Who does this guy think he is? And, why is he so attractive while he's being a jerk? ♡ John Laurens is angry. Peggy Schuyler is fed up. John is stormy and hot-headed. Peggy is bright and loving. Though her sisters tell her he's bad news, Peggy can't stay away from him. She doesn't want to. She sees something in him no one else does. John absolutely adores Peggy. She's the first person that's ever stuck up for him since his mother died. Peggy is his everything and he'd be damned if anyone tries to take her away from him. No one wants them together, and they're going to find out just how far their friends will go to break them up. John and Peggy made a pact that they'd do anything for each other. The lengths they go to, to protect each other will inevitably be their downfall. While they're both trying to grasp onto something real, they'll end up losing it all in the end. ------------------------------- Contains strong language, drug use, violence, explicit sex scenes, vulgar language, sexual assault, mentions of sex, and rape and death. I'll put trigger warnings at the start of each chapter! But read at your own risk! This is for mature audiences! --------------------- Started - 03/29/21 Published - 4/02/21 Completed - 9/29/21 Rankings: #4 in hamiltonmusical - 8/20/21 #4 in laurens - 6/10/21 #12 in hamliza #3 in andpeggy - 8/10/21 #86 in hamilton - 9/22/21 #2 in johnlaurens - 10/4/21 #4 in jeggy - 10/4/21 #1 in jeggy - 10/17/21 #1 in peggyschuyler - 10/17/21 #2 in hamiltonmusical - 11/22/21 #3 in jeggy - 01/21/22 #1 in jeggy - 07/01/22

More details